Barack Obama, Beyoncé and Jay-Z turned white in illustration, WikiHow apologises
Cartoon for ‘How to become a congressman’ tutorial was based on photo taken after a fundraising event – but website says illustrator got the skin colours wrongworld Updated: Jan 25, 2017 12:12 IST
The how-to website WikiHow has apologised for a “disgraceful” cartoon showing Barack Obama, Beyoncé and Jay-Z as white people on an article about how to become a congressman.
Billed as “the world’s leading how-to website”, WikiHow publishes crowd-sourced instructional articles on a wide variety of subjects.
Illustrating its seven-point tutorial on “How to become a congressman” was a cartoon rendition of a photograph of Barack Obama with Beyoncé and Jay-Z that depicted all three individuals as white.
Screenshots comparing the cartoon with the original image, taken after a fundraising event in New York in 2012, was circulated by a Beyoncé fan account on Twitter on Monday.
Wikihow turned Obama, Beyoncé, and Jay Z white to explain "How to become a congressman." pic.twitter.com/QNTGz5wjaq— FORMATION (@beyupdates_) January 22, 2017
A representative of wikiHow responded on Twitter, calling the image “disgraceful” and stating that an investigation had been launched into its origins.
In a fuller apology and explanation tweeted on Wednesday, a representative said WikiHow was “disgusted and ashamed” to have published the image, but that it did not believe it to have been “intentionally whitewashed”.
“When we saw the whitewashed image of Obama, Jay Z and Beyoncé, we were disgusted and ashamed. It never should have been on wikiHow.”
Jack Herrick, the founder of wikiHow, told the Guardian that the image had been removed, as well as the instruction it accompanied (“schedule and attend fundraising events”), because the article was being re-written and re-illustrated.
According to the tweeted statement, WikiHow’s investigation had found that the image was created in January 2014 by a team of illustrators.
1/ When we saw the whitewashed image of Obama, Jay Z & Beyoncé, we were disgusted & ashamed. It never should have been on wikiHow. https://t.co/tCIgpPpD2R— wikiHow (@wikiHow) January 24, 2017
“One person sketches, the other person colours. The sketcher sent the colorist a black and white sketch. The colorist did not know the race of the models [and] wasn’t aware it was Obama and Beyoncé. We don’t think the illustrator intentionally whitewashed here.
“This doesn’t excuse the fact that we hosted a terrible image on WikiHow and we needed more diversity on that article, period. We’re talking with our illustrators to prevent recurrence and encourage diversity. Especially in positions of power.”
Herrick said that WikiHow had issued a style guide in September 2014 that requested more gender and ethnic diversity in images, and since then “pushed our requests for diversity further and further”.
The 2016 style guide “strongly encourages” illustrators to be mindful of diversity and asks that they “strive to achieve” 50:50 male to female character ratio; no more than 50% of characters with white or light-coloured skin; and a variety of body types and, when applicable, ages.
“We’ve improved a lot on this issue over the last three years,” said Herrick. “You can and should expect WikiHow to be even better about this in our future work.”
An online game matching cartoons with the titles of the wikiHow article they accompanied went viral in April last year.
First Published: Jan 25, 2017 12:00 IST