Chris Pine, Henry Cavill and Mark Wahlberg have all been involved in contract disputes.
Chris Pine, Henry Cavill and Mark Wahlberg have all been involved in contract disputes.

Henry Cavill quitting Superman is nothing but an ugly negotiation tactic, and it has happened before

What you’re seeing play out in public – the curiously timed reports of Henry Cavill’s dismissal as Superman – is nothing but an ugly negotiating tactic. And it has precedent.
By Rohan Naahar | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON SEP 15, 2018 11:52 AM IST

The Hollywood Reporter said this week that Henry Cavill was most likely being dropped as Superman in Warner Bros’ ‘evolving’ (and rapidly unraveling) DC Extended Universe. The actor quickly responded with a cryptic Instagram video – which, if anything, only made things worse – and Warners was quick to ‘clarify’ that no firm decisions had been made.

But pay closer attention to their statement and two things will pop out. One, they’ve very conveniently avoided an outright denial (or confirmation) of that THR story. And two, they’ve emphasised – a little too enthusiastically – that they (continue to) have a great working relationship with Cavill.

But that’s not what several journalists are reporting. According to multiple people with inside information on the matter, the blame – just like it was during the moustachegate kerfuffle – can safely be directed towards Mission: Impossible – Fallout. But this time, instead of one studio playing the ultimate power move and forcing another to spend millions of dollars on digitally erasing the moustache Cavill had grown – and was contractually obligated to keep – while filming the sixth Mission Impossible film, Cavill believed his supporting role in the movie had somehow made him an A-list star.

It hadn’t. But with The Rock’s ex-wife (and the mother of his child), Dany Garcia, by his side in a managerial capacity, Cavill believed he could engage Warner Bros – the studio that picked him out of relative obscurity and made him Superman – in a game of chicken.

Because what you’re seeing play out in public – the curiously timed reports of Cavill’s dismissal and the enigmatic statements subsequently made by both parties – is nothing but an ugly negotiating tactic.

The THR story reported that the problem began when Cavill blamed ‘scheduling conflicts’ for his refusal to film a cameo appearance in DC’s upcoming Shazam! movie. Cavill reportedly still has one film left in his DC contract, and the cameo would have counted. Both ScreenRant and Beyond the Trailer report that the reason Cavill was holding out was because he felt that he was owed more money now that his star had risen. The strategy worked well for Gal Gadot, who not only negotiated a hefty pay-rise for Wonder Woman 1984, but also scored a producer credit.

It’s one thing for an actor to demand fair compensation, but Cavill is yet to deliver a solo hit. All three of his DC movies are commonly categorised as having ‘underperformed’ – which is the modern blockbuster code for ‘films that flopped theatrically but will turn a profit in the long run’. And only one of his non-DC movies is a bonafide hit – the aforementioned Mission Impossible 6.

As his next move, Cavill signed onto the Netflix fantasy series, The Witcher – which is a good (but crucially not great) plan B – perhaps to send the message that he was already moving on. And shortly after The Witcher was announced, THR broke the news of his dismissal. Again, it has been reported online that the story was ‘leaked’ by Warners as an arm-twisting maneuver, but who knows?

What we do know is that situations such as this have precedent. There’s no telling how this might end up, but as these five examples show, Cavill has little option but to lower his asking price.

Terrence Howard – Iron Man

In one of the rare examples of roles being recast in the Marvel Cinematic Universe – remarkable especially considering the sheer number of actors and schedules they have to juggle – Terrence Howard was removed as War Machine for Iron Man 2. And Howard – whose history of domestic abuse hardly makes him the victim in this situation – has publicly blamed Robert Downey Jr for his ouster.

“It turns out that the person I helped become Iron Man … when it was time to re-up for the second one took the money that was supposed to go to me and pushed me out,” Howard said. The role was subsequently recast with Don Cheadle. “It was going to be a certain amount for the first film, a certain amount for the second, a certain amount for the third,” Howard continued. “They came to me with the second and said, ‘Look we will pay you 1/8th of what we contractually had for you because we think the second one will be successful with or without you.’”

Howard added: “I called my friend that I helped get the first job and he didn’t call me back for three months.”

Chris Pine and Chris Hemsworth – Star Trek 4

It was recently reported that Paramount’s talks with both Chris Pine and Chris Hemsworth had broken down because they were asking a higher price to reprise their roles as James T Kirk and his father in the fourth Star Trek film. Hemsworth played a cameo in the 2009 reboot, before he became a household name thanks to the Marvel movies. The plot for the fourth film is rumoured to involve a time travel element, what with Captain Kirk’s father being dead and all.

While neither Chris is a part of the Hollywood A-list, they’re certainly bigger stars than Cavill. And they know it, because even though Paramount wants to keep the budget for the new Star Trek in check, especially after the third one became the lowest-grossing of the reboot series, the actors are still holding out. Pine recently said that talks were ongoing and that he hopes to arrive at an understanding, but with the series’ flexible timeline and the option of another Trek movie (this one being written by Quentin Tarantino) available, the ball is firmly in the Chrises’ court.

The cast of Modern Family

In 2012, five lead actors of the hit sitcom Modern Family, excluding Ed O’Neill - Sofia Vergara, Ty Burrell, Julie Bowen, Jesse Tyler Ferguson and Eric Stonestreet – asked a judge to rule their contracts illegal, claiming that they were being underpaid and that the contracts restricted them from taking on other work.

The actors at the time were being paid between $60,000 and $65,000 per episode, according to Variety, and were asking for at least $300,000 per episode were the show to last more than eight seasons, which it has. The same actors are now getting paid in the vicinity of $500,000 per episode.

The cast of Friends

In another example of TV actors successfully renegotiating their contracts, the main cast of Friends successfully convinced NBC to pay them a then-unheard of $1 million per episode. Mirroring everyone’s disbelief, co-creator Marta Kaufmann at the time said, “A million dollars an episode is kinda ridiculous. Let’s be honest, that’s a lot of money.”

But they had two crucial points going in their favour: Friends was one of the highest watched shows in the history of TV and ever since the third season, they’d been negotiating their deals collectively. These days only one sitcom can afford to pay its cast a million dollars per episode and that’s The Big Bang Theory.

Mark Wahlberg

Obviously, not all backroom contract negotiations are reported in the press. Johnny Depp continues to strike lucrative deals at Disney to keep doing the Pirate of the Caribbean movies – although, a point can be made that considering the recent disintegration of his career and his reputation, he needs them more than they need him.

But when Mark Wahlberg asked for $1.5 million to film nine days of reshoots for Ridley Scott’s All the Money in the World, he’d never have expected his fine business acumen to blow up in his face. Weeks later, just ahead of the Oscars, it was reported that his co-star Michelle Williams made only $80 a day for doing exactly the same work. And the cultural climate couldn’t have been worse: The Me Too movement was at its peak and stars such as Jessica Chastain and Jennifer Lawrence had been campaigning vocally for equal pay. To his credit, Wahlberg donated the entire $1.5 million to the Time’s Up campaign in Williams’ name.

Follow @htshowbiz for more
The author tweets @RohanNaahar

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Justin Timberlake is reportedly trying to mend his relationship Jessica Biel.
Justin Timberlake is reportedly trying to mend his relationship Jessica Biel.

Justin Timberlake announces birth of second son with Jessica Biel, reveals name

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 01:38 PM IST
  • Celebrity couple Justin Timberlake and Jessica Biel have welcomed their second child, a year after he publicly apologised for inappropriate behaviour amid cheating rumours.
Close
Priyanka Chopra and Adarsh Gourav in The White Tiger.
Priyanka Chopra and Adarsh Gourav in The White Tiger.

Priyanka Chopra drops Divine's banging original song from White Tiger. Listen

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 09:02 PM IST
  • Priyanka Chopra has shared Jungle Mantra, an original song from the White Tiger soundtrack, by Divine, featuring Vince Staples and Pusha T. Listen here.
Close
Ray Fisher played Cyborg in Justice League.
Ray Fisher played Cyborg in Justice League.

Ray Fisher confirms he's been removed from Flash movie, amid standoff with WB

UPDATED ON JAN 15, 2021 04:04 PM IST
  • Actor Ray Fisher has released a lengthy statement confirming his removal from the upcoming Flash movie, amid his standoff with Warner Bros.
Close
Riz Ahmed has talked about his wife for the first time.
Riz Ahmed has talked about his wife for the first time.

Riz Ahmed reveals his 'secret' wedding details along with wife's name

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 03:35 PM IST
Riz Ahmed has talked about his wife for the first time, how they got married during the pandemic and more.
Close
Chris Evans played Captain America in multiple MCU movies.
Chris Evans played Captain America in multiple MCU movies.

Chris Evans denies being in talks with Marvel to return as Captain America

PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 11:16 AM IST
As per fresh reports, Chris Evans is reportedly in talks to return to the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Captain America. The actor, however, has denied the rumours.
Close
Armie Hammer and Elizabeth Chambers have two kids together.
Armie Hammer and Elizabeth Chambers have two kids together.

Armie Hammer breaks silence on DMs scandal, says he's quit his upcoming film

PUBLISHED ON JAN 14, 2021 09:29 PM IST
  • Actor Armie Hammer announced that he is quitting his upcoming film, amid a scandal around messages that he allegedly sent a woman.
Close
Patralekhaa reminisced about Rajkummar Rao's journey from Gurugram to New York.
Patralekhaa reminisced about Rajkummar Rao's journey from Gurugram to New York.

Patralekhaa spots The White Tiger hoarding in NYC, gives shout-out to Rajkummar

PUBLISHED ON JAN 14, 2021 07:57 PM IST
  • Patralekhaa spotted Rajkummar Rao on a hoarding of The White Tiger in New York and shared a picture on Instagram stories. She reminisced about his incredible journey, from Gurugram to New York.
Close
One Night in Miami movie review: Debutante director Regina King assembles an astonishingly excellent cast.
One Night in Miami movie review: Debutante director Regina King assembles an astonishingly excellent cast.

One Night in Miami review: Blistering film traps four Black icons in motel room

UPDATED ON JAN 14, 2021 07:51 PM IST
  • One Night in Miami movie review: Debutante director Regina King extracts terrific performances from her four leading men, in a high-concept drama about power and responsibility.
Close
Ali Fazal and Russell Brand will be seen in Kenneth Branagh's Death on the Nile together.
Ali Fazal and Russell Brand will be seen in Kenneth Branagh's Death on the Nile together.

Russell Brand praises Ali's moustache in Death on the Nile, calls him 'terrific'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 14, 2021 11:56 AM IST
Actor-singer Russell Brand was all praises for his Death on the Nile co-star Ali Fazal. He took to Twitter to say nice things about the Bollywood actor and his moustache.
Close
Bruce Willis visited a pharmacy in Los Angeles on Monday but did not wear a mask.
Bruce Willis visited a pharmacy in Los Angeles on Monday but did not wear a mask.

Bruce Willis regrets ‘error in judgment’ after refusing to wear a mask in public

PUBLISHED ON JAN 13, 2021 01:58 PM IST
  • Bruce Willis was clicked without a mask at a pharmacy in Los Angeles on Monday. He later said that it was an 'error in judgment'.
Close
Nick Jonas has given a big thumbs up to Priyanka Chopra's latest film, The White Tiger.
Nick Jonas has given a big thumbs up to Priyanka Chopra's latest film, The White Tiger.

Nick Jonas reviews Priyanka Chopra's The White Tiger, calls it 'unreal'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 13, 2021 09:43 AM IST
Singer Nick Jonas is all praise for Netflix's upcoming film, The White Tiger. The film stars Nick's wife, actor Priyanka Chopra Jonas in a supporting role.
Close
Dave Bautista in a still from Army of the Dead, Leonardo DiCaprio in a still from Don't Look Up, and Chris Hemsworth in a still from Escape from the Spiderhead.
Dave Bautista in a still from Army of the Dead, Leonardo DiCaprio in a still from Don't Look Up, and Chris Hemsworth in a still from Escape from the Spiderhead.

Netflix unveils star-studded 2021 slate, featuring DiCaprio, The Rock, Hemsworth

UPDATED ON JAN 12, 2021 08:31 PM IST
  • First footage from high-profile upcoming films starring Chris Hemsworth, Leonardo DiCaprio, Dwayne Johnson, Melissa McCarthy, Amy Adams, and others, has been revealed by Netflix.
Close
Actor Robert Downey Jr. (L) and Kevin Feige, President of Marvel Studios at the premiere of Avengers: Infinity War.(REUTERS)
Actor Robert Downey Jr. (L) and Kevin Feige, President of Marvel Studios at the premiere of Avengers: Infinity War.(REUTERS)

Kevin Feige exclusive interview: Marvel boss on India's role in MCU's future

By Rohan Naahar
UPDATED ON JAN 12, 2021 06:35 PM IST
  • In an exclusive interview with Hindustan Times, Marvel Studios president, Kevin Feige, spoke about India's role in the future of the MCU, and the mind-bending WandaVision, the studio's first streaming series.
Close
Neetu Chandra is set to play Jaya, a fighter in Never Back Down: Revolt.(Instagram)
Neetu Chandra is set to play Jaya, a fighter in Never Back Down: Revolt.(Instagram)

Neetu Chandra debuts in Hollywood: 'The Never Back Down role was written for me'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 12, 2021 02:41 PM IST
Neetu Chandra is all set to make her Hollywood debut with the next instalment of action franchise, Never Back Down: Revolt.
Close
Pieces of a Woman movie review: Shia LaBeouf as Sean and Vanessa Kirby as Martha, in a still from the new Netflix film, executive produced by Martin Scorsese.(Netflix)
Pieces of a Woman movie review: Shia LaBeouf as Sean and Vanessa Kirby as Martha, in a still from the new Netflix film, executive produced by Martin Scorsese.(Netflix)

Pieces of a Woman movie review: Simply brilliant, if you can get over Shia LaBeouf’s problematic presence

By Rohan Naahar | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON JAN 08, 2021 07:16 PM IST
Pieces of a Woman movie review: Look beyond Shia LaBeouf’s problematic presence, and the film has a lot to admire -- especially Vanessa Kirby’s astonishing central performance.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP