‘Ban PETA’ plea trashed, Madras HC calls it ‘misadventure’ for publicity
The Madras high court has dismissed a PIL seeking a ban on PETA, holding that the plea was a “misadventure” filed for publicity against the backdrop of Jallikattu protesters demanding a ban on the animal rights advocacy group.
“We find this a misadventure only for publicity sake, given the current social context on account of the role of PETA vis-a-vis the Jallikattu issue. This petition is dismissed,” said the first bench, comprising Chief Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul and Justice M Sundar.
The PIL, filed by hotel employee Dinesh of Chennai, sought a direction to the Union home ministry to ban PETA.
The petitioner submitted that PETA was an NGO coming under the ambit of the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act and so had “no locus standi” to file cases challenging state and central laws.
PETA was one of the petitioners in the Supreme Court against conduct of Jallikattu. The NGO had invited the wrath of pro-bull taming sport protesters in the wake of its opposition to the event.
After hearing the plea on Wednesday, the court noted, “We are troubled by the tenor of the petition.”
The court noted that the petition “seeks to suggest that entertaining PETA’s petitions by the Supreme Court amounts to violation of sovereignty and integrity of India and because it had sought to challenge laws made in India, it should be banned.”
The court also held that the view was contemptuous.
“In our view, this is contemptuous of the Supreme Court, as it is the prerogative of the court whether to entertain or not to entertain a petition.”
On the petitioner’s submission that PETA was indulging in “sexiest advertisements” and “pornography,” the court said “we find nothing of pornography. There are photographs of women sparsely clad propagating non-use of fur and such other materials which affect the rights of animals.”
The court also said it would be the prerogative of the executive to take action against any organisation, if any law was violated.
Enter your email to get our daily newsletter in your inbox
- Digvijaya Singh accused the Centre of trying to derail the farmers' protest
- At a press conference, AAP spokesperson Raghav Chadha, while questioning the connection between Sidhu and BJP, showed several photos purportedly of the actor with various BJP leaders. "The BJP planted their stooge Deep Sidhu to create chaos in farmers' tractor parade," Chadha said.
- The police said the IED was most probably planted in the night and that the perpetrators were probably familiar with the troop movement.
- The leopard had killed a woman and inured three others before the forest department declared it a man-eater.
- The two Tejas Express services are the first set of trains run by IRCTC, a subsidiary of the Indian Railways. They stopped operating in March last year due to the pandemic. IRCTC resumed services in October, but operations were stopped a month later due to low occupancy.
- The police headquarters has asked the US Nagar district police to maintain extra vigil as it is the most affected district in the state by the farmers’ agitation.