The five-judge bench passed an order turning down pleas by farmer bodies who sought the recusal of Justice Mishra from hearing the case.(File photo/ Hindustan)
The five-judge bench passed an order turning down pleas by farmer bodies who sought the recusal of Justice Mishra from hearing the case.(File photo/ Hindustan)

Won’t withdraw from Constitution bench: Justice Arun Mishra

Justice Mishra’s 2018 judgement on compensation was at odds with a 2014 judgment of the court and the matter was then referred to a Constitution bench.
By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON OCT 24, 2019 01:59 AM IST

Supreme Court judge, Justice Arun Mishra on Wednesday refused to withdraw from a Constitution bench hearing a case over interpretation of section 24 of the land acquisition act that involves fair compensation to landowners -- the case essentially re-examines his own judgment on compensation dating back to 2018 -- whose property is acquired by the State.

The five-judge bench passed an order turning down pleas by farmer bodies who sought the recusal of Justice Mishra from hearing the case.

Justice Mishra’s 2018 judgement on compensation was at odds with a 2014 judgment of the court and the matter was then referred to a Constitution bench.

The facts of the case (or cases) are straightforward: the 2013 land acquisition law replaced an 1894 one and promised higher compensation for people whose land was acquired. While dealing with a case related to compensation, a three-judge bench headed by Justice RM Lodha said in 2014 that the acquisition of land under the old law would deem to have lapsed if the compensation was merely deposited in the government treasury and not either paid out to the landowners or deposited with the court. This meant all cases where this had happened -- there were several -- would now involve compensation under the new 2013 land acquisition law, entailing higher compensation.

In 2018, a three-judge bench of which Justice Mishra was a part through a majority verdict in a different case related to compensation said the land acquisition could not be deemed to have lapsed because depositing the money in the treasury was an established tradition. Justices Mishra and AK Goel were of this view while Justice MM Shantanagoudar wrote a dissenting verdict. However, the bench’s majority ruling meant that in cases where compensation had not been made or delayed, the land acquisition under the old law would still be valid.

Last week, Farmers’ Association opposed Justice Mishra heading the five-judge bench.

Senior advocate Shyam Divan, appearing for the farmers body opposed the presence of Justice Mishra on the bench saying propriety demands that a judge who has taken a view on the matter should not be a part of the bench that is sitting in appeal against it.

But Justice Mishra and other judges on the bench did not agree with the demand and asked lawyers to argue. The arguments went on for two days and the matter was reserved for judgment.

Justice Arun Mishra, one of the senior judges of the Supreme Court and a member of the collegium, criticised the “emerging trend” of using social media and articles to pressurise the judiciary and judges to give up cases and said such practices amounted to deliberate interference with the judicial system.

He said, “My determination has been strengthened by these circumstances. It would be embarrassing for me to hear comments on my own argument, but I will not succumb to a lobby which under a certain guise is pressurising the Chief Justice.”

“It will destroy the independence of the judiciary. You are asking for a bench of your preference, your liking?...This is a grave issue!”, the judge told senior advocate Shyam Divan who on behalf of the landowners said there was no intent of any bench-shopping.

“We are worried about an apprehension of bias,” Divan clarified.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Mithun Chakraborty dances during an election campaign rally for Sandhya Roy in West Midnapore district of West Bengal. (PTI Photo)
Mithun Chakraborty dances during an election campaign rally for Sandhya Roy in West Midnapore district of West Bengal. (PTI Photo)

When Mithun Chakraborty resigned from Rajya Sabha citing health reasons

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 07, 2021 12:28 PM IST
In 2014, Trinamool sent him to the Rajya Sabha but the Saradha scam apparently tarnished his image as he was the brand ambassador of the group that ran a ponzi scam in Bengal.
Close
A boatman wades through toxic foam floating on the river Yamuna at Kalindi Kunj in New Delhi.(PTI)
A boatman wades through toxic foam floating on the river Yamuna at Kalindi Kunj in New Delhi.(PTI)

Delhi among top 3 states with most contaminated sites in India

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 12:22 PM IST
There are 112 sites in India contaminated by toxic and hazardous substances. Besides, there are 168 sites that may be contaminated but require investigation and confirmation, as per the CPCB.
Close
Congress General Secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra.
Congress General Secretary Priyanka Gandhi Vadra.

Priyanka Gandhi Vadra to address Kisan Mahapanchyat in Meerut today

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 12:15 PM IST
Uttar Pradesh Congress Committee chief Ajay Kumar Lallu on Saturday said that the party will continue to protest against the farm laws and "Priyanka Gandhi will address a 'Kisan Mahapanchayat' in Meerut on Sunday and highlight the issues being faced by farmers."
Close
In October 2020, the Allahabad High Court had granted bail to MP Azam Khan, his wife and son in the case.(Photo: PTI)
In October 2020, the Allahabad High Court had granted bail to MP Azam Khan, his wife and son in the case.(Photo: PTI)

SP to hold cycle rally in support of Azam Khan over cases lodged by UP police

By hindustantimes.com | ANI, Lucknow
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 12:10 PM IST
  • In January, the Supreme Court dismissed pleas of the Uttar Pradesh government challenging the bail granted to Samajwadi Party MP Azam Khan, his wife Dr Tanzeen Fathima, and son Abdullah Azam Khan in an alleged case of forging birth certificate.
Close
The Bombay high court. (HT FILE PHOTO)
The Bombay high court. (HT FILE PHOTO)

Bombay HC refuses pre-arrest bail to judicial magistrate booked in bribery case

PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 12:08 PM IST
  • An associate of the judicial magistrate allegedly demanded and accepted a bribe on her behalf for dismissing a criminal complaint against a milk vendor.
Close
National Conference leader Omar Abdullah reacted sharply to Suvendu Adhikari's comment that West Bengal will become like Kashmir under another term of Trinamool. (HT Photo/File)
National Conference leader Omar Abdullah reacted sharply to Suvendu Adhikari's comment that West Bengal will become like Kashmir under another term of Trinamool. (HT Photo/File)

Omar Abdullah's swipe at Suvendu: 'Hasn't Kashmir become paradise after 2019?'

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON MAR 07, 2021 12:38 PM IST
The comment is stupid and tasteless, former J&K Chief Minister tweeted a day after Bengal BJP leader said West Bengal will become Kashmir if Trinamool comes back to power in assembly election.
Close
Jan Aushadhi stores, the affordable drug stores, have been set up across the country.(HT File Photo)
Jan Aushadhi stores, the affordable drug stores, have been set up across the country.(HT File Photo)

Called Modi ki dukan... buy medicine from there: PM launches Jan Aushadhi centre

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
UPDATED ON MAR 07, 2021 10:54 AM IST
PM Modi interacted with the beneficiaries of 'Pradhan Mantri Bhartiya Jan Aushadhi Pariyojana' and gave awards to stakeholders, in recognition of their excellent work.
Close
Union home minister Amit Shah is going to Kerala and Tamil Nadu for a day long visit.
Union home minister Amit Shah is going to Kerala and Tamil Nadu for a day long visit.

Amit Shah visits Kerala as Vijayan govt battles to rid gold smuggling taint

By Ramesh Babu | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Thiruvananthapuram
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 10:50 AM IST
  • Earlier, the CM had hit out at BJP's minister of state for external affairs, V Muraleedharan, alleging after his elevation, smuggling from West Asian countries increased manifold
Close
BJP activists cheer holding party flags at the rally and stage area ahead of PM Narendra Modi's election rally at the brigade parade ground, in Kolkata.
BJP activists cheer holding party flags at the rally and stage area ahead of PM Narendra Modi's election rally at the brigade parade ground, in Kolkata.

During PM Modi’s Kolkata rally, CM Banerjee will decry LPG price in Siliguri

By HT Correspondent, Kolkata
UPDATED ON MAR 07, 2021 11:16 AM IST
  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi's rally at the famous Brigade Parade Grounds in Maidan area is expected to draw a huge crowd.
Close
A healthcare worker inoculates a senior citizen at a government hospital near Ajmer in Rajasthan on Saturday.(ANI Photo)
A healthcare worker inoculates a senior citizen at a government hospital near Ajmer in Rajasthan on Saturday.(ANI Photo)

India records 18,711 new cases of Covid-19, 100 deaths

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
UPDATED ON MAR 07, 2021 09:38 AM IST
The count of active cases went up to 4,219, reaching 1,84,523, according to the health ministry data.
Close
 He also attacked the opposition parties which are supporting the farmers' protest. "There is a place for disagreement in democracy and so is for opposition and difference of opinion, but should there be any opposition that can harm the nation," he said.
He also attacked the opposition parties which are supporting the farmers' protest. "There is a place for disagreement in democracy and so is for opposition and difference of opinion, but should there be any opposition that can harm the nation," he said.

News updates from HT: Govt ready to amend farm laws, says Tomar

PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:53 AM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
More details in Chhattisgarh family's mysterious death case will be available after the post-mortem, said officials.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)
More details in Chhattisgarh family's mysterious death case will be available after the post-mortem, said officials.(Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Chhattisgarh: 5 of family found dead in Durg; note cites financial stress

By Ritesh Mishra | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Raipur
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:39 AM IST
  • The police were investigating the case from all possible angles.
Close
Union minister Giriraj Singh.(Santosh Kumar/ Hindustan Times)
Union minister Giriraj Singh.(Santosh Kumar/ Hindustan Times)

Officials don't listen to you? Beat them up with sticks: Giriraj tells residents

PTI, Begusarai
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:39 AM IST
The firebrand BJP leader, who has a reputation of shooting from the hip, made the remark while addressing a function organised by an agriculture institute in Khodawandpur near here.
Close
Union agricultural minister Narendra Singh Tomar at an event in New Delhi last month.(PTI File Photo)
Union agricultural minister Narendra Singh Tomar at an event in New Delhi last month.(PTI File Photo)

Govt ready to amend farm laws, says Union minister Narendra Singh Tomar

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 08:06 AM IST
Tomar said the three laws passed by Parliament in September last year will help farmers fetch more prices in the market.
Close
Bharatiya Kisan Union spokesperson Rakesh Tikait attends a 'Kisan Mahapanchayat', in Saharanpur district on Sunday.(PTI Photo)
Bharatiya Kisan Union spokesperson Rakesh Tikait attends a 'Kisan Mahapanchayat', in Saharanpur district on Sunday.(PTI Photo)

1 village, 1 tractor, 15 men and 10 days: Tikait's formula for farmers' protest

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 07, 2021 07:03 AM IST
The farmers have been sitting at various borders near national capital Delhi since November 26 with the demand that the three central farm laws must be repealed.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP