Women and worship: Time to shatter all patriarchal ceilings

Updated on Dec 05, 2016 09:49 AM IST
There is no ban on women worshippers at Mumbai’s other popular dargahs, Makhdoom Ali Mahimi, at Mahim, though this shrine shares some trustees with the Haji Ali dargah. The Nizamuddin and Qutbuddin Baktiyar Kaki shrines in Delhi do not give women full access, but the country’s most famous Sufi shrine, the Moinuddin Chisti dargah at Ajmer, has no such restrictions
Women offer prayers at the sanctum sanctorum inside Haji Ali dargah.(HT Photo)
Women offer prayers at the sanctum sanctorum inside Haji Ali dargah.(HT Photo)
Hindustan Times | By

Dargahs are among the most egalitarian of religious shrines: While some have restrictions on entry of women – or men – most do not discriminate. The rituals are simple and are not dictated by theology; singing, dancing, sharing food – even esoteric ceremonies – is part of the worship. You do not have to be a Muslim to ask the saint interred in the shrine to pray to God on your behalf.

In 2012, when a group of women were turned away from the inner sanctum of Mumbai’s Haji Ali dargah, the portals of the shrine were no longer so welcoming. The shrine trust justified the ban, explaining that shariat (religious laws) prohibited women from touching the tomb, but worshippers said there were not such restrictions till 2011. The shrine trust’s attempt to defend its discriminatory order made no sense.

There is no ban on women worshippers at Mumbai’s other popular dargahs, Makhdoom Ali Mahimi, at Mahim, though this shrine shares some trustees with the Haji Ali dargah. The Nizamuddin and Qutbuddin Baktiyar Kaki shrines in Delhi do not give women full access, but the country’s most famous Sufi shrine, the Moinuddin Chisti dargah at Ajmer, has no such restrictions. The rule on entry of women, dargah caretakers have said, is based on tradition.

When talks with the shrine trustees did not solve the matter, the women contacted the National Commission for Minorities, the National Commission for Women and ministers. In August 2014, they petitioned the Bombay High Court. After eight hearings, the court struck down the ban on women’s entry into the sanctum. The trust challenged the order in the Supreme Court, only to tell the apex court that they have, as a ‘progressive step’, decided to lift the ban.

On Tuesday, over a hundred women, walked along the narrow causeway that links the rocky islet housing the shrine to the city, and entered the chamber that holds the marble-covered tomb of Pir Haji Ali, Shah Bukhari, a 14th century trader who gave away his wealth and died a pauper. As the women prayed, a Qawwali group sat in the shrine’s courtyard, singing ‘Piya Haji Ali’ in praise of the saint.

For Muslim women, the judgment is more than just a permission to enter the sanctum of a religious shrine; their success has laid down the path for more fights against discriminatory social laws.

“The event touches a sensitive spot – the situation of women in religion,” said Astrid Lobo Gajiwala, a doctor and a lay Catholic theologian, in an article she wrote. “While the second class status of women in society is openly acknowledged and addressed the discrimination against women in religions is usually excused and justified with claims of it being divinely ordained.”

By taking on patriarchal diktats, the Haji Ali petitioners have set the agenda for more reforms – in religious and marital laws. After their victory, the groups that supported the campaign said that their next fight will be to get triple talaq banned.

The women from Bharatiya Muslim Mahila Andolan (BMMA), which had filed the petition, and their supporters like the Haji Ali Sab Ke Liye Forum have said that the case is a precedent. Noorjehan Safia Niaz, co-founder of BMMA had said that the order was a victory for democratic values, women’s power, Constitutional values and Koranic values.

The petitioners had said that they were happy that the dispute went to the Supreme Court. The petition’s passage though the country’s apex court has ensured that the case will have national repercussions.

Lobo Gajiwala, who supports the ordaining of Catholic women as priests, said that the Haji Ali order gives hope about reforms in their church. “For Indian Catholic women the triumph of their Muslim and Hindu sisters - at Shani Shingnapur - poses an interesting question: Is the exclusion of women from ordination a form of gender discrimination that can be changed through a judicial process? Can they file a PIL like their Hindu and Muslim sisters?”

Read

Women entering Haji Ali will inspire more fights against discriminatory social laws

Women finally enter inner sanctum of Mumbai’s Haji Ali Dargah

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR

    Manoj R Nair is part of Hindustan Times’ nationwide network of correspondents that brings news, analysis and information to its readers.

Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Instances of heinous crimes such as murder, robbery, kidnapping for ransom saw an almost 13% increase in the first six months of 2022 compared to the corresponding period last year. (Representational image/HT Archive)

    Crime in Delhi up by over 8%: Delhi Police data

    Cases of crime reported in Delhi till July 15 this year increased by 8.1%, compared to the same period last year, according to statistics shared by the Delhi Police on Wednesday, showing a broad increase across most categories in 2022. In 2021, in fact, a total of 2,485 home burglaries were reported for the entire year. Cases of non-heinous crimes, such as snatching, burglary and vehicle theft, too went up by 8%.

  • The border belt has seen over 20 drone-drops --- used for smuggling weapons, ammo and drugs from across the border --- in the past seven months. (HT PHOTO)

    Four pistols, 8 magazines seized from Pakistan border in Amritsar

    Police have recovered four pistols and their ammunition, believed to be dropped by a drone in the Lopoke area of the district near the India-Pakistan border. A team led by Lopoke police station in-charge Mantej Singh, launched a search operation in the area where the drone was spotted. More than 20 incidents of drone movements and smuggling of weapons and drugs at the Punjab border with Pakistan have been reported in this year.

  • An interstate gang involved in ATM fraud was busted with the arrest of three of its members in Pathankot. (HT PHOTO)

    ATM fraud: Three arrested with 66 cards, swipe machine in Pathankot

    An interstate gang involved in ATM fraud was busted with the arrest of three of its members in Pathankot on Wednesday. The accused – Ramesh Kumar, Pareen and Sikander of Hisar in Haryana – were arrested during a special operation. As many as 66 ATM cards, 19,000 cash, and a swipe machine were seized from the accused. Their SUV was also impounded.

  • With 11,000 of the 90,000 subsidised machines supplied to farmers over the last four years for in-situ stubble management missing, the Punjab agricultural department has decided to rope in the VB to look into the matter and take action (HT File)

    In-situ stubble management: 11,000 machines go missing in Punjab, agri dept pushes for VB action

    With 11,000 of the 90,000 subsidised machines supplied to farmers over the last four years for in-situ stubble management missing, the Punjab agricultural department has decided to rope in the vigilance bureau to look into the matter and take action. The loss incurred has been pegged at ₹140 crore, as per the agricultural department's preliminary investigation. It is likely that action will be taken against machine manufacturers, dealers, users and some department officials.

  • A day after three men were arrested with arms and explosives, police on Wednesday said the accused would send money earned from the sale of drugs to their Pakistan-based handlers through hawala channel (HT PHOTO)

    Trio held with RDX sent drug money to Pakistan via hawala channel: Punjab Police

    A day after three men were arrested with arms and explosives, police on Wednesday said the accused would send money earned from the sale of drugs to their Pakistan-based handlers through hawala channel. Their car, a Mitsubishi Lancer, was also impounded. The arrested accused had also been in contact with head of banned outfit International Sikh Youth Federation, Lakhbir Singh Rode. Rode is suspected to be living in Lahore.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 11, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now