SC dismisses plea seeking CBI probe into Mathura clashes
The Supreme Court today declined to hear a petition seeking a CBI probe into the clashes that erupted in Mathura last week, even as the Uttar Pradesh government transferred the area’s district magistrate and senior superintendent of police in this connectionUpdated: Jun 07, 2016, 12:31 IST
The Supreme Court on Tuesday declined to entertain a petition by a BJP leader seeking a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe into the violence in Mathura’s Jawahar Bagh in which 29 people, including two police officers, were killed last week.
A vacation bench headed by justice PC Ghose asked Ashwini Upadhyay to approach the Allahabad high court instead. The court said that Upadhyay has not made any representation to the state government neither the Allahabad HC where a matter on the issue was already pending.
On Monday, the top court agreed to urgently hear the plea for a CBI inquiry into the Jawahar Bagh violence.
This is a matter which is to be looked into by the state government as the Centre does not have the power to order a CBI probe in the matter, the bench, also comprising of justice Amitava Roy, said.
Upadhyay alleged that Ram Vriksh Yadav, the alleged mastermind behind the attack and Azad Bharat Vidhik Vaicharik Kranti Satyagrahi’s leader, was running a parallel government inside the Jawahar Bagh Park since 2014 with the backing of the local administration.
The petitioner said the Centre was ready for a CBI probe but the Uttar Pradesh government was developing cold feet over the issue. He also demanded uniform compensation for the families of those killed in the violence.
Twenty nine people, including a superintendent of police and an SHO, were killed in violent clashes between police and encroachers on June 2 when police tried to evict illegal occupants from Jawahar Bagh Park on the orders of the Allahabad HC.
Quoting media reports, Upadhyay alleged Yadav was very close to some politicians, ministers and the local administration was unwilling to act against the group.
Armed members of the group had been squatting at Jawahar Bagh but the local administration did not take appropriate action even as they built a self-sustaining community within the park during 2014-16.
“They built huts and toilets, cultivated vegetables and disallowed others from entering the park. There were around 3000 squatters, 20 Lakh kg food grain, 200 cars and 400 gas cylinders in the park,” he said.
The BJP leader also said the park had turned into a quasi-republic with its own Constitution, penal code, judicial system, prisons and army but the district administration was silent for two years.
“The police recovered 47 guns, 6 rifles and 179 hand grenades from the camp. By June 3, they had arrested 368 people, 120 of whom were charged with creating disturbances. This included 196 preventive arrests, including those of 116 women,” the petitioner said.
“CBI inquiry is necessary to find out the root cause of the Mathura incident and nexus among the Executive, Legislatures and the extremist group…”