Pollution monitors in Delhi may not be showing the full picture on air quality

Hindustan Times spot check finds differences in air pollution data, experts say reasons range from height of pollution monitoring device to distance from a spot.
The air pollution level at the busy Anand Vihar road side on Tuesday. The DPCC monitor read 175 in Anand Vihar. The station is at a higher level so it catches pollutants from all three major sources — railway station, bus terminus and road side.(Raj K Raj/Hindustan Times)
The air pollution level at the busy Anand Vihar road side on Tuesday. The DPCC monitor read 175 in Anand Vihar. The station is at a higher level so it catches pollutants from all three major sources — railway station, bus terminus and road side.(Raj K Raj/Hindustan Times)
Updated on Feb 13, 2017 10:45 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, New Delhi | By, New Delhi

Talk about bad air quality in Delhi and the apocalyptic readings of east Delhi’s Anand Vihar – a transport hub and arguably one of Delhi’s most polluted and congested spots — pop up.

But Delhi’s pollution map is much more than this choked corner.

When a 2015 study said Delhi’s air is consistently more toxic than that in Beijing, SAFAR (System of Air Quality and Weather Forecasting and Research) chief Gufran Beig disputed the finding. He said comparing pollution levels of south Delhi’s RK Puram with the US embassy in Beijing was not correct because of a huge geographical difference between the two locations.

“The US embassy is outside the polluted zone of Beijing and has a lush green area on one side and a big water body on the other, both contributing to pollution sequestration. RK Puram is in the middle of Delhi and is next to the congested Ring Road without any sequestration zones,” he had said.

HT visited seven places in Delhi, where air quality is monitored, with a mobile machine to check if the location had any impact on measuring pollution levels.

Stations at RK Puram and Mandir Marg are in green zones, some distance away from emission emitting vehicles. But a few such as those at ITO and Siri Fort are close to the road, and would naturally show higher pollution.

The perennially polluted Anand Vihar on the Delhi-UP border is located between a tri-junction of a railway station, bus terminus and a Metro station. The station at the busy Punjabi Bagh is in the middle of a bungalow-dominated neighbourhood.

We found a difference in the official pollution levels and HT’s measurement (see GRAPHIC). Most experts HT spoke were not surprised. They said it could be because the technology used in the HT machine may be different from the official monitoring stations. It also depends how close to the air pollution the air was measured.

The reasons behind the difference in data was different for the sites. At RK Puram, we caught peak traffic hour whereas DPCC data did not record spurt in congestion, while at Siri Fort, the reason might be higher traffic and our monitor being at a lower level than CPCB station.

At ITO, the CPCB monitor is inside INSA – few metres away from the main congestion point, whereas we were close to the source while at Anand Vihar, the DPCC monitor is at a higher level thereby catching pollutants from all three major sources — railway station, bus terminus and Chaudhari Charan Singh Marg. At Mandir Marg, there was marginal difference which might be because of different calibrations of HT and DPCC monitor, while at Punjabi Bagh, we caught pollution levels with higher traffic flow than the DPCC monitor.

So why were these locations selected?

In Delhi, SAFAR set up an integrated air quality monitoring system along with automatic weather stations at 10 “different strategic locations within NCR”.

“The 10 locations were purposefully selected so as to represent all kinds of localities in the NCT… As per international guidelines, the correct way to know one index for a city air quality is to consider different microenvironments… For a typical metro city, commercial; urban complex; sub-urban; residential; industrial; road side; traffic junction are the microenvironments which should be covered in the monitoring network,” a World Meteorological Organisation report says, adding that the SAFAR network met all micro-environment parameters.

Apart from SAFAR, air quality in Delhi is monitored by the Central Pollution Control Board and the Delhi Pollution Control Committee. The three agencies collect air quality data at 28 locations, maximum for any city in India, but do not have a uniform mechanism to disseminate information on a real-time basis.

The CPCB is preparing fresh guidelines on the placement of these monitoring stations, said Dr Dipankar Saha, additional director and head of the Air Laboratory at the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB).

“The height of these monitoring points should be changed. Uniform height is not the way forward. All stations should have different monitoring heights to get well-mixed, representative data,” he explained.

A DPCC official said there was no ideal location in a metro city like Delhi for a monitoring station.

“In Delhi, we have monitoring two hotspots -- one on the airport runway to ascertain the aviation impact, and Anand Vihar to see the impact of other states and vehicular pollution. In other stations, we measure ambient air quality,” he said.

The DPCC will add 20 more stations to cover other micro-environment zones to provide a realistic picture of Delhi’s air quality. These will be evenly distributed between industrial, commercial and residential areas and even hospitals.

“Pollution is definitely bad but not as bad as it has been made out to be. The air quality may be very poor for instance at busy intersections like ITO crossing but that doesn’t mean it will be same in Chanakyapuri or Narela in outer Delhi,” DPCC senior scientist MP George said.

“In an unplanned city like Delhi, you can’t get optimised stations. Nothing will be enough. But when the number of stations increase, you will get better representative values,” he added.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Ritam Halder has been a journalist for nearly a decade and has worked in multiple roles across organisations. He has been a features writer, a digital journalist as well as a desk hand. He now covers environment, water and urban issues in Delhi.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Protesters raise slogans demanding the release of Yasin Malik during a protest outside separatist leader in Srinagar’s Maisuma on Wednesday. (Waseem Andrabi Hindustan Times)

    Protests erupt in Srinagar’s Maisuma

    Clashes erupted between supporters of Yasin Malik and security forces in Srinagar on Wednesday after a Delhi court sentenced the Kashmiri separatist leader to life imprisonment in a 2017 terror funding case. Protests against the court's verdict erupted in Maisuma – Malik's native place, a short distance from Lal Chowk – as his supporters and relatives arrived at his house and shouted slogans demanding his release.

  • In the new team, the Shimla district, particularly Rohru and Jubbal and Kotkhai assembly segments, has got more share than the other 66 assembly segments. (Image for representational purpose)

    Himachal: Pratibha, Vikramaditya get bigger roles in PCC expansion

    In the new team, the Shimla district, particularly Rohru and Jubbal and Kotkhai assembly segments, has got more share than the other 66 assembly segments. Of the 41 newly appointed secretaries, seven are from the Rohru assembly segment and they all owe allegiance to Mandi Lok Sabha member Pratibha Singh and her legislator son Vikramaditya Singh, while of the 13 general secretaries, five are from Shimla district alone. Former councillor Mahender Chauhan has also been appointed as vice-president.

  • The Delhi high court said it will hear further arguments on the bail plea of Umar Khalid on May 30. (PTI Photo/Shashank Parade)

    Can’t hold mini trial during bail plea: HC to Umar Khalid

    A bench of justices Siddharth Mridul and Rajnish Bhatnagar on Wednesday said that it will not hold a “mini-trial”, and look into the evidence and the statements without testing the authenticity of the material. “In so far as UAPA is concerned, we have to look at the material on the record without testing the veracity... You can’t say if the statement says three of them (accused) met, then we should test it by holding a mini-trial,” the bench said.

  • After achieving the first position in administering first and second doses of Covid vaccine in Himachal, the tribal districts of Kinnaur and Lahaul-Spiti have again taken a lead in giving the booster dose to the eligible population in the state even as all other districts lag way behind. (Image for representational purpose)

    Himachal’s tribal districts take lead in booster dose vaccination

    In the other tribal district of Lahaul-Spiti, 64% eligible population has been administered the precautionary dose . Chamba has achieved 34% coverage and Kullu around 37%. In Himachal, more than 8 lakh people were eligible for the booster shot as on May 24. Since the launch of the booster dose drive in January, 3, 15,734 precautionary doses have been administered in the state which is 40% of eligible population.

  • For now, the evening driving test facility will be available at the automated driving test tracks (ADTTs) in Shakurbasti, Mayur Vihar and Vishwas Nagar. (HT Archive)

    Delhi: Evening driving tests at 3 tracks in city

    For now, the evening driving test facility will be available at the automated driving test tracks (ADTTs) in Shakurbasti, Mayur Vihar and Vishwas Nagar. The night driving test will be held in slots between 5pm and 7pm and 45 appointments will be available daily at each of the three tracks.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, May 26, 2022