Mumbaiites work hard but don’t have a life

Updated on Jun 07, 2018 11:45 AM IST
An average Mumbai employee clocked in 3,315 hours a year at work, the most in any of the 77 cities studied, and took the least number of days of vacation – barely 10 a year – compared to other cities.
Commuters at Andheri Station in Mumbai.(HT File)
Commuters at Andheri Station in Mumbai.(HT File)
Hindustan Times | By

We in Mumbai work the highest number of hours in a year, according to the findings of a global study released earlier this week. Most Mumbaiites will shrug their shoulders and remark that it is, after all, their lived experience and they did not need the Swiss investment bank, UBS, to tell them so. In fact, the reality may well be harsher than the study findings.

An average Mumbai employee clocked in 3,315 hours a year at work, the most in any of the 77 cities studied, and took the least number of days of vacation – barely 10 a year – compared to other cities. However, it still did not bring him or her enough income to afford an iPhone X with ease. The average Mumbai employee would have to would have to work for over 915 hours to afford the aspirational must-have gadget for millennials across the world. That’s tough work indeed when a New Yorker can afford it with only 54 hours of work or an employee in Zurich – the best off in this regard – with barely 38 hours of work.

That the value of work is measured by a high-value device itself says a great deal about the scope of the study as also about aspirations of millennials. All these years, the UBS’ studies measured affordability by the hours an employee needed to put in anywhere in the world, to by a Big Mac burger. The study examined 15 professions which best represent the natural workforce composition of a European country. To that extent, it would be a limited marker for Asian cities including Mumbai.

But here’s the nub. The study still seems to under-estimate the number of hours an average Mumbaiite puts in at work in a day, say labour researchers​. Break down the numbers: if we factor in 10 days of vacation in a year into the 3,315 hours a year, it would mean an average Mumbai employee works for about 9.33 hours a day. Calculate the vacation and weekly-offs together at 62 days a year and he or she would be clocking a little more than 10 hours a day.

This is about three-quarter of a day’s work for most people in the formal sector, the sort that the study would have looked at. We know from experience and observation that most employees put in a good 12-14 hours a day at work across sectors such as finance, banking, entertainment, IT and IT-enabled services, medical and hospitality. The informal sector is worse; a 14-hour work day is par for the course for most workers across transport, construction, street vendors, domestic work and the like.

Then, the hours of work do not encapsulate working conditions or the long hours spent getting to the workplace and back home in Mumbai. Across the informal sector and even in some formal sector jobs, the working conditions do not meet the basic standards of the International Labour Organisation (ILO), which describes ‘decent work’ as that which offers opportunities for income growth, respects rights of employees or workers, extends social protection and provides for strong social bonds or dialogues. By these standards, very few kinds of work opportunities in Mumbai, perhaps the few at the top-most rungs of a handful of industries, would qualify as decent work.

But the important aspect of long working hours is altogether missed here. That was not perhaps in the scope of the study but the length of a work day would have to be evaluated by the income earned and the quality of life it affords an employee or worker. Those in the lowest income groups work long hours too but are unable to access even basic housing in Mumbai. Doesn’t this say a great deal about work and life in the city?

​ We aren’t even thinking about the iPhone X.​

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    When the Siddhartha Vihar Hostel in Wadala was brought down, floor by floor, in early February by the BMC, a piece of Mumbai’s history associated with Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar was obliterated.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Tyagi allegedly encroached upon a portion of the common area. (HT PHOTO)

    Illegal encroachments of Noida man demolished days after he abused neighbour

    Authorities on Monday demolished Noida Sector 93B resident Shrikant Tyagi's encroachments at Grand Omaxe residential society days after he was booked for assaulting and abusing a woman neighbour for objecting to them. “The Noida Authority hired workers, who demolished an illegal structure using handheld hammers. A bulldozer was also used to break the fibre glass structure put up at his... veranda,” said an official.

  • Gehlot also urged to increase financial assistance of the Centre in various centrally sponsored schemes. (File image)

    Declare ERCP as national project, Rajasthan CM Gehlot at NITI Aayog meeting

    Rajasthan chief minister Ashok Gehlot on Sunday demanded that the government of India (GoI) should declare Eastern Rajasthan Canal Project as a national project. In the 7th meeting of the Governing Council of the NITI Aayog held on Sunday, he also urged to increase financial assistance of the Centre in various centrally sponsored schemes. The meeting was chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

  • The injured woman being taken to hospital by RPF staff. (Image source: RPF S.W.Railway/Twitter)

    Bengaluru: Woman injured by goods train at Yelahanka Railway Station

    An unidentified woman suffered a 'major' injury after being hit by a goods train at Bengaluru's Yelahanka Railway Station Sunday. Staff from the Railway Protection Force acted promptly by giving her first aid treatment and then shifting her to a hospital for further treatment. It is not clear how the injury occurred.

  • The tenure of the 587 Village Committees (VCs) ended on March 7, 2021. (File image)

    Prior to 2023 state polls, Tripura parties prepare for village panel elections

    Ahead of the assembly polls scheduled to be held in 2023, the political parties of Tripura are gearing up for the upcoming village committee polls of the autonomous district council. The High Court of Tripura, in a recent verdict, requested the state government to announce the schedule of village committee polls of Tripura Tribal Areas Autonomous District Council and complete the poll process with declaration of results by first week of November.

  • The murder took place in G block locality of Shastri Nagar under Nauchandi police station. (File image)

    Wife, granddaughter of retired cop killed in Meerut; robbery suspected: Police

    In a tragic incident, the wife of a retired head constable and their granddaughter were killed by unknown assailants in their Meerut house on Sunday, police said. The murder took place in G block locality of Shastri Nagar under Nauchandi police station. Circle officer of Civil lines area Devendra Singh said police teams were on the spot and investigating the incident. The former policeman's wife and their 12-year-old granddaughter were also in the house.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 08, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now