A-still-from-Carol
A-still-from-Carol

Carol to Nahid: Is Cannes 2015 obsessed with marital rift?

Pray, what is wrong with world cinema? And, pray, what is wrong with the Cannes Film Festival that it ought to have chosen such similar themes. Men and women in unhappy relationships -- and using their own children as pawns in a cruel game of chess.
By Gautaman Bhaskaran | Hindustan Times, Cannes
UPDATED ON MAY 18, 2015 04:57 PM IST
Pray, what is wrong with world cinema? And, pray, what is wrong with the Cannes Film Festival that it ought to have chosen such similar themes. Men and women in unhappy relationships -- and using their own children as pawns in a cruel game of chess.



In about the first three days of the Festival's ongoing 68th edition, I saw the same plot repeat in a movie from Iran, in one from the US and the third from France. Each of these had men calling the shots or thereabouts.



Obviously, cinema across continents is running out of ideas. Or, is it that man-woman marital rift is getting to be so widespread that films find it hard to ignore this aspect of human relationship.



American auteur Todd Haynes' Carol (with Cate Blanchett) is set in the winter of 1952, in New York. It is Christmas, but there is no joy in the life of the upperclass socialite, Carol (Blanchett). And when she meets a young lowly shop assistant, Therese, the older woman is attracted. With Carol's divorce with a successful businessman imminent, she plunges into a lesbian relationship with Therese -- who leaves her steady boyfriend to be with the rich woman. Caught in all this drama is Carol's young daughter, who is bewildered at her mama and papa fighting over her custody. In the end, Carol ends the war by telling her husband that they ought not to quarrel over that one precious thing which the two had created out of love. Their daughter.



Watch trailer:





Cannes then takes us to Iran, where Ida Panahandeh's Nahid is also about a separated couple -- with the custody of their son going to the mother on the explicit condition that she will not remarry. But who is to say how the heart will behave. When the debt-ridden Nahid (Sareh Bayat) meets Masood (Pejman Bazeghi), a well-to-do businessman, she flips for him. And when her ex-husband finds out about this, he takes away the boy. Like Carol, Nahid is extremely well enacted, wonderfully crafted and mounted with feeling. But then the subject is so cliched now, and neither Panahandeh nor Haynes can inject any novelty into their stories. Therein the movies slip.



Watch: Nahid trailer





While Carol and Nahid are subtly narrated, French auteur Maiwenn's Mon Roi, is a dramatic take on marital conflict. Here again, a child is involved, and since Tony ( Emmanuelle Bercot) is a lawyer, her husband Georgio (Vincent Cassel) finds it hard to get an upper hand. A cad to the core, he wants Tony (a man's name though) to remain his wife, while he sleeps around with other women with not a care. A classic case of a passionate affair -- where the couple make the most violent love and in such unusual places as kitchen surfaces -- turning horridly sour. Here too the performances are just superb (though a little overboard at times), and the movie has a zing about it. But come on, conflict in marriage and a little child torn apart by this raging adults is all so passe.

I am merely hoping that I do not get around seeing more of such bedroom squabbles in the coming days of the Festival, which will draw its curtain on May 24.

(Gautaman Bhaskaran has been covering the Cannes Film Festival for 26 years.)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Priyanka Chopra has shot for a new episode of Hot Ones.
Priyanka Chopra has shot for a new episode of Hot Ones.

Priyanka Chopra paces around with milk in hand after shooting another Hot Ones

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 02:20 PM IST
Priyanka Chopra has shot for yet another episode of Hot Ones where celebrities are made to gulp down spicy sauces, to test their tolerance for hot food.
Close
The Rajasthan high court's instruction has come on a petition filed by Karan Johar (HT Photo)
The Rajasthan high court's instruction has come on a petition filed by Karan Johar (HT Photo)

Court bars coercive step against Karan Johar in case involving Pandya, KL Rahul

By HT Correspondent, Jodhpur
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:46 PM IST
  • Hardik Pandya and KL Rahul had petitioned the high court last year seeking quashing of the FIR. The court had already given interim protection to both of them from arrest.
Close
Varun Dhawan at the wedding venue.
Varun Dhawan at the wedding venue.

Varun Dhawan arrives at venue ahead of wedding with Natasha Dalal

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:40 PM IST
Ahead of his wedding with Natasha Dalal, Varun Dhawan was seen arriving at his wedding venue, The Mansion House, in Alibaug on Saturday. See pictures here.
Close
Kareena Kapoor in a glimpse from the photo shoot.
Kareena Kapoor in a glimpse from the photo shoot.

Kareena Kapoor is all about style and glamour in an all-black photo shoot. Watch

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:22 PM IST
Kareena Kapoor has shared a video from one of her glamourous photo shoots. She is seen dressed in a black gown with a thigh-high slit.
Close
Audience will ask tough questions to contestants.
Audience will ask tough questions to contestants.

Bigg Boss 14 promo teases a power-packed Weekend Ka Vaar episode, watch

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 12:28 PM IST
Bigg Boss Weekend Ka Vaar will see a number of ex-contestants grace the episode as well as few audience, some of whom will grill the current contestants. Rahul Vaidya, Abhinav Shukla and Rubina Dilaik will be asked some tough questions.
Close
Taapsee Pannu has shared a post about her 2015 film Baby.
Taapsee Pannu has shared a post about her 2015 film Baby.

Taapsee Pannu recalls the 7 minutes that changed the direction of tide for her

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 01:14 PM IST
Taapsee Pannu has talked about her short role in Akshay Kumar's 2015 film Baby. She said it changed the direction of tide for her.
Close
Akshay Kumar has shared a new still from Bachchan Pandey.
Akshay Kumar has shared a new still from Bachchan Pandey.

Akshay Kumar announces Bachchan Pandey release date with new still

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:23 AM IST
Akshay Kumar has booked Republic Day holiday in 2022 for his upcoming film, Bachchan Pandey. He plays a dreaded gangster in the film.
Close
Here are top entertainment news stories.
Here are top entertainment news stories.

Jasmin Bhasin may return on Bigg Boss 14, Nick Jonas praises The White Tiger

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:01 AM IST
From news reports about Jasmin Bhasin returning to the Bigg Boss 14 house to Priyanka Chopra's The White Tiger earning praise from her husband Nick Jonas, here are top entertainment news stories.
Close
Having shot for ‘Mirzapur’ and ‘Raktanchal’ in Varanasi and Lucknow, actor Pramod Pathak will next shoot in Kanpur. (Sourced photo)
Having shot for ‘Mirzapur’ and ‘Raktanchal’ in Varanasi and Lucknow, actor Pramod Pathak will next shoot in Kanpur. (Sourced photo)

Pramod Pathak: I’ll shoot in my Kanpur from next month

By Deep Saxena
UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:46 AM IST
UPite Pramod Pathak’s role of JP Yadav in both seasons of ‘Mirzapur’ and Tripurari in ‘Raktanchal’ gave him what his 25-year-long career could not.
Close
Actor Kirti Kulhari will be next seen in the direct to OTT release The Girl on the Train.
Actor Kirti Kulhari will be next seen in the direct to OTT release The Girl on the Train.

Kirti Kulhari on web censorship: It comes in the way of complete freedom of expression, I’m not in favour of that

By Rishabh Suri
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:44 AM IST
Actor Kirti Kulhari who was seen in two successful web series in 2020 — Four More Shots Please season 2 and Criminal Justice Behind The Doors — admits that Indian artistes owe a lot to OTT through which their work is reaching the world.
Close
Hrithik Roshan has shared his new look.
Hrithik Roshan has shared his new look.

Hrithik Roshan shares bearded look from new commercial, see pic

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:44 AM IST
Hrithik Roshan has shared the advertisement of a beard grooming brand which features him in a bearded avatar, enough to be declared as the 'sexiest don alive'.
Close
Naina Singh was last seen in Bigg Boss-14 House. (Sourced)
Naina Singh was last seen in Bigg Boss-14 House. (Sourced)

Naina Singh: One cannot hide their real persona on screen

By S Farah Rizvi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:43 AM IST
Hailing from Moradabad, reality TV star Naina Singh feels it’s tougher to be yourself on screen instead of playing a reel-life character.
Close
Salman Khan has been shooting for Antim for some time now.(Varinder Chawla)
Salman Khan has been shooting for Antim for some time now.(Varinder Chawla)

Salman Khan, Mahesh Manjrekar spotted post Antim shoot, see here

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:32 AM IST
Actor Salman Khan, Pragya Jaiswal and actor-filmmaker Mahesh Manjrekar were spotted in Mumbai, after the shoot of Salman's upcoming film, Antim. See pictures here.
Close
Alia Bhatt had been shooting for Gangubai Kathiawadi and RRR towards the end of 2020.
Alia Bhatt had been shooting for Gangubai Kathiawadi and RRR towards the end of 2020.

Alia Bhatt sets the mood for the weekend: 'Can't get out of bed kinda day'

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 09:22 AM IST
Alia Bhatt shared a new selfie of herself while still lazing in the bed. She had been in news recently for her reported hospitalization.
Close
Priyanka Chopra has been promoting her new film, The White Tiger for the last couple of days.
Priyanka Chopra has been promoting her new film, The White Tiger for the last couple of days.

Priyanka Chopra thanks Nick Jonas for The White Tiger praise and the wine

UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:52 AM IST
Actor Priyanka Chopra and husband Nick Jonas celebrated the release of her film, The White Tiger. She took to Instagram to thank him. See her response here.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP