Supreme Court is pictured through a gate in New Delhi.(HT File Photo)
Supreme Court is pictured through a gate in New Delhi.(HT File Photo)

Calcutta HC’s Justice Karnan accuses SC of ‘upper caste’ bias over contempt notice

On February 8, a seven-judge Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice JS Khehar had ordered the registrar general of the Calcutta HC to relieve justice Karnan of his duties.
By Sudipto Mondal and Soibam Rocky Singh | Hindustan Times, Bengaluru/New Delhi
UPDATED ON MAR 09, 2017 01:20 PM IST

The courts have “no power to enforce punishment against a sitting Judge of the High Court”, Justice CS Karnan has said in response to a contempt notice by the Supreme Court for approaching the Prime Minister with a list of judges he considers corrupt.

On February 8, a seven-judge Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice JS Khehar had ordered the registrar general of the Calcutta HC to relieve Karnan of his duties. Justice Karnan was also asked to appear before the bench on February 13 to face contempt charges.

In a letter to the registrar general of the Supreme Court on Friday, a copy of which is available with HT, Karnan wrote: “This said order does not conform to logic, therefore is not suitable for execution. The characteristic of this order clearly shows the upper caste judges are taking law into their hands and misusing their judicial power by operating the same against a SC/ST Judge with mala fide intention of getting rid of him. Therefore, the suo motu contempt order dated 08.02.2017 is not sustainable under law.”

He also pointed to the instance from last year where he attempted to file a case against Chief Justice JS Khehar under the SC/ST Act and requested that the contempt case against him be heard after Khehar retired.

Justice Karnan has invoked his identity as a Dalit at a time when there isn’t a single judge from the SC or ST communities in the Supreme Court. The last Dalit Supreme Court judge was former Chief Justice KG Balakrishnan, who retired on May 11, 2010.

Justice Karnan’s letter went on to state: “I have given a recent allegation that there were 20 corrupt judges in the Madras High Court and the Hon’ble Justice S Kishan Kaul is No. 1 accused. Even this accusation was ignored although my complaint is still on file. It is observed that the 7 judges mentioned above are all out for a contempt case against me, presumably to clear the path for Justice Mr. S K Kaul’s elevation (to the Supreme Court).”

“The Suo Motu contempt order against me a Dalit judge and restraining my judicial and administrative assignment is unethical and goes against the SC/ST Atrocities Act. It is certainly a national issue and a wise decision would be to refer the issue to the House of Parliament.”

Confirming the authenticity of the letter, Karnan told HT over phone from Kolkata, “Yes, it is true that the letter was written by me. And I don’t think there is anything more to elaborate on the matter right now.”

When requested for an interview, the judge who is set to retire in a few months, said, “I shall speak my mind very soon. I will answer all questions.”

Attorney general Mukul Rohatgi had termed Karnan’s allegations disparaging. Rohatgi had said the top court must deal with the sitting judge sternly so that a message was sent across to citizens that judiciary did not dither from acting against one of its own. He had also said the public communications by Karnan were scurrilous and slanderous.

Karnan has gone incommunicado after his defiant letter. “He has isolated himself from the outside world and is refusing to meet anybody,” Supreme Court lawyer Mathews Nedumpara told HT. Nedumpara, who is the president of the National Lawyers’ Campaign for Judicial Transparency, said a delegation from his organisation had been trying without success to meet Karnan since the contempt order was issued.

Nedumpara said, “Justice Karnan has been discriminated against and socially isolated by the legal fraternity. This has sent him into extreme depression. During a phone conversation with me he also said that he is facing financial constraints because of which he is not able to travel to Delhi and hire a high-profile lawyer. We offered to represent him pro bono but he refused.”

Karnan, who was appointed to the Madras HC in 2009, has been at loggerheads with his fellow judges ever since 2011 when he accused them of discriminating him because he was Dalit.

In 2015, he accused then Chief Justice of the Madras high court SK Kaul of harassing him because he was a Dalit and belittling him by giving him “insignificant and dummy” portfolios while his juniors were given high profile matters.

This escalated further when he accused Kaul of corruption in February 2016. When the Supreme Court transferred him that same month, he surprised everybody by issuing a stay on his own transfer order. When a two-judge bench of the SC comprising JS Khehar and R Banumathi lifted his stay order, he ordered the Chennai police commissioner to book a case against the two judges under the SC/ST (atrocities) Act. He finally backed down and took charge at the Calcutta HC after a closed-door meeting with then CJI TS Thakur.

After remaining silent for a year, he once against raised the banner of revolt by writing letters to the Prime Minister.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
The average voting percentage across all these local bodies together was around 60.26 per cent, it said.(HT Photo )
The average voting percentage across all these local bodies together was around 60.26 per cent, it said.(HT Photo )

Over 60% voter turnout recorded in Gujarat local body polls

PTI, Ahmedabad
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 09:24 PM IST
As per the provisional figures, voter turnout of 54.95 per cent across 81 municipalities, 62.41 per cent in 31 district panchayats, and 63.42 per cent in 231 taluka panchayat, was recorded, the State Election Commission (SEC) said.
Close
A farmer sleeps inside a mosquito net during a protest against the new farm laws, at the Singhu border in New Delhi on Sunday. (ANI Photo)
A farmer sleeps inside a mosquito net during a protest against the new farm laws, at the Singhu border in New Delhi on Sunday. (ANI Photo)

Delhi sees 2nd highest mean maximum temperature for Feb since 1901

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 09:09 PM IST
The highest mean maximum temperature recorded for February in Delhi was 29.7 degrees Celsius in 2006, the IMD officials said.
Close
Congress leader Rashid Alvi said that his party will have work round the clock and formulate a strategy in the upcoming polls to fight BJP.(File photo)
Congress leader Rashid Alvi said that his party will have work round the clock and formulate a strategy in the upcoming polls to fight BJP.(File photo)

Appreciating BJP's work ethics, Rashid Alvi says Congress must work 24/7

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:59 PM IST
Alvi also commented on Prime Minister Narendra Modi's regret that he could not learn Tamil Nadu, during his monthly radio programme Maan Ki Baat.
Close
A health worker during a dry run for the administration of Covid-19 vaccine.(ANI/ File photo)
A health worker during a dry run for the administration of Covid-19 vaccine.(ANI/ File photo)

News updates from HT: Dry run at 4 govt-run hospitals in Pune tomorrow

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:56 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
Congress flags waves at rallies
Congress flags waves at rallies

Congress faces uphill battle in poll-bound states

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:40 PM IST
Barring Kerala, where the party feels it is poised to defeat the ruling Left Democratic Front (LDF), the Congress is beset with ally troubles in all other poll-bound states-- Assam, West Bengal and Tamil Nadu -- and the Union Territory of Puducherry.
Close
A health worker wearing a PPE kit collects a swab sample of an old lady for the Covid-19 test at Dadar railway station. (ANI Photo)
A health worker wearing a PPE kit collects a swab sample of an old lady for the Covid-19 test at Dadar railway station. (ANI Photo)

8,293 new cases in Maharashtra as Covid-19 spike continues amid lockdown, curbs

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 09:18 PM IST
There are 12 active containment zones in Mumbai and 133 buildings have been sealed, according to data released by the Bhrihanmumbai Municipal Corporation.
Close
The Centre has made FASTags mandatory from February 15 midnight and any vehicle not fitted with it will be charged double the toll at electronic toll plazas across the country, as per the current rules. (HT PHOTO).
The Centre has made FASTags mandatory from February 15 midnight and any vehicle not fitted with it will be charged double the toll at electronic toll plazas across the country, as per the current rules. (HT PHOTO).

Centre to begin live monitoring for toll-plazas to measure queues, waiting time

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:35 PM IST
  • The live monitoring system will measure the ‘Daily Congestion Index’ for each plaza as well as the overall congestion across the national highway network.
Close
File photo: Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal.(HT photo)
File photo: Delhi chief minister Arvind Kejriwal.(HT photo)

New agriculture reform laws death warrant for farmers: Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal

By S Raju, Meerut
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:19 PM IST
  • Kejriwal said all the previous governments cheated farmers on their demand for an appropriate price for their crops
Close
Hindu Mahasabha organisation member drinks with other members and supporters a cup of panchagavya, a traditional Hindu ritual mixture made of cow dung, urine, milk, curd and ghee, as they attend a ‘gaumutra (cow urine) party’ to fight coronavirus in New Delhi.(Photo: Sonu Mehta/ Hindustan Times)
Hindu Mahasabha organisation member drinks with other members and supporters a cup of panchagavya, a traditional Hindu ritual mixture made of cow dung, urine, milk, curd and ghee, as they attend a ‘gaumutra (cow urine) party’ to fight coronavirus in New Delhi.(Photo: Sonu Mehta/ Hindustan Times)

Rename Congress as Godsevadi Congress Party, Hindu Mahasabha taunts Sonia Gandhi

PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 07:55 PM IST
  • Former corporator Babulal Chaurasiya who joined the Congress recently, used to be an admirer of Mahatma Gandhi’s assassin Nathuram Godse.
Close
The 4.41km stretch between Dakshineswar and Noapara was sanctioned 11 years ago but more than 500 encroachments took over seven years for the work to progress.. (Samir Jana / HT Photo)
The 4.41km stretch between Dakshineswar and Noapara was sanctioned 11 years ago but more than 500 encroachments took over seven years for the work to progress.. (Samir Jana / HT Photo)

'Dream of Kolkata': Piyush Goyal on 'world-class' Noapara-Dakshineswar metro

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Deepali Sharma, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:13 PM IST
The minister said that the train with world-class facilities will benefit around 50,000 commuters every day.
Close
For those willing to get the vaccine at private centres, each dose is likely to cost <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>250 at the session site. (Shankar Narayan/HT PHOTO)
For those willing to get the vaccine at private centres, each dose is likely to cost 250 at the session site. (Shankar Narayan/HT PHOTO)

Delhi Covid-19 vaccine third phase starts tomorrow: All you need to know

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 07:27 PM IST
Those who wish to get inoculated at a private hospital will have to pay for their dose. Private hospitals have been allowed to charge up to 250 per dose of Covid-19 vaccine.
Close
Co-win app will be thrown open for self-registration after the second phase begins at 9am on March 1.
Co-win app will be thrown open for self-registration after the second phase begins at 9am on March 1.

Co-Win registration from 9am tomorrow as India enters 2nd phase of vaccination

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 07:48 PM IST
Co-Win 2.0 is not a new app. It's an upgrade of the existing app through which the government conducted the first phase of vaccination. For this upgrade, vaccination was stalled on Saturday and Sunday.
Close
Rakesh Tikait alleged that the Centre formulated the new farm laws without the consent of the farmers.(PTI)
Rakesh Tikait alleged that the Centre formulated the new farm laws without the consent of the farmers.(PTI)

Keep tractors ready as you may have to reach Delhi anytime: Rakesh Tikait

ANI, Shamli, Uttar Pradesh
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 06:54 PM IST
"This is my appeal to farmers that they should continue to work in their fields and also keep their tractors ready with their tanks full of oil as they may have to come to Delhi anytime," Rakesh Tikait said.
Close
A health worker prepares to administer a dose of Covid-19 vaccine at the Super Speciality Hospital Hospital in Srinagar,(Bloomberg)
A health worker prepares to administer a dose of Covid-19 vaccine at the Super Speciality Hospital Hospital in Srinagar,(Bloomberg)

67% health workers, 59% other frontline workers given Covid-19 vaccine in in J-K

By Ashiq Hussain
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 06:36 PM IST
  • On Saturday, the Centre asked all the states and union territories to closely monitor the trajectory of Covid infections to prevent surge in cases and assiduously expedite vaccination of priority groups.
Close
Ghulam Nabi Azad served as the chief minister of Jammu and Kashmir between 2005 and 2008,(ANI)
Ghulam Nabi Azad served as the chief minister of Jammu and Kashmir between 2005 and 2008,(ANI)

'I appreciate him for...': Ghulam Nabi Azad goes all praise for PM Modi

Written by Prashasti Singh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 28, 2021 06:29 PM IST
His statement comes days after PM Modi sang high praises of the leader. A "true friend" to him, Azad set high standards as a Member of Parliament and the Leader of Opposition, PM said.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP