HT Image
HT Image

Dr Strangelove

The good Dr Singh and his ministerial colleague, the other Dr Singh, want Indians to be one-dimensionally identified as OBCs, MBCs, etc.
By By Indrajit Hazra | None
PUBLISHED ON MAY 29, 2006 12:35 AM IST

The Good Dr Prime Minister has a good Dr Nobel Laureate as a friend who has some very wise things to say about the politics of identity. “A person belongs to many different groups, of which a religious affiliation is only one. To see, for example, a mathematician who happens to be a Muslim by religion mainly in terms of Islamic identity would be to hide more than it reveals... To concentrate only on [9th century mathematician] Al-Khwarizmi’s Islamic identity over his identity as a mathematician would be extremely misleading, and yet he clearly was also a Muslim.”

Somehow though, Amartya Sen’s observations don’t seem to have made much of an impression on his buddy, Manmohan Singh. For, the Prime Minister will be enacting  an enabling draft bill that will subsume the goulash of identity markers that make millions of us ‘Indian’. Sen focuses on the debilitating practice of the tag of ‘Muslimhood’ being thrust on people across the world who happen to be Muslim, drowning out anything else they may be. Singh, in the meantime,  has joined the ranks of ‘community’ leaders who have herded Indians into their nicely labelled caste pens. Singh and his new-found friends will obviously call it ‘empowerment’. I’d rather call it ‘sucking up to a votebank’.

So who is an OBC? According to the First Backward Classes Commission (known fondly as the Mandal Commission), an OBC has to belong to a caste -- thus the ‘caste’-link to a ‘class’ category -- or community that fulfils four main characteristics:

i) Low social position in the traditional caste hierarchy of Hindu society.

ii) Lack of general educational advancement among the major section of a caste or community.

iii) Inadequate or no representation in government service.

iv) Inadequate representation in the field of trade, commerce and industry.

The Mandal Commission prepared a list of 2,399 “backward castes or communities”, 837 being categorised as “most backward”. But these ‘indicators’ in the commission report made in 1980 were based on the 1961 Census. Which makes it not too surprising that while Mandal states that 52 per cent of the nation comprises (comprised?) OBCs, others have wildly varying figures. The 1999-2000 National Sample Survey Organisation puts the OBC population percentage at 32 per cent, while the 1998 National Family Health Survey puts it at 29.8.

For all I care, the percentage of Indians with an urge to raid the fridge after midnight could be 52, 32 or 29.8. Quite unlike the complete empirical firmness of the number 27 -- the percentage of seats to be reserved for OBCs in our institutions of higher education. To add to the confusion, of course, there are the OBCs who lie outside the ‘low social position in the traditional caste hierarchy of Hindu society’. The government is a bit fuzzy about whether Muslim OBCs can also line up outside the backgate.

So maybe the best way of defining an OBC is: a caste or community for which the UPA government will be reserving 27 per cent of seats in educational institutions.

Which makes me simultaneously scratch my head and come to another aspect of the Great Indian Fudge: this noble notion of being Indian first and other things after. By firming up the definition of the OBC, it seems to me that the UPA government is telling large sections of the population: you’re OBC first, you’re OBC second and then other things.

Unlike belonging to a religion, belonging to a modern caste-categorisation is not a static thing. Sania Mirza will be a Muslim (among many other things) however many cars she endorses. For the person deemed as an OBC, however, the object is ultimately to break out of OBC-hood. After all, social justice is about providing a crutch till the missing leg starts growing -- which, at least in theory, is the whole point of reservations and why people like Ambedkar were keen on a strictly time-bound reservations policy.

But then, who would be politically dumb enough to want ‘backwards’ to wither away and drift into the general mainstream when such groupings can be nourished till kingdom come as a ‘constituency’? Also, it’s way easier than providing social justice to all those who need it. And by pushing for reservations, the ‘secular’ Congress can play Mayawati-Lalu-Mulayam without being oh-so-terribly casteist.

There was a time when I knew families that were pretty clear that their women (convent-educated, fluent in English Bengalis) would marry gents of their caste -- or at least of an ‘acceptable’ caste. But as these women grew older (and more desperate to shake off intimations of permanent spinsterhood), their families threw caste considerations to the dogs and they made do with good men from outside the ‘circle’. I figured that caste was finally becoming an anachronism at least in urban India.

Poor fool that I was, I hadn’t reckoned for the UPA government’s go at playing Mad Max Weber. So if a foreigner asks me whether India in 2006 is still a caste-ridden society, my brain will surely frizzle in confusion as I consider Article 15 -- “Prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth” -- and the other sections of the Constitution the UPA government will quote from.

The good Dr Singh and his ministerial colleague, the other Dr Singh, want Indians to be one-dimensionally identified as OBCs, MBCs, etc... never mind whether these tags will help these ‘caste’ entities in the long run or not. (See UP and Bihar for clues.) Now if Manmohan Singh gets shy about proclaiming his government’s casteist credentials because of his latest move, he really shouldn’t. After all, he’ll be helping 52 per cent of Indians. Or is it 32 per cent? Or 29.8? Damn it! Let’s just call them OBCs and play along, shall we?

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Earlier, Maharashtra Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray said that areas in north Karnataka which are dominated by Marathi-speakers be declared a Union Territory till the Supreme Court gives final verdict.(HT Photo)
Earlier, Maharashtra Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray said that areas in north Karnataka which are dominated by Marathi-speakers be declared a Union Territory till the Supreme Court gives final verdict.(HT Photo)

Border row: Maharashtra government releases old documentary to make its case

PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:47 PM IST
The 35-minute black and white film titled "A case for justice", produced by the Maharashtra government 50 years ago, has now been released on YouTube in digital format.
Close
Natasha Narwal was arrested in the case for allegedly being part of a premeditated conspiracy in the riots.(Twitter)
Natasha Narwal was arrested in the case for allegedly being part of a premeditated conspiracy in the riots.(Twitter)

Delhi riots: Court dismisses bail pleas of Pinjra Tod activist Natasha Narwal

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:38 PM IST
  • Additional Sessions Judge Amitabh Rawat said in a case of conspiracy of such a large scale, not having a video was not so vital as generally conspiracy, by its very nature, is hatched in secrecy and not having videos of such a conspiracy was obvious rather than doubtful.
Close
In an affidavit filed in the apex court, the Centre had said that giving an additional attempt or relaxation in age for some candidates would amount to extending differential treatment to similarly placed aspirants at the examination.(File photo)
In an affidavit filed in the apex court, the Centre had said that giving an additional attempt or relaxation in age for some candidates would amount to extending differential treatment to similarly placed aspirants at the examination.(File photo)

SC expresses displeasure over Centre's affidavit in civil services exam matter

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:37 PM IST
A bench headed by Justice AM Khanwilkar expressed displeasure over it and said that the affidavit filed before it was not clear about at whose level this decision was taken.
Close
Coining a new ‘BJP-mukt and Congress-mukt India’ slogan, Telangana chief minister and Telangana Rashtra Samithi president K Chandrashekhar Rao said on Tuesday a new national party as a consortium of regional parties may emerge “very soon”.(PTI File Photo)
Coining a new ‘BJP-mukt and Congress-mukt India’ slogan, Telangana chief minister and Telangana Rashtra Samithi president K Chandrashekhar Rao said on Tuesday a new national party as a consortium of regional parties may emerge “very soon”.(PTI File Photo)

With 1.9 lakh job vacancies, Telangana govt is working at 61% of total strength

PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:24 PM IST
  • According to the pay revision committee's report, Telangana was also lagging behind in terms of population-workforce ratio, compared to many other states.
Close
PM Narendra Modi on Thursday said the government has taken various steps to boost self-reliance in the defence sector and India will be known as a producer of military equipment, instead of being a market. (ANI PHOTO).
PM Narendra Modi on Thursday said the government has taken various steps to boost self-reliance in the defence sector and India will be known as a producer of military equipment, instead of being a market. (ANI PHOTO).

Covid-19 or border challenge, India capable on every front: PM Modi

PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:12 PM IST
  • In his customary address at the National Cadet Corps rally, the PM said whether it was the protective cover of the vaccine or dealing with those who challenge India, the country was capable on every front.
Close
Congress flags waves at rallies
Congress flags waves at rallies

Cong, Left agree to share 193 seats in Bengal assembly, to hold talks on rest

PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:55 PM IST
  • On December 24, the All India Congress Committee (AICC) formally approved a tie-up with the Left parties in Bengal.
Close
 The farmers, led by BKU leader Rakesh Tikait, are continuing their sit-in protest at Ghazipur border.(HT Photo)
The farmers, led by BKU leader Rakesh Tikait, are continuing their sit-in protest at Ghazipur border.(HT Photo)

Farmers' protest: Tikait brothers differ, situation tense at Ghazipur border

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:52 PM IST
The farmers' agitation had received a jolt when the protesters who took part in a tractor rally wreaked havoc on the roads of Delhi on Republic Day.
Close
Security personnel stand guard outside Rashtriya Dalit Prerna Sthal after vacated the place overnight Wednesday. (PTI)
Security personnel stand guard outside Rashtriya Dalit Prerna Sthal after vacated the place overnight Wednesday. (PTI)

Farmers’ protest ends in Noida as BKU faction quits Rashtriya Dalit Prerna Sthal

PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:52 PM IST
  • The Bharatiya Kisan Union (Lokshakti) said it was ending the protest because it had lost direction.
Close
India is still very low on corruption Index, the report said, noting that experts feel the CPI does not reflect the actual corruption level in any country. The integrity score determines the corruption situation of a country.(Getty images)
India is still very low on corruption Index, the report said, noting that experts feel the CPI does not reflect the actual corruption level in any country. The integrity score determines the corruption situation of a country.(Getty images)

India slips six places to rank 86 in corruption perception index 2020

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:37 PM IST
The index, which ranks 180 countries and territories by their perceived levels of public sector corruption according to experts and business people, uses a scale of 0 to 100, where 0 is highly corrupt and 100 is very clean.
Close
Special international flights have been operating under the Vande Bharat Mission since May and under bilateral "air bubble" arrangements(PTI file photo)
Special international flights have been operating under the Vande Bharat Mission since May and under bilateral "air bubble" arrangements(PTI file photo)

Suspension of scheduled international passenger flights extended till Feb 28

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:19 PM IST
  • "However, international scheduled flights may be allowed on selected routes by the competent authority on a case-to-case basis," the Directorate General of Civil Aviation said. The suspension does not affect the operation of international all-cargo operations and flights specifically approved by it.
Close
New Delhi: Delhi Police Commissioner SN Shrivastava during a press conference, in New Delhi, Wednesday, Jan 27, 2021.(PTI)
New Delhi: Delhi Police Commissioner SN Shrivastava during a press conference, in New Delhi, Wednesday, Jan 27, 2021.(PTI)

'Thank you for patience': Delhi top cop to staff on R-Day chaos. Read letter

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:10 PM IST
In the first presser after the turbulent Republic Day Delhi witnessed, the Delhi police commissioner accused the farmer unions of betrayal and not following conditions set for the tractor rally that was supposed to be held from 12 PM to 5 PM.
Close
"The world's largest vaccination programme is going on in India. More than 20 lakh people of the country have been given Covid-19 vaccines. About 3 crore people will be given Covid-19 vaccines in the first two phases," Naqvi said.(PTI)
"The world's largest vaccination programme is going on in India. More than 20 lakh people of the country have been given Covid-19 vaccines. About 3 crore people will be given Covid-19 vaccines in the first two phases," Naqvi said.(PTI)

Indian vaccines reflect scientists' hard work, PM's commitment: Naqvi

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:57 PM IST
India has not only taken care of the health and well-being of its own people during the coronavirus crisis, it has also helped other nations by them sending vaccines, the minority affairs minister said at a 'Nutrition and Covid Awareness Camp'.
Close
PM Modi virtually addressing the Davos Dialogue on Thursday.(ANI Photo)
PM Modi virtually addressing the Davos Dialogue on Thursday.(ANI Photo)

'India fulfilled its global responsibility': PM Modi's top quotes

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:46 PM IST
PM Modi talked about how India ensured that a large chunk of its population is saved from the coronavirus disease (Covid-19) pandemic after predictions were made that 70-80 crore people will be infected.
Close
Indian fishermen clear their nets early morning after returning from the Arabian Sea in Mumbai, India.(File Photo / AP)
Indian fishermen clear their nets early morning after returning from the Arabian Sea in Mumbai, India.(File Photo / AP)

Puducherry government launches helpline to assist fishermen

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:46 PM IST
The fishermen could also get details of the status of their applications for relief, incentives and financial succour and welfare schemes.
Close
Air Force, Army and Navy bands performing during the full dress rehearsals on January 27 for the Beating Retreat.(Raj K Raj / HT Photo)
Air Force, Army and Navy bands performing during the full dress rehearsals on January 27 for the Beating Retreat.(Raj K Raj / HT Photo)

Beating Retreat: New song to be played to commemorate 50 years of 1971 victory

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:44 PM IST
The composition will be led by Lieutenant colonel Vimal Joshi and Havildar Jiwan Rasaily during a quick march at the historical Vijay Chowk where the ceremony takes place.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP