Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, Donald Trump called his remarks at the rally “totally appropriate,” rejecting any blame for the attack(AP)
Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, Donald Trump called his remarks at the rally “totally appropriate,” rejecting any blame for the attack(AP)

Donald Trump may be shielded from riot charges by a previous Supreme Court ruling on a Ku Klux Klan speech case

To make the case that Donald Trump incited the riot, prosecutors would have to show that he intended to provoke violence, but his words are vague enough that it’s possible to argue that he was simply urging his supporters to peacefully protest outside the Capitol.
Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 12, 2021 10:36 PM IST

A 1969 Supreme Court ruling that tossed the conviction of a Ku Klux Klan leader may also shield President Donald Trump from prosecution for inciting last week’s Capitol riot, leaving few alternatives to hold him accountable if impeachment efforts fail.

At the rally preceding the riot, Trump gave an inflammatory speech, urging the crowd to go to the Capitol and demand legislators address his baseless claims of election fraud. He asked his supporters to “show strength” and “fight much harder.” Rudy Giuliani, Donald Trump Jr. and US Representative Mo Brooks also spoke ahead of the riot, which led to five deaths.

Several Democrats and some Republicans have raised the possibility that Trump might be prosecuted for inciting the riot, and Michael Sherwin, the acting US attorney in Washington, fed such speculation when he suggested on Thursday that his office would probe the president’s role. But many legal experts are skeptical charges will be filed against Trump.

“A prosecution is possible but unlikely,” said John Banzhaf, a law professor at George Washington University. “A conviction would be even less likely.”

‘Imminent Lawless Action’

That’s because the Supreme Court said in its landmark decision in Brandenburg v. Ohio that the constitutional right to free speech protects inflammatory rhetoric unless it’s intended to incite “imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action.” The ruling overturned the conviction of Clarence Brandenburg, an Ohio Klan leader who had been prosecuted under a state law for making a speech in which he advocated violence against African Americans and Jews.

The case, in which the American Civil Liberties Union(ACLU) represented Brandenburg, set a high bar for criminal prosecutions of inflammatory speech. To make the case that Trump incited the riot, prosecutors would have to show that he intended to provoke violence, but his words are vague enough that it’s possible to argue that he was simply urging his supporters to peacefully protest outside the Capitol.

“Intention to incite is always difficult to show,” said Shirin Sinnar, a law professor at Stanford who studies the legal treatment of political violence. “A lot of the evidence here can be interpreted in different ways.”

Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, Trump called his remarks at the rally “totally appropriate,” rejecting any blame for the attack. He instead cast efforts to impeach him as a “terrible thing” that was causing “tremendous anger.”

To prove intent, prosecutors could parse the language Trump used in his speech, highlighting particular words or phrases that seem to urge violence. They could also point to Trump’s comments in a video released only after police had started regaining control of the Capitol: “We love you, you’re very special.”

‘Trial by Combat’

Still, those comments are “a far cry from inciting violence,” said Ediberto Roman, a professor at Florida International University College of Law. Giuliani, who called for “trial by combat” to settle the president’s election-fraud claims,” was “far closer to promoting violence,” Roman said, though the former New York mayor would also be hard to successfully prosecute.

The “high crimes and misdemeanors” standard to impeach the President under the Constitution is more flexible, and several Trump allies like former New Jersey Governor Chris Christie have said he clearly committed an impeachable offence by encouraging the rioters. House Democrats on Monday introduced a resolution to impeach Trump for inciting the insurrection at the Capitol, setting up a vote this week unless Vice President Mike Pence and a majority of Trump’s cabinet invoke the Constitution’s 25th Amendment to remove Trump.

But it’s unclear how many Republicans will want to take a politically difficult vote to remove a president of their own party. Speaking to CNN on Sunday, US Senator Pat Toomey suggested criminal prosecution might be an alternative to impeachment in terms of holding Trump accountable.

Federal prosecutors have so far sent mixed signals. Though Sherwin emphasized that the Justice Department was scrutinizing “all actors,” his top deputy, Ken Kohl, said the following day that he did not expect charges against people who gave speeches at the rally. Ultimately, however, the decision whether or not to prosecute Trump will be up to the leaders of the Justice Department under President-elect Joe Biden, who has said he will nominate federal appeals court judge Merrick Garland to be attorney general.

White House Subpoenas

Some former prosecutors say Trump’s actions offer enough evidence of intent to justify at least an investigation. A grand jury could subpoena internal White House communications to help US prosecutors determine whether Trump or his associates knew that some of the rioters had come to Washington intent on committing violence.

“I wouldn’t say it’s a slam dunk, but if I’m a prosecutor, I feel pretty good about my proof of intent,” said Randall Eliason, a former assistant US attorney in Washington. “This crowd did exactly what Trump wanted.”

It’s the same kind of evidence that prosecutors are currently scouring concerning people that directly participated in the riot. If they can find rioters conspired with one another, they’ll use social media posts, email and phone communications, police observations of rioters’ behavior and communications to try to prove their cases, said Mike Shepard, a former Justice Department official.

Federal prosecutors have already charged more than 50 participants in the Capitol siege, accusing them of a range of offenses from trespassing to assault, and are also investigating as a murder the death of Capitol Police Officer Brian Sicknick.

​Harry Sandick, a former federal prosecutor, said a number of the rioters could ultimately face charges of participating in a seditious conspiracy, which involves two or more people agreeing to use force to hinder the execution of U.S. law or seize U.S. government property, according to statute. Many rioters seemed to have in mind the goal of stopping Congress from certifying Biden’s election victory.

“There is evidence of coordination on social media by the rioters with each other,” said Sandick. “There are also statements by the rioters that they understood their actions to be at Trump’s request.”


SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
FILE PHOTO: Members of the far-right Proud Boys, including leader Enrique Tarrio (C), rally in support of U.S. President Donald Trump to protest against the results of the 2020 U.S. presidential election, in Washington, U.S. November 14, 2020. REUTERS/Hannah McKay/File Photo(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Members of the far-right Proud Boys, including leader Enrique Tarrio (C), rally in support of U.S. President Donald Trump to protest against the results of the 2020 U.S. presidential election, in Washington, U.S. November 14, 2020. REUTERS/Hannah McKay/File Photo(REUTERS)

Proud Boys leader was ‘prolific’ informer for US law enforcement: Report

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 08:14 PM IST
The Proud Boys were involved in the deadly insurrection at the US Capitol January 6.
Close
The United Nations logo is seen on a window in an empty hallway at United Nations headquarters in New York, US.(Reuters/ File photo)
The United Nations logo is seen on a window in an empty hallway at United Nations headquarters in New York, US.(Reuters/ File photo)

UN experts fault Italy in drownings of over 200 migrants

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 08:09 PM IST
The Human Rights Committee also called on Italian authorities to “proceed with an independent and timely investigation and to prosecute those responsible” for the deaths.
Close
Police officers manage a checkpoint on a road near the Wockhardt pharmaceutical plant in Wrexham, Britain January 27, 2021. REUTERS/Phil Noble(REUTERS)
Police officers manage a checkpoint on a road near the Wockhardt pharmaceutical plant in Wrexham, Britain January 27, 2021. REUTERS/Phil Noble(REUTERS)

UK AstraZeneca vaccine plant partially evacuated over suspect package

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 08:05 PM IST
Local police confirmed that a bomb disposal unit was on site and advised the public to avoid the area.
Close
“USDA and the Biden Administration are committed to bringing relief and support to farmers, ranchers and producers of all backgrounds and financial status, including by ensuring producers have access to temporary debt relief,” Robert Bonnie, the department’s deputy chief of staff, said in a statement.(AP)
“USDA and the Biden Administration are committed to bringing relief and support to farmers, ranchers and producers of all backgrounds and financial status, including by ensuring producers have access to temporary debt relief,” Robert Bonnie, the department’s deputy chief of staff, said in a statement.(AP)

Biden administration to give debt relief to 12,000 farmers

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 07:36 PM IST
The US Department of Agriculture will temporarily suspend past-due debt collections and foreclosures for farmers borrowing under two major loan programs administered by the Farm Service Agency, administration officials said.
Close
India intends to formally complain to Global Affairs Canada (GAC), the country’s foreign ministry, over allowing the pre-planned blockade of the consulate in Vancouver by protestors ostensibly opposing the farm laws. (TWITTER)
India intends to formally complain to Global Affairs Canada (GAC), the country’s foreign ministry, over allowing the pre-planned blockade of the consulate in Vancouver by protestors ostensibly opposing the farm laws. (TWITTER)

India takes up with Italy, Canada incidents outside missions in Rome, Vancouver

PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 07:36 PM IST
  • In Italy, unidentified persons painted the slogan “Khalistan Zindabad” on the facade of the Indian embassy in Rome and put up several pro-Khalistan flags and banners at the gate ahead of Republic Day.
Close
Russian RS-24 Yars ballistic missiles roll in Red Square during the Victory Day military parade marking the 75th anniversary of the Nazi defeat in Moscow.(File Photo / AP)
Russian RS-24 Yars ballistic missiles roll in Red Square during the Victory Day military parade marking the 75th anniversary of the Nazi defeat in Moscow.(File Photo / AP)

New START: All you need to know about US-Russia nuclear arms control treaty

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Kunal Gaurav
UPDATED ON JAN 27, 2021 07:30 PM IST
The last remaining nuclear arms control treaty between Washington and Kremlin was signed by US President Barack Obama and his Russian counterpart Dmitry Medvedev in 2010.
Close
As head of the Environmental Protection Agency, McCarthy signed the Obama administration’s Clean Power Plan
As head of the Environmental Protection Agency, McCarthy signed the Obama administration’s Clean Power Plan

Who’s who on Joe Biden’s sprawling climate team

Bloomberg
UPDATED ON JAN 27, 2021 07:00 PM IST
President Joe Biden has already assembled an unprecedented team of White House climate advisers and installed climate experts in roles that haven’t typically been thought to require environmental expertise, a sign that environmental policy will be central to his administration’s agenda.
Close
The Auschwitz-Birkenau Museum and Memorial preserves the Auschwitz death camp set up on Polish soil by Nazi Germany during World War Two. More than 1.1 million people, most of them Jews, perished in gas chambers at the camp or from starvation, cold and disease.(AP)
The Auschwitz-Birkenau Museum and Memorial preserves the Auschwitz death camp set up on Polish soil by Nazi Germany during World War Two. More than 1.1 million people, most of them Jews, perished in gas chambers at the camp or from starvation, cold and disease.(AP)

Auschwitz marks anniversary virtually as survivors fear end of an era

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:56 PM IST
Survivors and museum officials told Reuters they fear the pandemic could end the era where Auschwitz's former prisoners can tell their own stories to visitors on site. Most Auschwitz survivors are in their eighties and nineties.
Close
China’s leader made the statement in a video conference with Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam on Wednesday.(AFP)
China’s leader made the statement in a video conference with Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam on Wednesday.(AFP)

China’s President Xi says ‘patriots’ should govern Hong Kong

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:55 PM IST
The comments from Xi underscore Beijing’s consistent message that Hong Kong’s lawmakers and civil servants need to be patriotic.
Close
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said earlier this month that he reached the deal with Pfizers chief executive to speed up vaccine deliveries to Israel.(AP)
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said earlier this month that he reached the deal with Pfizers chief executive to speed up vaccine deliveries to Israel.(AP)

Israel to vaccinate all athletes for Tokyo Olympics by May

Reuters
UPDATED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:23 PM IST
International Olympic Committee (IOC) President Thomas Bach has said that although participants will be encouraged to get vaccinated, it will not be mandatory.
Close
"Most probably, they will be taken to Chittagong tomorrow and the next day, they will be sent to Bhasan char from there," Navy Commodore Abdullah Al Mamun Chowdhury told Reuters
"Most probably, they will be taken to Chittagong tomorrow and the next day, they will be sent to Bhasan char from there," Navy Commodore Abdullah Al Mamun Chowdhury told Reuters

Bangladesh to move 2,000-3,000 more Rohingyas to remote island this week

Reuters, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 06:11 PM IST
  • "Last time, we had preparations for 700 to 1,000 but finally more than 1,800 Rohingya moved there. People who moved earlier are calling their relatives and friends to go there. That's why more people are going there." Navy Commodore Abdullah Al Mamun Chowdhury told Reuters.
Close
Russia and the United States exchanged documents on January 26, 2021, to extend the New START nuclear treaty.(AP)
Russia and the United States exchanged documents on January 26, 2021, to extend the New START nuclear treaty.(AP)

Russian parliament approves New START nuclear treaty extension

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 05:46 PM IST
The pact’s extension doesn’t require congressional approval in the US, but Russian lawmakers must ratify the move and Putin has to sign the relevant bill into law.
Close
A medical worker performs a fast PCR test in a test container in Austria.(REUTERS)
A medical worker performs a fast PCR test in a test container in Austria.(REUTERS)

UK Covid variant sufferers cough more, but sense of smell less affected - survey

Reuters, London
UPDATED ON JAN 27, 2021 05:38 PM IST
  • The variant, identified in southeast England in December, is thought to be more transmissible, and could also be associated with higher mortality, though data suggesting increased death rates are uncertain and not yet strong.
Close
Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson reacts during a press conference at Downing Street on the government's coronavirus action plan in London. (AP)
Britain's Prime Minister Boris Johnson reacts during a press conference at Downing Street on the government's coronavirus action plan in London. (AP)

UK could save 1.5 million crisis-hit workers at a modest cost

By hindustantimes.com | Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 05:33 PM IST
The UK could offer help for over a million people currently left out of income support programs at relatively little cost, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies.
Close
The shortfall of planned deliveries of the AstraZeneca vaccine come at the same time a slowdown in the distribution of Pfizer-BioNTech shots.(Reuters)
The shortfall of planned deliveries of the AstraZeneca vaccine come at the same time a slowdown in the distribution of Pfizer-BioNTech shots.(Reuters)

Covid-19 vaccine delivery talks with EU will go ahead: AstraZeneca

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 27, 2021 05:20 PM IST
The comments came after EU officials said that the company had pulled out of the meeting to discuss delayed vaccine commitments to the bloc.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP