Media trial in Sushant Singh Rajput case: Bombay high court says journalists have lost their neutrality

Published on Oct 23, 2020 11:41 PM IST
HT Image
HT Image
ByK A Y Dodhiya

The Bombay high court (HC) did not mince words while pointing out to the fact that journalists today have lost their neutrality and the media has become polarised. The observations were made by the bench of chief justice Dipankar Datta and justice Girish Kulkarni on Friday while hearing public interest litigations against the media trial in the Sushant Singh Rajput death case. The court was prompted to make the observations after the advocate of one of the respondent channels submitted a report authored in 1947 by a European institute, which analysed options between self-regulation and statutory regulation for the media, and concluded that there was no need for government control.

While clarifying that the channel was not guilty of the allegations made by the petitioners as it was not named by any of the petitions, advocate Ankit Lohia appearing for Zee News, however, said that he wanted make submissions in support of the contentions of other channels that there was no need for government interference in functioning of channels. He cited a 1947 report of a European institute and stated that the report had made it clear that the media should self-regulate instead of any statutory regulation.

The chief justice made an observation on the submissions of Lohia and said, “We are ruled by the rule of law. In India there is a rule of law, right? How do you advocate that people who go around accusing others can find shelter of freedom of press? Journalists back then were responsible and neutral, now the media is polarised.”

Justice Kulkarni then questioned Lohia why he referred to the 1947 report and not to the 1983 Law Commission report which had compared the media regulation model of India with that of European countries and had suggested that there was a need for checks and balances in the functioning of the media in India.

After Lohia responded to the query stating that the media was not averse to being regulated, the bench observed, “This is not a question of regulation. This is a question of checks and balances. People forget where to draw lines. Do it within lines. You [news media] want to criticise government, do it. The issue in the present case is that someone has died and the allegation is you are interfering.”

Thereafter, senior advocate Alankar Kirpekar for India TV and advocate Zeeshan Hashmi for News Nation channels also made submissions and drew the attention of the court to the fact that the media trial in the actor’s death case was a one of an instance, and hence the court should not insist on having statutory regulation on the media. They even submitted that the media was controlled by the government in countries such as China and Bangladesh, as a result of which, their independence was ranked very low internationally.

Meanwhile, additional solicitor general Anil Singh, representing the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) and Enforcement Directorate (ED) stated that the petitioners’ claims about information pertaining to the investigation in Rajput’s death case being leaked to selective media was misconceived and the three agencies had categorically denied the allegation through their affidavit.

On the request of one of the petitioners, the court agreed to have further hearing in the matter next week on October 29.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • screengrab from the video

    Gurugram club manager, bouncers arrested after late night brawl

    The manager of Club Casa Danza in Udyog Vihar was arrested by Gurugram police after a late-night brawl that took place on the intervening night of August 7-8 between the bouncers and a group of friends who had visited the club. Bouncers Sonu, Mandeep, Sumit, Nitin, Ram Singh & Rakesh -- also accused of snatching cash -- were arrested, as reported by news agency ANI.

  • Over 3,500kg of explosives will be filled within 9,400 holes drilled in the columns and shears of the nearly 100m-tall twin towers.

    Further delay in blast may cause collapse of Noida towers: Agency

    Over 3,500kg of explosives will be filled within 9,400 holes drilled in the columns and shears of the nearly 100m-tall twin towers. Holes have been drilled in nearly every column of the tower on every floor, adding upto a total of over 15km in length, the status report by Edifice Engineering said.

  • IMD in its initial forecast for Independence Day also said that light rain is expected in the morning. (Raj K Raj/HT PHOTO)

    Capital hot and humid again; Met predicts light rain, mercury drop

    RK Jenamani, scientist at IMD, said the monsoon trough was in central India and fairly south of Delhi at present; however, two active weather systems – one on the Gujarat coast and the other over central MP--were leading to a low-pressure area and the movement of easterly winds towards Delhi.

  • The prison department, however, did not release the names or profiles of the convicts who are stitching the Tricolour inside the jail. (HT PHOTO.)

    Aug 15 ahead, Tihar convicts roped in to stitch national flags

    Jail officials also said that this Independence Day, at least 21 prisoners are set to be released under a “special remission scheme” announced by the ministry of home affairs on the occasion of Azadi Ka Amrit Mahotsav. Previously, convicts were only granted remission (reduction in sentence or jail term days counted as added to a prisoner’s record) on Independence Day.

  • MCG officials said that the Haryana Urban Local Bodies’ order will affect 130 licensed meat shops in Gurugram.

    35 teams to enforce week-long ban on meat in Gurugram

    Vijaypal Yadav, joint commissioner of MCG, said that the 35 teams, comprising four members each, will be deployed across as many municipal wards in the city, adding that anyone found violating the order will have to pay a penalty of 5,000.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now