HT Image
HT Image

Secular blunders

A state that calls itself secular has no business to involve itself in purely religious matters such as pilgrimages. By all means make provisions for the security and comfort of pilgrims, but the state governments must not go beyond that, writes Khushwant Singh.
By Khushwant Singh | None
UPDATED ON JUL 19, 2008 07:11 PM IST

A state that calls itself secular has no business to involve itself in purely religious matters such as pilgrimages. By all means make provisions for the security and comfort of pilgrims, as our state governments do during Kumbh Melas at Allahabad and Rath Yatras at the Jagannath Temple in Puri, but they must not go beyond that. State officials have no right to associate themselves or extend patronage to religious bodies or give away public land, property or money to them. That error was made by General SK Sinha, recently retired Governor of Jammu & Kashmir. He had no right to give away vast hectares of forestland to the Amarnath Shrine Board. As an experienced administrator, he should have foreseen that the move would cause grave resentment in the predominantly Muslim population of the Valley. And so it did. His successor N.N. Vohra was right in rescinding his predecessor’s order while at the same time reassuring pilgrims that the state would guarantee their safety and comfort. He had to face the ire of Hindus in majority in Jammu and the rest of India. It gave right-wing Hindu political parties a grievance they could exploit for electoral gains. Such mistakes should not be repeated.

It is also time to reconsider facilities provided to Muslims going on Haj pilgrimages to Mecca and Medina. Islam clearly provides that only those who can afford to travel to these holy cities should undertake the pilgrimage. Nevertheless, the Government of India provides subsidies to pilgrims who can’t pay for their expenses and sends official delegations of Muslims free of charge to Saudi Arabia. There is no justification whatsoever for its doing so. Most Muslims I know disapprove of such government patronage and would welcome their being withdrawn. The lesson to be learnt from our recent experience is that any secular Government that meddles in religious matters only burns its own fingers.

II. Minoo, the Bridge-Builder

It was a grievous blow to those who strive to build bridges between Pakistan and India to hear that Minoo Bhandara, ex-member of the Pakistan National Assembly had died. Apparently, while on a visit to China, he met with a car accident and was seriously injured. He was flown back to Rawalpindi. Amongst the first to call on him in hospital were President Musharaf and his wife Sahba. He seemed to be recovering but on June 15 he gave up the battle. He was barely 70. I don’t recall when and where I first met Minoo. We had a common friend and role model in Manzur Qadir. He shared my opinion that Manzur was the paradigm of goodness and rectitude. It was this admiration for Manzur that created a bond between us. However, I do remember that at our first meeting I asked him: “Are you a Bawaji?” He was non-plussed as he did not know what the word meant. I had to tell him that in India, behind their back, we refer to Parsis as Bawajis. “And what are you doing in Pakistan?” was my next question.

He explained he ran the Murree Brewery and was also a member of the National Assembly. We became friends. Whenever he was in Delhi, which was often, he spent a couple of evenings with me. He was proud of his products, notably his single malt whisky which he brought for me. He was invariably accompanied by a pretty Pakistani girl, usually a painter, poet, or novelist.

I also discovered that Pakistan’s leading novelist in English, Bapsi Sidhwa, was his sister. Bapsi stayed with me when she was in Delhi. Whenever I visited Pakistan, I stayed with Minoo in his beautifully laid out bungalow in Rawalpindi. He had built a mosque alongside for his Muslim employees. I asked him how the Pakistani took to brewery as liquor is forbidden as haraam. He smiled and replied: “You know how things are in our countries — say one thing, do another. My products are only meant for export. But behind closed doors the elite of Pakistan, when they can’t get imported stuff, they make do with the indigenous.”

Needless to say that in Pakistan amongst the richest who made his fortune legally was Minoo Bhandara who had the monopoly on brewing beer and distilling whisky. Minoo’s main interest was not politics but literature.

He would patiently answer all the questions about political affairs in Pakistan that I fired at him and then turn to books, novels, anthologies of poetry and whatever. In Delhi, he usually stayed at the India International Centre and spent his afternoons doing the rounds of bookstores in Khan Market. Invariably he asked me what I was writing on. I was then busy translating selections of Urdu poetry into English. I was facing a lot of difficulties with Ghalib. I told him I don’t agree with any of the interpretations of the opening lines of his Diwan: Naqsh faryaadi hai kis kee shokhiye tehreer ka/Kaaghazi hai pairhan har paikar-e-tasveer ka.

I told him that there was nothing to suggest that Ghalib had alluded to a practice of petitioners having to wear paper robes when they appeared before the Shah. He simply meant to say that a picture tells its own tale. It does not need learned interpretation to explain its purport. Minoo disagreed and said: “At the time we (i.e. Zoroastrians) ruled Iran that was accepted practice.” We had an animated (never heated) argument over it. Another time, it was about Faiz’s oft-quoted lines: Raat yoon dil mein teyree khoyee huee yaad aayee/Jaisey veeraney mein chupkay say bahaar aa, jaaye. He argued over my translation. I conceded to the suggestion he made.

Every time Minoo came to India, it was to attend a conference or seminar on Indo-Pak relations. He put the Pakistani point of view to Indian audiences. Back in Pakistan, he put Indian reactions in articles he wrote for Pakistani journals. He was a true bridge-builder between the two nations. With his going, that bridge has fallen.

For me, Minoo’s death has been a personal loss. With all my Lahore days’ Pakistani friends now resting in their graves, he was my last remaining link with a country I call my vatan, my homeland. That link has been snapped.

III. Pattern of Exams

General Students: answer all questions.

OBCs: answer any one question

SCs: only read questions

STs: thanks for coming

Gujjars: thanks for allowing others to attend the examination!!

(Contributed by Vipin Buckshey, N.Delhi)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
After implementation of the amended Motor Vehicles (MV) Act since September 1, road accidents and fatalities in the state have started declining.(HT PHOTO.)
After implementation of the amended Motor Vehicles (MV) Act since September 1, road accidents and fatalities in the state have started declining.(HT PHOTO.)

Celebrated biker King Richard killed after collision with camel in Jaisalmer

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Kota
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:32 AM IST
  • Srinivasan had been on several long bike tours and expeditions, travelling to 36 countries and several continents, including America, Europe, Asia and Australia.
Close
Rajya Sabha chairman M Venkaiah Naidu regularly urges the members of the House to speak in their mother tongue. (ANI)
Rajya Sabha chairman M Venkaiah Naidu regularly urges the members of the House to speak in their mother tongue. (ANI)

Sanskrit was the 5th most used language in Rajya Sabha in 2019-20

By Smriti Kak Ramachandran | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:03 AM IST
  • While Hindi and English have been mostly used during the proceedings of the House, members preferring to speak in the 21 other scheduled Indian languages has increased to over five times per sitting in 2020 compared to the 14-year period between 2004-17.
Close
Commuters on their way during cold and foggy morning in New Delhi, India. (HT photo/ Sanjeev Verma)
Commuters on their way during cold and foggy morning in New Delhi, India. (HT photo/ Sanjeev Verma)

News updates from Hindustan Times: Delhi NCR air 'severe' and all the latest new

By hindustantimes.com
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:05 AM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times.
Close
Flight and train services were disrupted on Saturday morning owing to dense fog in Delhi. (Photo: ANI)
Flight and train services were disrupted on Saturday morning owing to dense fog in Delhi. (Photo: ANI)

Flights, trains delayed, diverted, cancelled due to dense fog in Delhi

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:14 AM IST
Delhi airport issued a statement asking passengers to check with their airlines concerned for updated information about their flight status.
Close
Low wind speed is not allowing dispersal of pollutants in the air in Delhi NCR.
Low wind speed is not allowing dispersal of pollutants in the air in Delhi NCR.

Delhi-NCR air in severe category, temperatures to dip in northwest India

By Jayashree Nandi, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:21 AM IST
  • Cold wave or 'severe’ cold wave conditions are also very likely over Punjab, Haryana, Chandigarh, Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and east Madhya Pradesh during the next two days
Close
In the study, the researchers assessed 97 patients with Covid-19, measuring their mitochondrial DNA levels on the first day of their hospital stays. (Image used for representation).(HT Photo)
In the study, the researchers assessed 97 patients with Covid-19, measuring their mitochondrial DNA levels on the first day of their hospital stays. (Image used for representation).(HT Photo)

Rapid blood test to identify patients at highest risk of severe Covid-19

PTI
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:30 AM IST
The test, described in the journal JCI Insight, measures levels of mitochondrial DNA -- a unique type of genetic material that normally resides inside the energy factories of cells.
Close
States have been given a free hand to increase the number of session sites, if needed, as a single site cannot administer the vaccine to more than 100 beneficiaries in a day.
States have been given a free hand to increase the number of session sites, if needed, as a single site cannot administer the vaccine to more than 100 beneficiaries in a day.

Covid-19: Nationwide vaccination drive to start today

By Rhythma Kaul, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:41 AM IST
Each centre will deploy vaccines from a single manufacturer to avoid mixing of doses in recipients, which is not permitted, said officials involved in the delivery programme that will be launched at 10.30am.
Close
A health official shows a Covishield vaccine dose in Amritsar.(PTI)
A health official shows a Covishield vaccine dose in Amritsar.(PTI)

Rest for at least half an hour: Centre's guideline ahead of vaccination Day 1

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:32 AM IST
Paracetamol may be used to provide symptomatic relief from post-vaccination adverse reactions, the ministry has specified.
Close
A health worker performs a trial run of Covid-19 vaccine delivery system in New Delhi, India. The global death toll from COVID-19 has topped 2 million.(AP)
A health worker performs a trial run of Covid-19 vaccine delivery system in New Delhi, India. The global death toll from COVID-19 has topped 2 million.(AP)

Covid-19 LIVE updates: India to vaccinate 3 lakh health care workers today

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Arpan Rai
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:53 AM IST
The vaccination drive covers all Indian states and union territories. The drive will be held daily from 9am to 5pm, except on the days earmarked for routine immunisation programmes.
On average, perceived destitution (financial condition being well below average) is 3.4 times more widespread than perceived opulence (financial condition being well above average) in India.(PTI image)
On average, perceived destitution (financial condition being well below average) is 3.4 times more widespread than perceived opulence (financial condition being well above average) in India.(PTI image)

Number Theory: How much does an average Indian earn?

By Abhishek Jha, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:00 AM IST
The average annual per capita income of households interviewed in the LASI survey conducted in 2017-18 is 44,901. This is just about 39% of the per capita income in the same year according to the National Account Statistics
Close
Former Haryana CM Bhupinder Singh Hooda
Former Haryana CM Bhupinder Singh Hooda

Farm laws: Bhupinder Hooda, other Congress leaders taken into custody over march

ANI
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 07:54 AM IST
Hooda along with state party chief Kumari Selja, general secretary Randeep Surjewala and other party leaders were taken into preventive detention here by the Chandigarh Police and first taken to the Sector 3 police station.
Close
Kumari Selja said JJP and the BJP will have to pay a heavy political price in Haryana for supporting the farm laws(HT FILE)
Kumari Selja said JJP and the BJP will have to pay a heavy political price in Haryana for supporting the farm laws(HT FILE)

‘We are not in the game of greed for power’: Kumari Selja

By Hitender Rao, Chandigarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 07:43 AM IST
  • Haryana Congress chief Kumari Selja said that she hoped that Jannayak Janta Party (JJP) MLAs and Independents would vote against the Khattar government in Haryana assembly.
Close
A priest offers prayers after the first consignment of Covid vaccine arrives at a storage facility in Ajmer.(PTI)
A priest offers prayers after the first consignment of Covid vaccine arrives at a storage facility in Ajmer.(PTI)

Sanitation workers, Padma awardee doctor, MP: List of 1st vaccine beneficiaries

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:27 AM IST
Initially, several state politicians showed interest in getting the jabs first in an attempt to allay any fear among people. But in his last interaction with the states, Prime Minister Narendra Modi made it clear that the priority will be healthcare workers and not politicians.
Close
Kamal Morarka had a keen interest in sports and served as vice-president of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) and vice-president of the Rajasthan Cricket Association.(Twitter)
Kamal Morarka had a keen interest in sports and served as vice-president of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) and vice-president of the Rajasthan Cricket Association.(Twitter)

Former minister Kamal Morarka dies at age of 74

PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 06:56 AM IST
Kamal Morarka was a Union minister in the Chandra Shekhar government in 1990-91 and a Rajya Sabha member from Rajasthan from Janata Dal (Secular) during 1988-94.
Close
A farmer sitting during an ongoing farmer's protest against the new farm laws, at the Delhi-Ghazipur border in New Delhi. (ANI)
A farmer sitting during an ongoing farmer's protest against the new farm laws, at the Delhi-Ghazipur border in New Delhi. (ANI)

Farmers' protest : 9th round of talks inconclusive, next meeting on Jan 19

By hindustantimes.com
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 08:14 AM IST
The farm unions representing tens of thousands of farmers, mainly from Punjab and Haryana, who have launched a mass agitation on the borders of the national capital, are demanding that the government scrap three laws approved by Parliament in September.
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP