HT Image
HT Image

Spot the Stalinist

So long as they are prepared to honour the verdict of free and fair elections, the BJP is not ‘fascist’, and the CPI(M) is not ‘Stalinist’, writes Ramachandra Guha.
By History matters | Ramachandra Guha | Hindustan Times
UPDATED ON JUL 16, 2008 05:57 PM IST

Some years ago, in an essay I published in a Delhi magazine, I argued that although there were very many bigots in the BJP, it was mistaken to see it as ‘fascist’. My reason for rejecting that label was that despite its views and orientations, the BJP had called a general election in the summer of 2004 and, when it lost the popular mandate, moved out of office and allowed the Congress-led UPA to take over the reins of government. If fascists call elections (which is rare), they take care to doctor them. Only death or defeat — whether at war, as with Adolf Hitler, or at the hands of a popular uprising, as with the Duvaliers of Haiti — has put paid to the political powers of totalitarian dictators.

My claim that despite its bigotry and intolerance the BJP was not fascist was met with rousing indignation by intellectuals of the Left. Letters were written to the magazine denouncing me as a right-wing reactionary. One young Marxist journalist went so far as to carry out a campaign among her colleagues to stop them from buying my books.

The fact that the RSS was modelled on paramilitary organisations promoted by Mussolini in Italy and by Hitler in Germany; that the demonisation of the Muslims was conducted in language similar to the Nazi villification of the Jews; that the BJP poster boy Narendra Modi had marked authoritarian tendencies; and that in Modi’s Gujarat, Muslims were marginalised, victimised, ghettoised, and brutalised — all these were for the Leftist intellectual proof enough that the BJP and its constituent elements were indeed ‘fascist’. Anyone who argued otherwise had (since to think in black and white categories is, to the Marxist intellectual, second nature) both betrayed humanity and played into the hands of the enemies on the right.

I, too, know of the European precedents of the desi swayamsewak; I too deplore their treatment of Muslims as second or third class citizens; and I too think that the conduct of Narendra Modi during and after the Gujarat pogrom of 2002 was a blot on Indian democracy. But I would still urge caution in borrowing terms generated by a very different historical context. The BJP is insular; the RSS is bigoted. I would still not call them ‘fascist’.

By the same token, I do not consider the CPI(M) to be ‘Stalinist’, although that label is often used to describe them by Hindutva ideologues as well as by independent leftists. To be sure, the CPM publicly admires and even venerates Joseph Stalin. His is one of the four portraits that adorn the backdrop in a party congress (the others being Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, and V.I. Lenin). And it is certainly true that the thought and practice of the CPI(M) is at times strikingly reminiscent of the tactics of Stalinist parties. Here, I am thinking especially of their doctoring of history.

In the CPI(M)’s rendering of 20th century Russian history, there was no Gulag, no mass extermination of peasants resisting collectivisation, no jailing or killing of dissident intellectuals. In their rendering of 20th century global history, the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 was a liberation from imperialism, the construction of puppet regimes in Eastern Europe in the late 1940s a victory for democracy and socialism.

These distortions are well known, and rightly deplored. The CPI(M)’s distortions of modern Indian history are less frequently commented upon. Historians close to the party have enjoyed a notable success in covering up the tracks of the extraordinary betrayal of the Indian people that occurred during and after the party congress held in Calcutta in March 1948. In books written by them (but often published under respectable mainstream imprints), the events of 1948-9 are represented in terms of ‘the brutal repression by the state’ of a popular peasant uprising. In fact, led by their new General Secretary B.T. Ranadive, and egged on from afar by the Soviet Union, the (then undivided) Communist Party of India declared war on the nascent Indian State. What were the officials of this State to do — lie on their backs and allow the communists to trample on them and plant the Red Flag in New Delhi?

The leaders and intellectuals allied to the CPI(M) are dogmatic and intolerant of dissent. They tend to be economical with the truth. They have slavishly worshipped some of the most brutal regimes in history. Still, they are not Stalinist. For, like the alleged ‘fascists’ on the other side, they have chosen to work within the political system mandated by the Indian Constitution, that is, multi-party democracy. In Kerala and Tripura, the CPI(M) has shown no hesitation in moving out of office when it is defeated in an election. There is no reason to believe that it would not do the same were it to lose the popular mandate in West Bengal.

The BJP is yet to disavow the ideal of the Hindu Rashtra, of a political system based on a single authorised interpretation of a particular religious tradition. The CPI(M) is yet to formally turn its back on the idea of a one-party Communist State. (Its official position is that in the present capitalist system, it has to work with other parties; but that in a future Socialist Utopia it shall be wholly in charge.) But so long as they are prepared to honour the verdict of free and fair elections, the BJP is not ‘fascist’, and the CPI(M) is not ‘Stalinist’.

Ramachandra Guha is the author of India after Gandhi

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
A vial of the Russian Sputnik V coronavirus vaccine is pictured in Belgrade, Serbia, (Reuters)
A vial of the Russian Sputnik V coronavirus vaccine is pictured in Belgrade, Serbia, (Reuters)

Russian Sputnik vaccine gets phase 3 trials approval in India

PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:11 PM IST
In its report, the Board concluded that no safety concerns were identified and the study met the primary endpoints of safety.
Close
People watch the live telecast of Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressing the nation on the launch of Covid -19 vaccination drive, at District Hospital in Varanasi, Saturday, Jan. 16, 2021.(PTI)
People watch the live telecast of Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressing the nation on the launch of Covid -19 vaccination drive, at District Hospital in Varanasi, Saturday, Jan. 16, 2021.(PTI)

'Defining victory in war against virus': PM Modi launches Covid-19 vaccine drive

PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:07 PM IST
Prime Minister Modi emphasised that “only when our scientists are assured of the power of vaccine, they gave permission for emergency use”, asking people not to pay heed to speculations about the efficacy of the shots.
Close
**EDS: VIDEO GRAB FROM OFFICIAL YOUTUBE CHANNEL OF PM MODI** New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi virtually launches pan-India rollout of COVID-19 vaccination drive, in New Delhi, Saturday, Jan. 16, 2021. (PTI Photo)(PTI01_16_2021_000043B)(PTI)
**EDS: VIDEO GRAB FROM OFFICIAL YOUTUBE CHANNEL OF PM MODI** New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi virtually launches pan-India rollout of COVID-19 vaccination drive, in New Delhi, Saturday, Jan. 16, 2021. (PTI Photo)(PTI01_16_2021_000043B)(PTI)

India's vaccine, production capability must be used for human interest: PM Modi

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Susmita Pakrasi, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:58 AM IST
PM Modi said that India is among the few countries which despite hardships, provided medicines and medical help to over 150 countries around the world.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi virtually launches pan-India rollout of COVID-19 vaccination drive, in New Delhi, Saturday, Jan. 16, 2021.(PTI)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi virtually launches pan-India rollout of COVID-19 vaccination drive, in New Delhi, Saturday, Jan. 16, 2021.(PTI)

PM Modi launches Covid-19 vaccine drive in India: Key highlights from his speech

By Saubhadra Chatterji | Edited by Arpan Rai
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:44 AM IST
India launched one of the world’s largest coronavirus vaccination drives on Saturday, setting in motion a complex deployment plan aimed at stemming the wide spread of infections across a nation of more than 1.3 billion people.
Close
Our huge population was not our weakness. We turned it into our strength, PM Modi said, (PTI)
Our huge population was not our weakness. We turned it into our strength, PM Modi said, (PTI)

'Some countries let their people remain in China...': PM Modi's veiled dig

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:47 AM IST
We evacuated not only Indians but also people from other countries under Vande Bharat Mission," PM Modi said.
Close
Children walk on a snow-covered wooden bridge amid dense fog during a cold winter morning, in Srinagar. (ANI Photo)
Children walk on a snow-covered wooden bridge amid dense fog during a cold winter morning, in Srinagar. (ANI Photo)

No end to cold wave at -8.2 degree C in Srinagar, sunny days bring some relief

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Srinagar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:28 AM IST
  • Since the last four days, Srinagar and other parts of Kashmir are observing freezing temperatures and a cold wave.
Close
PM Modi said the coronavirus disease kept people away from their families.(ANI/Twitter)
PM Modi said the coronavirus disease kept people away from their families.(ANI/Twitter)

India's vaccines enjoy global credibility because of their track record: PM Modi

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Susmita Pakrasi, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:03 PM IST
Health workers, people over 50 and those deemed at high-risk are prioritised to receive one of the two approved vaccines.
Close
There is no law or an autonomous body that governs digital content or Over-the-top (OTT) platforms in India(AFP)
There is no law or an autonomous body that governs digital content or Over-the-top (OTT) platforms in India(AFP)

I&B ministry works on self-regulation law for OTT platforms and digital media

UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:49 AM IST
  • The aim is to provide a level-playing field in media and a platform to redress public grievances against digital media
Close
Nidhi Razdan issued a statement to say that she was victim of a phishing attack.(Yogesh Kumar/Hindustan Times )
Nidhi Razdan issued a statement to say that she was victim of a phishing attack.(Yogesh Kumar/Hindustan Times )

Nidhi Razdan phishing attack: Harvard doesn’t have journalism department

By HT Correspondent, Washington
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 10:56 AM IST
  • Razdan said she has lodged a complaint with the police and requested “immediate steps to identify, apprehend and prosecute perpetrators of this abominable attack".
Close
Around 100 beneficiaries will be vaccinated at each session site on the inaugural day, the union health ministry has said.(ANI/Twitter)
Around 100 beneficiaries will be vaccinated at each session site on the inaugural day, the union health ministry has said.(ANI/Twitter)

Don't make mistake of taking off mask after getting 1st dose of vaccine: PM Modi

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Susmita Pakrasi, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 12:05 PM IST
PM Modi added that India's vaccination programme is driven by humanitarian concerns and those exposed to maximum risk get priority.
Close
Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses the nation virtually ahead of the launch of the vaccine drive.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses the nation virtually ahead of the launch of the vaccine drive.

'People should stay away from rumours, propaganda,' PM Modi at vaccine launch

Written by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:51 AM IST
"It takes years to prepare vaccines. But in the shortest span of time, we have not only one but two India-made vaccines," PM Modi said heaping praises on scientists.
Close
Maharashtra CM Uddhav Thackeray addresses the media in Mumbai. (HT FILE PHOTO)
Maharashtra CM Uddhav Thackeray addresses the media in Mumbai. (HT FILE PHOTO)

CM Uddhav Thackeray to launch Maharashtra’s vaccination drive soon

By Sagar Pillai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 10:27 AM IST
The launch will follow Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s live video interaction with health care workers. Arrangements for the interaction have been made at Mumbai’s R N Cooper Hospital.
Close
People, not adhering to social distancing norms, at Narwal wholesale vegetable and fruit market, amid coronavirus pandemic, in Jammu.(PTI)
People, not adhering to social distancing norms, at Narwal wholesale vegetable and fruit market, amid coronavirus pandemic, in Jammu.(PTI)

India records 15,158 fresh Covid-19 infections, slightly lower than yesterday

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON JAN 16, 2021 11:02 AM IST
In the last 24 hours, India reported 15,158 fresh infections, slightly lower than Friday, taking the total tally to over 10.54 million.
Close
After implementation of the amended Motor Vehicles (MV) Act since September 1, road accidents and fatalities in the state have started declining.(HT PHOTO.)
After implementation of the amended Motor Vehicles (MV) Act since September 1, road accidents and fatalities in the state have started declining.(HT PHOTO.)

Celebrated biker King Richard killed after collision with camel in Jaisalmer

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Kota
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:32 AM IST
  • Srinivasan had been on several long bike tours and expeditions, travelling to 36 countries and several continents, including America, Europe, Asia and Australia.
Close
Rajya Sabha chairman M Venkaiah Naidu regularly urges the members of the House to speak in their mother tongue. (ANI)
Rajya Sabha chairman M Venkaiah Naidu regularly urges the members of the House to speak in their mother tongue. (ANI)

Sanskrit was the 5th most used language in Rajya Sabha in 2019-20

By Smriti Kak Ramachandran | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 16, 2021 09:03 AM IST
  • While Hindi and English have been mostly used during the proceedings of the House, members preferring to speak in the 21 other scheduled Indian languages has increased to over five times per sitting in 2020 compared to the 14-year period between 2004-17.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP