Sign in

CBI files chargesheet against four police officials in school murder case

An 80-odd page chargesheet was filed before Aman Inder Singh, special judicial magistrate of Punjab and Haryana high court, on Wednesday. The agency gave a clean chit to the private school.

Updated on: Jan 8, 2021, 01:43:37 IST
Hindustan Times, Gurugram | By , Gurugram
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
Copy link
  • copy link

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) filed a supplementary chargesheet against four Gurugram police officers for falsely implicating a school bus conductor and for fabricating documents against him in the 2017 school murder case.

The bus conductor was the initial suspect in the murder of an eight-year-old student of a private school in Bhondsi. (Hindustan Times)
The bus conductor was the initial suspect in the murder of an eight-year-old student of a private school in Bhondsi. (Hindustan Times)

An 80-odd page chargesheet was filed before Aman Inder Singh, special judicial magistrate of Punjab and Haryana high court, on Wednesday. The agency gave a clean chit to the private school.

The probe agency, which had named a juvenile as the main accused in the case and filed a chargesheet in February 2018, said in the supplementary chargesheet that “there is sufficient evidence for prosecution” against four police officials who allegedly implicated the bus conductor and accused him of murder and sexual assault.

Birem Singh, assistant commissioner of police, Narender Khatana, then station house officer of Bhondsi police station, Shamsher Singh, sub-inspector and the investigating officer for two days, and Subhash Chand, EASI, are the four officials named.

Khatana refused to comment on the matter, while the three other officials could not be reached for comment.

Sushil Tekriwal, counsel for the father of the victim, said that the police had forced Kumar to confess and had fabricated the documents in the case. “Police officers have made fake daily diary (DD) entries. They had prepared the first document of the case in the mortuary on September 8, 2017, where they had shown Ashok Kumar as a suspect without a complaint and a case was registered. They knew since day one there was no sexual assault. Still, they forced him to accept that he had attempted to sexually assault the victim,” he said.

Tekriwal alleged that the investigating officer had prepared the documents without visiting the crime spot. “They had tried to give a clean chit to the juvenile and recorded his statement before the Sohna court on September 15 as a witness under Section 164 CrPc without verifying his friend’s statement. Even the gardener had informed the police that the juvenile had informed him during the incident, but no one questioned him. Police had also tried to create pressure on the physical education teacher to record his statement in favour of juvenile, which he had denied,” he said.

The bus conductor was the initial suspect in the murder of an eight-year-old student of a private school in Bhondsi. He had accused the police of assassinating his character and for torturing him. He was arrested on September 8, 2017, but was acquitted by a special court on February 28, 2018.

Kumar alleged that he was tortured, beaten, hung upside down and his head submerged in water by police officials to obtain a confession. “I was asked to parade before the media and they humiliated me in front of my family and public. Since then, I have had sleepless nights and I am still trying to regain my lost self-esteem and reputation,” he said.

The father of the deceased, who is the complainant in the case, said that the CBI has delayed filing supplementary chargesheet and they are yet to get justice. “The police officials are also equally guilty as they tried to mislead us and tried to implicate an innocent man instead of the real culprit. Those guilty should be punished as per the law. Such incidents tarnish the image and lose trust in police,” he said.

The court has fixed January 15 for consideration of the chargesheet.

The father of the 18-year-old suspect, who was a juvenile at the time of the incident, had filed an application on January 3 with juvenile justice board (JJB) seeking interim bail for his son so that he could take his class 12 examinations between January 21 and February 15. The father had also stated that since his examination centre was in Nuh, an interim bail was necessary.

The hearing of the application is listed for Friday.

The court has dismissed a bail plea at least 15 times over the last 37 months. In May 2019, he was shifted from an observation home in Faridabad to a place of safety in Madhuban, Karnal.

  • Leena Dhankhar
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Leena Dhankhar

    Leena Dhankhar is Senior Editor and Bureau Chief, Gurugram, at Hindustan Times, where she has spent over 17 years chronicling the transformation of one of India's fastest-growing urban regions. From starting her career as a crime reporter to leading the Gurugram bureau, her journalism has been defined by investigative reporting, in-depth storytelling and an unwavering focus on public interest. Over nearly two decades, she has reported extensively across crime, politics, civic governance, elections, real estate, environment, courts, sports, education and entertainment, covering Gurugram, Faridabad, Nuh and Palwal. Her reporting has exposed several major scams and systemic failures, including insurance frauds, waste management irregularities, illegal arms manufacturing units in Nuh, illegal mining in the Aravallis, organised crime networks and governance lapses affecting millions of residents. Known for her investigative work and exclusive stories, Leena has reported on high-impact national issues, including the Nicaragua charter flight carrying Indian migrants that was turned back amid allegations of human trafficking, exposing the growing network of illegal immigration rackets. Her work has also focused on gang wars, prison administration, juvenile crime, women and child protection systems, the functioning of the Juvenile Justice Board and Child Welfare Committee, and environmental challenges such as pollution, waterlogging and deteriorating civic infrastructure. Beyond hard news, Leena has extensively documented Haryana's rich heritage, forests and wildlife, bringing attention to the state's historical landmarks, biodiversity, conservation efforts and ecological challenges through immersive reportage and feature writing. Her journalism has consistently gone beyond breaking news. She has documented Gurugram's rapid urbanisation through long-form narratives and enterprise reporting on issues ranging from pothole-ridden roads, flooding and waste management to the changing social fabric of India's Millennium City. She also writes widely read feature columns, including The Outsider, Changemaker, and Concern for Gurugram, profiling people, places and ideas shaping the city's identity. Leena is the author of Gurugram School Murder, published by Juggernaut Books, a deeply reported account of one of India's most high-profile school murder investigations. She is currently working on her second book, an investigative work exploring some of India's most significant scams and fraud investigations. Beyond print journalism, she has expanded her storytelling through public speaking and digital media. She is a TEDx speaker and has produced podcasts exploring Gurugram's transformation, civic challenges and untold stories. Her work reflects a commitment to narrative journalism that combines rigorous reporting with compelling storytelling. A law graduate with an MBA in Human Resources, Leena brings a multidisciplinary perspective to her reporting, particularly on governance, public policy and legal affairs. She has travelled extensively across India to pursue investigative assignments, often reporting from remote locations and conflict-prone areas in search of stories that matter.Read More