As US eases hostilities, Cuba faces new challenge
Latin American countries and others that supported Cuba in its long battle against the United States may become less tolerant of its one-party rule, repression of dissidents and strict controls over the economy and the media if the US threat disappears.world Updated: Dec 19, 2014 09:51 IST
For decades, it was Cuba's first response to criticism. Poor economic performance? An obvious effect of a US trade embargo that amounted to a blockade of the island nation by a bullying superpower.
Arrests of dissidents? A legitimate act of self-defense against mercenaries working for the world's richest nation, which backed the failed Bay of Pigs invasion and plots to assassinate revolutionary leader Fidel Castro.
Now, though, with Washington agreeing to restore full diplomatic ties that were cut in the early 1960s, Cuba's communist government may not be able to blame its old Cold War nemesis so readily.
"The big bad wolf of Yankee imperialism is softening its teeth - so they won't have that ready-made scapegoat any more for things that are wrong on the island," said a Latin American diplomat who used to live in Cuba and still tracks events there.
Cuba has repeatedly sought to dispel the idea that it secretly wanted the embargo in place, saying if the Americans believed that they should challenge Cuba by lifting it.
With that now a greater possibility, however, there are risks.
Latin American countries and others that supported Cuba in its long battle against the United States may become less tolerant of its one-party rule, repression of dissidents and strict controls over the economy and the media if the US threat disappears.
"There wouldn't be any justification that we're in a state of war because the Americans are constantly attacking us. They won't be able to justify it, at least not to their friends," said Jose Daniel Ferrer, leader of the Cuban Patriotic Union (UNPACU), Cuba's largest dissident organization.
US President Barack Obama has made clear he expects improved human rights in Cuba as part of the deal to restore full relations. The US government called it "a critical focus of our increased engagement."
The rapprochement announced on Wednesday included a prisoner swap -- US citizen Alan Gross and a Cuban who spied for the United States were freed in exchange for three Cuban agents who were serving time in US prison.
A US official said Cuba also released 53 people deemed by Washington to be political prisoners.
Still, the deal refocuses attention on Cuba's human rights record as its critics accuse Obama of giving up too much for the return of Gross, who the US government insisted was innocent.
Cuba has released most of its political prisoners, with Amnesty International putting the number in single digits and UNPACU saying it is between 90 and 100.
Instead, the government detains dissidents for several hours or days at a time, as it did in public demonstrations at a busy Havana square on Dec. 10, rounding up dozens who responded to a call to protest by the opposition group Ladies in White.
President Raul Castro, 83, has pushed through market-style economic reforms since taking over from his ailing older brother Fidel in 2008.
On the day he took office, he said Cubans should not use the embargo as an excuse for perennial shortages and economic hardship and he poked fun at the blame game in a 2010 appearance before parliament.
But his reforms are slow-moving and he has said the wider goal is to strengthen Cuban socialism, not weaken it.
So it was no surprise that even when announcing the US-Cuban political breakthrough, simultaneously with President Barack Obama in separate speeches, Castro also reminded the world the sanctions were still in place.
"This doesn't mean the main problem is resolved," he said. "The economic, commercial and financial blockade that causes our nation massive human and economic damage must stop."
Cuba estimates the sanctions have cost its economy about $117 billion in lost trade and extra costs, including nearly $4 billion in the most recent annual estimate.
Critics say Cuba exaggerates the costs and has found commercial work-arounds with friendlier nations but the impact of not trading directly with the United States has been huge - from lost sales of sugar and other products to the inability to import cheap medicines.
Obama can significantly weaken the US sanctions with executive authority and the White House has said it hopes the US Congress will formally lift the embargo before Obama leaves office in January 2017.
The United States and Cuba have accused each other of sabotaging previous efforts at closer ties but all signs indicate Cuba would welcome a controlled flow of US investment, especially with its main foreign ally Venezuela suffering from economic disarray.
Castro will almost certainly look to control the pace of economic change rather than allow a surge of US influence into Cuba and opponents say they expect the government to find new reasons to justify tight communist control.
"If they no longer have the excuse of the ferocious wolf, they'll always find others," said former Cuban dissident Ohalys Victore, who left the island in 2002 and now sells life insurance in Arizona.
As part of Obama's policy change, Washington is allowing US telecoms providers to offer services in Cuba - a potential boost to the slowest internet in the Americas but perhaps not immediately welcome in a tightly-controlled society.
"That potentially shifts the onus onto the Cuban government if they can't expand internet access," said Antoni Kapcia, a Cuba expert at Nottingham University in England, saying justification for internet under-development would be harder.
"They may have lost that bit of an alibi."
(Additional reporting by Andrew Cawthorne in Caracas, Editing by Kieran Murray)
First Published: Dec 19, 2014 09:47 IST