All doctors put in one category due to war-like situation during Covid-19 pandemic: HC

Updated on Jun 03, 2021 08:57 AM IST
A bench of Chief Justice D N Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh said that the May 16 notification issued by the Delhi government was a "temporary in nature" and based "purely upon public need and looking at the grave exigencies" prevailing in the city due to Covid-19 pandemic.
The bench said at that time there was a call for duty by all teaching and non-teaching doctors as well as medical students and thus, the May 16 order was "absolutely just and fair".(Representational Image / PTI)
The bench said at that time there was a call for duty by all teaching and non-teaching doctors as well as medical students and thus, the May 16 order was "absolutely just and fair".(Representational Image / PTI)
PTI | , New Delhi

The Delhi High Court on Wednesday dismissed with costs of 5,000 a plea challenging the Delhi government's decision to put doctors of varying seniority and departments in one category for Covid management duties, saying the step was taken in view of the "war-like situation" at the time.

A bench of Chief Justice D N Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh said that the May 16 notification issued by the Delhi government was a "temporary in nature" and based "purely upon public need and looking at the grave exigencies" prevailing in the city due to Covid-19 pandemic.

"It was a war like situation when the impugned order was passed," the bench added.

It said at that time there was a call for duty by all teaching and non-teaching doctors as well as medical students and thus, the May 16 order was "absolutely just and fair".

"There is all power, jurisdiction and authority with the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (GNCTD) to issue an order, like that of May 16, in view of the grave exigencies in the city.

"There was no want of jurisdiction on the part of GNCTD when it issued the impugned order," the bench said and added "we see no reasons to interfere with the Covid-19 management by GNCTD".

The court also said that the present plea was not in public interest by any stretch of the imagination and it appeared that the petitioner doctor "wants exemption from Covid-19 duties" which cannot be given "irrespective of the speciality or branch of medicine".

On this aspect, the petitioner's lawyer -- Payal Bahl -- said her client was not seeking any exemption from Covid duties.

Delhi government additional standing counsel Anuj Aggarwal clarified that the May 16 order/notification did not change anyone's seniority or hierarchy and was issued only for better management of manpower for Covid-19 duties.

The petitioner had challenged the order on the ground that it was issued without concurrence of the Lt Governor as was required under the GNCTD Amendment Act which came into force from April 27 onwards.

The bench said that in peculiar facts of the present case and the temporary nature of the notification which was issued in view of the public need and grave exigencies prevailing at the time, the order did not violate any provisions of the GNCTD Amendment Act.

Later in the day, the same issue -- challenge to the notification -- was raised before a single judge by an association representing medical officers in the city.

Justice Rekha Palli informed the association's lawyer that a similar plea has been dismissed earlier in the day by a division bench.

However, the lawyer sought time to go through the division bench order and the court listed it for hearing on June 4.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • College of Agricultural Engineering and Technology of PAU, Ludhiana, offers the Btech Agricultural Engineering with admission capacity of 82 seats besides masters and doctoral programmes. (HT FILE)

    Ludhiana | PAU opens admission for 4-yr Btech Agricultural Engineering course

    For the academic year 2022-23, Punjab Agricultural University has announced the dates for admission to four-year BTech Agricultural Engineering degree programme, run by the College of Agricultural Engineering and Technology. Director extension education and dean, Ashok Kumar, College of Agricultural Engineering further informed that the interested students may follow the given link for counselling— https://ptu.admissions.nic.in/link/registration-for-btech-102-basis-1st-year-course-1st-round/— and further details can also be accessed from the PAU website. The college offers the programme with admission capacity of 82 seats besides masters and doctoral programmes.

  • Maharashtra Natural Gas Limited (MNGL), has reduced the selling price of domestic Piped Natural Gas (PNG) by <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>2 per standard cubic meter (SCM) (REPRESENTATIVE IMAGE)

    Price of domestic PNG reduced by 2 from August 18 in Pune

    Pune-based city gas distribution (CGD) company, Maharashtra Natural Gas Limited, has reduced the selling price of domestic Piped Natural Gas (PNG) by ₹2 per standard cubic meter in Pune city including Pimpri-Chinchwad and adjoining areas of Chakan, Talegaon and Hinjewadi with effect from Thursday. Accordingly, MNGL has reduced retail price of PNG to ₹49.50 per standard cubic meter from an earlier price of ₹ 51.50/- per SCM.

  • While the mohalla clinic at Transport Nagar had 35 patients, Metro Road drew in 56, Chand Cinema 166, Kadwai Nagar 66, Focal Point 23, Dhandari Kalan 86, Raikot 40, Jagraon 80 and 72 patients visited the clinic at Khanna, Ludhiana. (HT FILE)

    Mohalla clinics in Ludhiana witness 43% rise in patient footfall on second day

    The Aam Aadmi Clinics also referred to as mohalla clinics witnessed a 43% rise in the number of patients on their second day. While the mohalla clinic at Transport Nagar had 35 patients, Metro Road drew in 56, Chand Cinema 166, Kadwai Nagar 66, Focal Point 23, Dhandari Kalan 86, Raikot 40, Jagraon 80 and 72 patients visited the clinic at Khanna.

  • Municipal town planner Rajnish Wadhwa said around 12 lakh population has been covered and 67 per cent of the delimitation survey had been completed and the Ludhiana MC teams were working in the field to cover the remaining population (HT FILE)

    Ludhiana | Delimitation survey 67% complete, local bodies dept directs MC to speed up

    At a time when different political parties are pulling up socks for the upcoming municipal elections, the municipal corporation has completed 67 per cent of the delimitation survey in the city. Though the local bodies department had, in its letter dated June 1, directed the MC to complete the survey within a week, the officials said since the population survey still had to be conducted in the city, the delimitation survey was not yet completed.

  • Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde on Wednesday ordered a probe by the state police’s Crime Investigation Department (CID) into the death of former MLC and prominent Maratha quota leader Vinayak Mete in a road accident (HT FILE PHOTO)

    CID to probe ex-MLC Vinayak Mete’s death in road accident

    Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde on Wednesday ordered a probe by the state police's Crime Investigation Department into the death of former MLC and prominent Maratha quota leader Vinayak Mete in a road accident, said an official. Mete (52), who headed the Maratha outfit Shiv Sangram Sanghatna, was killed after a vehicle hit his car on the Mumbai-Pune Expressway on Sunday last.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, August 17, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now