Demonstrators of Free Software Movement Karnataka hold placards during a protest against Facebook's Free Basics initiative in Bangalore.(AFP Photo)
Demonstrators of Free Software Movement Karnataka hold placards during a protest against Facebook's Free Basics initiative in Bangalore.(AFP Photo)

How Zuckerberg’s Free Basics lost to net neutrality in India

On Monday afternoon, Mumbai-based entrepreneur Mahesh Murthy wrote on his Facebook Timeline — “On differential pricing and Facebook Free Basics or Airtel Zero....They’re all banned! We won!”
By Kalyan Subramani, Bengaluru
UPDATED ON FEB 11, 2016 07:19 AM IST

On Monday afternoon, Mumbai-based techprenuer, Mahesh Murthy wrote on his Facebook Timeline, “On differential pricing and Facebook Free Basics or Airtel Zero....They’re all banned! We won!”

It was a message many among Murthy’s 24,000-odd followers were waiting to read. Just minutes before Murthy announced victory, Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) had said that differential pricing for accessing content on the internet or what the opponents of it call the absence of Net Neutrality will be treated as illegal and attract a fine up to Rs 50 lakh if violated.

Read: TRAI says no to Facebook’s Free Basics, supports net neutrality

The last few months preceding TRAI’s Monday verdict, Murthy and a small group of like minded individuals had turned crusaders, hell bent on stopping Facebook Founder CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s unabashed and persistent move to bring Free Basics to India. For the $18 billion social media giant based in Silicon Valley, the stakes were too high -- enough to have reportedly spent Rs 200-300 crore on a media campaign in India in the last week of December 2015. With less than a fourth of Indians having access to the Internet, the scope to monetize content on the Net was the proverbial pot of gold Facebook found and quite likely still finds irresistible.

Murthy said a small group of ‘rag-tag’ professionals put their heads together and decided to give Facebook a fight. “It was the right thing to do. Personally I had no commercial axe to grind here. What Zuckerberg was trying to do was completely wrong. We were just a bunch of guys, some of us have not even met each other, but got organized on Slack and strategized our move,” Murthy told HT. Slack is a cloud-based teamwork application, quite popular among the technologically savvy professionals. This group had professionals with background in law, technology, media etc.

Watch | Decoding the TRAI ruling in favour of net neutrality

Kiran Jonnalagadda along with Nikhil Pahwa, Founder and Publisher of MediaNama created a parallel movement under Savetheinternet banner. Jonnalagadda, co-founder of HasGeek said for the year or so he had to take a break from work to defend Net Neutrality. “It was important, else it was going to affect our business in the long run anyway,” he said.

The road to victory did come with a price for Murthy as well. For starters, he says his good friend Kirthiga Reddy, managing director of Facebook in India slipped off his network. “Our children go to the same school in Mumbai. We live around the same area in Mumbai. But I think it will be ok,” he said hoping his friendship with Reddy will be restored when the storm over Free Basics subsides. Interestingly Murthy has three times more followers on Facebook than Reddy.

“In the midst of the campaign, my WhatsApp account was disconnected for lifetime. I was later told it happened inadvertently and restored.” WhatsApp is the messenger service provider Facebook had bought for $19 billion in 2014 and has over a billion users worldwide now. Murthy says he was also among five people in India whose views on Free Basics was collated regularly and sent to Facebook headquarters.

Zuckerberg and his team in Silicon Valley were listening, but were not willing to change their stance on Free Basics said Jonnalagadda. “They were only interested in knowing why we were opposing Free Basics, but did little to change it,” he adds.

Bengaluru-based Vaitheeswaran Kothandaraman, co-founder of Fabmall (acquired by Aditya Birla group and re-branded More), got involved when Free Basics was still Internet.org. “The great thing is we were not working together but for a common good. That was the most interesting part of it.”

Kothandaraman believes that Free Basics was a communications disaster right from the start. “Just because they could have the Prime Minister visit their headquarters (town hall meeting) does not mean that the people in India could be pushed around. In that sense what TRAI has done is truly impressive.” For many like Kothandaraman, Facebook’s media campaign proved to be the proverbial last straw on the camel’s back. “That got me personally annoyed. I even Tweeted ASCI (Advertising Standards Council of India) to ask Facebook to explain the media miscommunication they were pushing,” he said.

The campaign against Free Basics also found support from Vijay Shekhar Sharma, founder and chief executive of India’s largest digital wallet company Paytm and Nandan Nilekani, former Infosys CEO and first chairman of Unique Identification Authority of India (Aadhar). Sharma asked fellow Indians to either choose Free Basics and do a jihad for independent internet later or pick net neutrality while Nilekani called it a ‘walled garden’ that is against the spirit of openness on the internet.

For many like Jonnalagadda and Chennai-based Vijay Anand who runs The Startup Centre, the fight was not exactly against Free Basics, but differential pricing. “In a debate with the Cellular Operators Association of India, I asked if differential pricing is akin to ‘hafta’ that startups and developers have to pay the operators now.’

Most agree this is only battle won, not the war. Murthy believes Facebook will come back with the best lawyers to fight out their case. “Facebook has done a laudable job in India. I still recommend it to my clients. But with Free Basics they overstepped with a bad product and bad communication.”

On Monday Kothandaraman wrote on his Facebook with a dash of humor, “Let’s stay vigilant though. Old wine may return in new bottle branded ‪#‎FreeBull.”

Read: Father of internet congratulates India for strong net neutrality rules

Trai played with a straight bat, stood up for net neutrality

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
Reserve Bank of India(HT Photo)
Reserve Bank of India(HT Photo)

‘Not an unmixed blessing’: RBI report amid plan for digital currency

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 03:23 PM IST
Earlier in the week, RBI governor Shaktikanta Das said that the central bank plans to launch its own digital currency and the work with respect to the same was in progress.
Close
Key benchmark index Sensex dropped by 1,786 points or 3.46 per cent last week amid weak global cues.(Bloomberg)
Key benchmark index Sensex dropped by 1,786 points or 3.46 per cent last week amid weak global cues.(Bloomberg)

Nine of top 10 firms lose nearly 2.2 lakh crore in market valuation

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 03:22 PM IST
Reliance Industries (RIL) was the only scrip to post gains in its market valuation among the top 10 valued companies.
Close
Outsourcing coal workers working at a colliery at Jharia in Dhanbad, Jharkhand,( Chandan Paul / Hindustan Times)
Outsourcing coal workers working at a colliery at Jharia in Dhanbad, Jharkhand,( Chandan Paul / Hindustan Times)

India's coal import drops 12 % to 181 million tonnes in January-April period

PTI
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 01:35 PM IST
The company had imported 204.55 MT of coal in April-January period of the previous fiscal year, according to provisional data compiled by mjunction services.
Close
Job losses and non-availability of casual work were the key reasons, according to the survey.(Stock image: Getty)
Job losses and non-availability of casual work were the key reasons, according to the survey.(Stock image: Getty)

96% people faced drop in earnings during lockdown: Survey

PTI, Mumbai
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 10:27 AM IST
Of the total respondents, 52 per cent were from rural areas and the rest from urban limits.
Close
Women walk past the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) near Wall Street in New York. (AFP)
Women walk past the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) near Wall Street in New York. (AFP)

Women make inroads on Wall Street, but many mountains yet to be moved

AFP, New York
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 08:37 AM IST
  • Employment figures demonstrate the mountains that still have to be moved to achieve parity between men and women in the financial services sector.
Close
Theatres stand temporarily closed on Shaftesbury Avenue during England's third coronavirus lockdown, in London(AP)
Theatres stand temporarily closed on Shaftesbury Avenue during England's third coronavirus lockdown, in London(AP)

UK govt to set $7 billion program to help struggling firms

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON FEB 28, 2021 06:01 AM IST
The UK is set to create a 5 billion-pound ($7 billion) grant program to help businesses that have been hard hit by the pandemic.
Close
"We have no time to waste. If we act now, decisively, quickly and boldly, we can finally get ahead of this virus," Biden said. (REUTERS)
"We have no time to waste. If we act now, decisively, quickly and boldly, we can finally get ahead of this virus," Biden said. (REUTERS)

US Prez Biden urges quick Senate action on huge stimulus package

Posted by Harshit Sabarwal | AFP
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 11:45 PM IST
The package passed the House just after 2:00 am (0700 GMT) Saturday, in a 219 to 212 vote, with not one Republican vote, and moves next week to the Senate. "I hope it will receive quick action," Biden said in a brief address from the White House.
Close
The Texas court has twice ruled against Apple in the past, demanding it pay hundreds of millions of dollars to VirnetX -- another company specializing in patent litigation.(Reuters file photo)
The Texas court has twice ruled against Apple in the past, demanding it pay hundreds of millions of dollars to VirnetX -- another company specializing in patent litigation.(Reuters file photo)

US SC to look into system that lets corporations like Apple kill patent lawsuits

Bloomberg
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 08:52 PM IST
  • In an argument at the intersection of intellectual property and the separation of powers, the justices on Monday will consider a challenge to a congressionally-created board that critics have dubbed a “death squad” because of its tendency to toss out patents.
Close
Warren Buffett, Chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway(AP)
Warren Buffett, Chairman and CEO of Berkshire Hathaway(AP)

Warren Buffett says 'never bet against America' in annual letter to shareholders

AP
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 08:39 PM IST
“In its brief 232 years of existence, however, there has been no incubator for unleashing human potential like America. Despite some severe interruptions, our country’s economic progress has been breathtaking,” Buffett wrote.
Close
Digital payments in India could rise to $135.2 billion in 2023, according to an Assocham-PWC India study in 2019.(Bloomberg)
Digital payments in India could rise to $135.2 billion in 2023, according to an Assocham-PWC India study in 2019.(Bloomberg)

Reliance partners with Google, Facebook for digital payment network bid

Reuters, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 05:12 PM IST
  • Facebook and Google are already partnered with Reliance and own stakes in Jio Platforms
Close
Its education arm, known as Dali, meaning “big force” in English, was established last year and offers everything from pre-school programs to adult education and smart learning devices.(AP)
Its education arm, known as Dali, meaning “big force” in English, was established last year and offers everything from pre-school programs to adult education and smart learning devices.(AP)

ByteDance to hire 13k new employees, explore China's education technology

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 04:40 PM IST
ByteDance, the owner of the short video app TikTok, said that it will hire 10,000 educational professionals, including tutors and course designers, in China over the next four months,
Close
A neighborhood experiencing a power outage after winter weather caused electricity blackouts in San Marcos, Texas, US on February 16, 2021.(Reuters Photo )
A neighborhood experiencing a power outage after winter weather caused electricity blackouts in San Marcos, Texas, US on February 16, 2021.(Reuters Photo )

Texas’s power market is $1.3 billion short after energy crisis

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 02:31 PM IST
On Friday, the grid operator announced it would cover part of the shortfall with $800 million in congestion revenues, money generated from trading bottlenecks on the grid that is supposed to be returned to consumers.
Close
Following the acquisition of Dynamic Yield, McDonald’s executives called it a central part of the company’s evolving digital strategy.(Reuters)
Following the acquisition of Dynamic Yield, McDonald’s executives called it a central part of the company’s evolving digital strategy.(Reuters)

McDonald's to sell part of its artificial intelligence start-up

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 12:06 PM IST
The company works with other clients besides McDonald’s, and that business has grown since the acquisition and now works with 300 other brands globally.
Close
Mukesh Ambani, chairman and managing director of Reliance Industries. (Reuters File Photo)
Mukesh Ambani, chairman and managing director of Reliance Industries. (Reuters File Photo)

Mukesh Ambani is again richest Asian as China’s Zhong loses $22 billion

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON FEB 27, 2021 09:45 AM IST
Ambani spent most of the past two years leading the ranking of Asia’s richest people, taking over from Alibaba Group Holding Ltd.’s Jack Ma.
Close
The fall in gold prices led to buying and a surge of demand across the country.(Reuters)
The fall in gold prices led to buying and a surge of demand across the country.(Reuters)

Weekly wrap: After early surge, gold prices fall for last 3 days

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 27, 2021 09:33 AM IST
  • Gold set off to a brighter start at the beginning of the week as the price of the precious metal went up by 278 to 46,013 per 10 grams on Monday.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP