Choithram Hospital issue: Human rights commission asks DGP to submit report

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has sent a notice to the state director general of police (DGP) asking him to get the matter of Choithram Hospital, not releasing a person’s body to relatives, enquired by an officer posted outside Indore district and submit the report within six weeks.
Updated on May 27, 2015 04:52 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, Indore

The National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has sent a notice to the state director general of police (DGP) asking him to get the matter of Choithram Hospital, not releasing a person’s body to relatives, enquired by an officer posted outside Indore district and submit the report within six weeks.

The notice was served on May 16 last.

Acting on a complaint filed by Subash Mohapatra of Global Human Rights Communications, the NHRC took cognisance of the incident, which took place in July 2013.

Indore police have submitted two reports till now.

The first report, which was submitted by the police on October 21, 2013, was questioned by the petitioner and a notice was issued again on July 29, 2014, to the police.

In response to the answer furnished by the Indore police, which was submitted by SP headquarters, NHRC on May 16 last said that the contents of the report were identical to the earlier report, which was already considered by the commission.

“The report is merely based on police records and thus does not inspire confidence,” the commission stated.

Shankar Basu, a poor driver from Bihar, admitted to the Choithram Hospital on June 30, 2013, by a transporter, died on July 16, 2013.

The hospital refused to hand over the body to family members, as they were not able to pay the bill of Rs 1.25 lakh.

On July 19, 2013, the hospital authorities reported the police that a body is with them. The police did not investigate the matter, nor did they bother to ask the hospital management as to why the body was detained.

“The authorities at Indore’s Choithram Hospital and Research Centre refused to give the body to the family members of a poor driver, who died in the hospital during treatment. The body was detained for non-payment of the medical bill. After three days, the hospital authorities reported the police that a body is with them. The police did not investigate the case, nor did they take any action against the hospital authorities,” Mohapatra alleged in his petition.

The police report submitted to the commission, however, offers a different version.

The report admits that a bill of Rs 1.25 lakh was raised against his name.

“On July 5, 2013, the family members of the driver came to the hospital, but they left the place without any information and did not turn up again. Despite information given by the hospital authorities, the family of the deceased did not respond. The hospital, therefore, informed the police after three days and last rites was performed by Shri Satyaguru Dutt Dharmik Avam Parmarthik Trust, Indore. The report claims that the allegations regarding non-delivery of the body to the family members are baseless and false,” the police report said.

“The enquiry conducted by the Indore police is not appropriate and the police have also not provided us relevant documents such as post-mortem report, panchnama, seizures, statements recorded during the enquiry,” Mohapatra said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    State Correspondent for Chhattisgarh. Reports Maoism, Politics, Mining and important developments from the state. Covered all sorts of extremism in Central India. Reported from Madhya Pradesh for eight years.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • New Delhi: Waterlogging on a road amid monsoon rains, in New Delhi, Thursday, June 30, 2022.

    Traffic snarls in Delhi as rainfall leads to waterlogging. Advisory issued

    Traffic snarled in Delhi as the national capital welcomed the first monsoon showers on Thursday morning bringing much-needed respite from the heat and humidity. The India Meteorological Department announced the arrival of southwest monsoon in Delhi, which usually arrives in the national capital on June 27 and covers the entire country by July 8. Social media was flooded with photographs of waterlogged roads, with commuters complaining about the traffic and some seeking help from police.

  • Vehicles stuck in a heavy traffic jam on a road amid monsoon rains, in New Delhi, Thursday, on June 30, 2022. 

    Photos: 1st monsoon shower in Delhi, traffic jams, waterlogging in several parts

    Delhi received its first monsoon shower on Thursday, providing relief from the scorching heat. Taking to Twitter, the Delhi Traffic Police said, “As per the India Meteorological Department report, Thunderstorm with light to moderate intensity rain and gusty winds would occur over and adjoining areas of entire Delhi. Commuters are advised to plan their journey accordingly.” Barapullah, Ring Road and ITO were among several parts of Delhi that saw heavy traffic due to incessant rainfall.

  • Office-goers had a tough time reaching their workplaces as heavy rain inundated several places, including Industrial Area Phase 1 (in pic), in Chandigarh on Thursday morning. (Keshav Singh/HT)

    First monsoon rain leaves Chandigarh waterlogged

    In the first major spell this monsoon, intense rain for two hours during peak office hours on Thursday morning left Chandigarh and adjoining Panchkula and Mohali towns waterlogged, leading to traffic jams. The India Meteorological Department classifies rain between 64.5mm and 115.5mm as heavy. Till 11.30am, Yamunanagar recorded the highest rainfall in the region with 73mm followed by Chandigarh 68.2mm, Mohali 55mm, Panchkula 49.5mm, Patiala 23mm, Ambala 15 mm and trace rain in Ludhiana.

  • Representational image.

    Three members of a family, driver found dead in Mumbai’s Kandivali West

    Three members of a family and their driver were found dead late on Wednesday in Mumbai's Kandivali West, which the police suspect was a deliberate act by the driver who allegedly killed the three before ending his life.

  • Bihar: College asks students to use phone torch to write exam amid power crisis

    Bihar: College asks students to use phone torch to write exam amid power crisis

    Students of a prominent college in Bihar's Munger city were allegedly allowed to write exams using their mobile phone torchlight. The incident was reported from RD & DJ College, Munger on Wednesday when the power had tripped due to inclement weather and the college generator was not functioning either. Another examinee without disclosing his identity said, “The college and university here are playing a cruel joke with students.”

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, June 30, 2022