Caught between inflated bids and incorrect estimates, Pune’s super projects stutter to start

Updated on Nov 27, 2019 04:52 PM IST
The CCI order comes after a complaint was filed by Nagrik Chetna Manch, a city-based non governmental organisation (NGO), on March 3, 2017
24X7 water scheme. Khadakwasla dam(Milind Saurkar/HT Photo)
24X7 water scheme. Khadakwasla dam(Milind Saurkar/HT Photo)
Hindustan Times, Pune | By

PUNE Eighteen months ago when the Competition Commission of India (CCI) imposed a fine on six firms for “bid rigging”, and “collusive bidding”, in a Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC) tender for garbage processing plants, the “civic cartel” nexus at work in the corporation was exposed.

This is the second case of bid rigging in the PMC. The first case involved tenders for thermal composting garbage plants in 2014.

The CCI order comes after a complaint was filed by Nagrik Chetna Manch, a city-based non-governmental organisation (NGO), on March 3, 2017. The NGO alleged that three firms, SAAR IT Resources Private Limited, CADD Systems and Services Private Limited and Pentacle Consultants (I) Private Limited, had rigged a tender floated by the PMC for carrying out geo-enabled tree census in 2015.

In fact, “questionable” bids have been responsible for stalling mega projects, such as the Rs 2,055 crore 24x7 water scheme, Katraj-Kondhwa road (Rs 149 crore), and the Rs 5,192 crore High Capacity Mass Transit Route (HCMTR).

The 36-km long inner ring road promises to improve city’s traffic; however high costs could make it financially unviable, say citizen activists.

In the latest case, the lowest bid that PMC received for HCMTR, also known as the elevated ring road, was 44 per cent higher than the estimated cost of the project. While PMC has not officially opened the tenders, the Nagrik Kriti Samiti (NKS), or peoples’ action committee has sought cancellation of the project citing lack of financial feasibility. While bids haven’t been opened as yet, the PMC has not rejected the NKS claim, and that of opposition leaders, that the bid is inflated.

“Significant discrepancy in the estimated project cost and the bid quotation raises questions regarding financial feasibility of the projects and merits a re-evaluation of the costing by third party. The lowest bid for the HCMTR tender was Rs 7,535 crore, 44 per cent higher than the estimated project cost of Rs 5,192 crore,” said NKS in a recent press statement.

This isn’t the first instance PMC has received a bid higher than the estimated project cost. Two years ago, for the 3.5 km Katraj-Kondhwa road stretch, PMC had to invite tenders thrice and finally approved a tender of Rs 149 crore, the fourth time. This was, however, still higher than original proposal estimate of Rs 120 crore. The first tender the civic body had received was of Rs 215 crore, much higher than estimated cost, forcing a retendering.

In February 2018, PMC approved 24x7 scheme after standing committee of the PMC gave its nod to the project and allotted the work to Larson &Tourbo and Jain Irrigation Company. Earlier the project’s estimated cost was Rs 2,600 crore and tenders were 26 per cent higher, which could have increased the project cost to Rs 3,100 crore.

After opposition from various political parties, then chief minister Devendra Fadnavis intervened in the matter and ordered the scrapping of the process. Fadnavis had asked for a re-tendering of the project following which the project cost came down to Rs 2,055 crore, Rs 1,100 crore less than the estimate.

Civic official explains inflated tenders

Rubal Agarwal, additional commissioner, maintained that PMC is taking efforts to maintain transparency, while adding that higher inflated bids may have been the result of “another website through which bids were filed”.

“Earlier the tenders in PMC were being filed through a private website which was run by a contractor for free. Later, we found that the contractor was charging Rs 100-200 per tender. It was not transparent and accessible to all which is why from September 1, we decided to use the state government website,,” she said.

According to Agarwal, the website is transparent and the time limit cannot be extended, unless the PMC decides so. “Maybe the earlier tenders that came through the private website were quoting inflated charges but we are taking steps to make the tendering process more transparent and accessible in the public domain too,” she said.

Consultants responsible for inflated bids: Congress

According to senior Congress leader Arvind Shinde, bids with higher than estimated costs are often justified by the consultants appointed by the civic body and consultants are appointed as per the convenience of the contractors.

“It is true that this has become a trend that the contractors often quote a higher amount and then the tenders are re-invited leading to delay or accepting the new quotation. The consultants work to support the contractors instead of working for the Civic body. There have been contractors who quote about 50-60 per cent more than the estimated cost and the tenders have been approved. The civic body has no money and the ruling party has failed to bring in any money from the State government in the past five years,” said Shinde.

Activists question consultants, contractors

Vijay Kumbhar, a right to information (RTI) activist, said the approach of the PMC is wrong, when appointing contractors and consultants. “Why do we need consultant? At present consultant is the one who also gives a loan for the project. These companies are pre-selected and this is a new way of blackmail or rather corporatisation of corruption,” said Kumbhar.

It was Kumbhar who had raised questions about river rejuvenation project and demanded the tender process be carried out afresh, while raising questions about a consultant appointed for Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) and the inflated proposals by bidders in Mula-Mutha river rejuvenation project being jointly implemented by PMC and Jica.

“This is a classic case where the Jica’s association with consultant firm and PMC officials was established, making it fit case for retendering,” said Kumbhar.

SCN Jatar, president of Nagrik Chetana Manch, had also pointed out how 24x7 water scheme, that promises equitable supply across the city, bid was first of higher cost. Initial tender for 24x7 water scheme was of inflated price than estimated one following which opposition forced ruling BJP to go for re-bidding. It was Jatar who pursued bid rigging scam in PMC, which resulted in CCI imposing a fine of Rs 3.57 crore on six firms.

Ruling party aware of problems, safeguarding PMC

Shrinath Bhimale, BJP, and leader of the house in PMC, sayd, “It is true that due to various reasons the main projects are getting delayed. Along with the tendering process, land acquisition and errors in estimates are the reasons for this. JICA (river rejuvenation) and High Capacity Mass Transport tenders are above the estimate cost. PMC is taking care that the civic body does not bear the additional burden. PMC has asked the Central government’s suggestion on the JICA project and on the 24x7 water project, work is in progress.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The Karnataka high court.

    Married daughters also entitled for insurance compensation on parents' death: HC

    The Karnataka High Court has held that married daughters are entitled for compensation by insurance companies on the loss of their parents in accidents. The HC single judge bench of Justice H P Sandesh heard an appeal filed by an insurance company challenging the award of compensation to married daughters of one Renuka (aged 57) who was killed in an accident on April 12, 2012 near Yamanur, Hubballi, in north Karnataka.

  • DCW chairperson Swati Maliwal sought a copy of the first information report (FIR), details of the accused person arrested or absconding and steps taken to apprehend the accused. (Mohd Zakir/HT File Photo)

    Submit report by 14 August, DCW orders Delhi police on rape of 3 school girls

    The Delhi Commission for Women on Thursday asked the city police to submit a complete report by August 14 on the action taken on a rape complaint by three girls studying in a Delhi government school. The commission also asked police to confirm that the three minor girls were produced before the child welfare committee as required by law, and a copy of the order issued by the committee.

  • Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar and speaker Vijay Kumar Sinha. (PTI)

    No-confidence motion against speaker delayed Bihar assembly session

    In the first Cabinet meeting after taking oath on Wednesday, chief minister Nitish Kumar and his deputy, Tejashwi Yadav, decided to convene the Bihar assembly session on August 24 to seek trust vote. The session was delayed as speaker Vijay Kumar Sinha refused to quit and promoted ruling alliance to move a no-confidence motion. Former speaker Vijay Kumar Choudhary said it will be taken first on the day the House convenes.

  • A man's leg accidentally touched others in the procession, who took objection because of which the argument started. (HT File)

    Two men stabbed in Gadag during Muharram procession: Report

    Two young men were stabbed during a Muharram procession at the Mallasamudra village in Karnataka's Gadag on Tuesday, according to reports. The injured have been identified as Tousif Hosamani and Mushtaq Hosamani. One of the two young men is battling for his life. Both are being treated at the Gadag Institute of Medical Sciences Hospital. Police have registered a case against six men in the incident.

  • CFI was active amid the controversy surrounding the hijab ban. (Image credit: Imran Khan/Twitter)

    Campus Front of India opposes 'Bharat Mata Pooja' in Mangaluru varsity

    The Campus Front of India has objected to a 'Bharat Mata pooja' scheduled to be held today at a university in Mangaluru - one of the areas at the heart of the hijab ban in Karnataka - and wanted to know why the university had allowed a pooja with a poster holding up a saffron flag instead of the tricolour, news agency PTI reported.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now