Publishers lose copyright case against DU’s photocopy shop

Updated on Sep 16, 2016 05:18 PM IST
The Delhi high court dismissed on Friday suits by three international publishers against the sale of photocopied books and pages in Delhi University, a landmark verdict likely to have a wide-reaching impact on copyright laws in India.
The Delhi high court dismissed on Friday suits by three international publishers against the sale of photocopied books and pages in Delhi University.
The Delhi high court dismissed on Friday suits by three international publishers against the sale of photocopied books and pages in Delhi University.
Hindustan Times | ByRocky Soibam Singh, New Delhi

The Delhi high court dismissed on Friday suits by three international publishers against the sale of photocopied books and pages in Delhi University, a landmark verdict likely to have a wide-reaching impact on copyright laws in India.

Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw also lifted a ban on the photocopier kiosk from issuing copies of chapters from textbooks of the three international publishers to students.

In November 2012, the court had banned the iconic Rameshwari Photocopy Service located near the Delhi School for Economics in north campus on a petition moved by publishers including University Press, Cambridge University Press and Taylor & Francis.

The international publishing giants had alleged that the kiosk was violating their copyright and “at the instance of Delhi University” was causing huge financial losses as students stopped buying their text books.

But Delhi University supported the photocopiers, saying the use of reproduced copyrighted books by student was a “reasonable educational needs” and should not be treated as infringement. Students also rallied behind the kiosk, saying most of the books were too expensive.

The university argued that calling reproduction of copyrighted books for educational purpose as infringement was “wrong.” Under the copyright Act, 1957, there are exemptions on “fair use” of work including educational propose from the purview of infringement, it had said.

It argued the photocopy of copyrighted books at the university’s campus were done by students for preparation of their course and was not meant for commercial exploitation.

Intellectual property experts hailed the verdict, saying the court had correctly upheld the supremacy of social good over private property.

“Copyright laws are meant to balance public and private interests but in recent years, the public interest has been eroded due to lobbying. The HC has restored that balance,” said Shamnad Basheer, intellectual property law expert.

“The court has actually said that copyright is not divine and that education is an important social need. This is a huge moment.”

Analysts also pointed out that the verdict put India at the centrestage of a global debate on intellectual property rights, first triggered three years ago when the Supreme Court denied a patent to pharma major Novartis.

The HC decision also sent out a signal that the country wouldn’t follow global trends that have tended to side with private copyright demands, they added. “We are not going to blindly adhere to western norms. We will look at our laws and requirements. This judgment cements that stand,” Basheer said.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The basketball player had gone to the stadium in Moga for practice on August 12 when one of the accused, Jatin Kanda, allegedly tried to rape her. When she resisted and tried to escape, he allegedly pushed her off the roof from a height of 25 feet, which resulted in her suffering multiple injuries. (Representative image)

    Basketball player suffers multiple fractures after she resists rape bid in Moga

    Five days since three youngsters allegedly tried to rape an 18-year-old basketball player and pushed her off the roof of an indoor stadium in Punjab's Moga district, leaving her injured with multiple fractures, police are yet to make any arrest or headway. According to hospital sources, her condition is stable after she underwent jaw surgery. The incident took place on August 12, and all three accused have been on the run since.

  • From the early 1920s, daily meals and rations provided to the convicts in Yerawada jail became a topic of discussion in Marathi newspapers when freedom fighters started protesting about the quality of food. (HT FILE)

    Taste of life: The diet of Poona jail inmates during British rule

    From the early 1920s, daily meals and rations provided to the convicts in Yerawada jail became a topic of discussion in Marathi newspapers when freedom fighters started protesting about the quality of food. The records of the prison department are so meagre on the subject of diet that not much information can be gathered from them. The prisoners were to be provided with firewood if they wished to cook for themselves.

  • Jamshedpur senior superintendent of police Prabhat Kumar said the investigations have begun. (File image)

    Robbers loot 35 lakh from bank in Jamshedpur, tell customers they’re from CBI

    A group of four armed robbers held the bank staff and customers hostage on gun point and decamped with around ₹30 lakh from the Mango branch of Bank of India in Jamshedpur on Thursday, officials said. The customers said the robbers, who were wearing masks, seized their mobile phones saying they were from the (Central Bureau of Investigation). Jamshedpur senior superintendent of police Prabhat Kumar said the investigations have begun.

  • No terror angle, says Fadnavis on boat with 3 AK-series rifles near Raigarh beach

    No terror angle, says Fadnavis on boat with 3 AK-series rifles near Raigarh beach

    An abandoned boat containing three AK-series assault rifles and ten boxes was found along the Raigad coastline on Thursday morning, police said. The boat was spotted at the Harihareshwar beach in Raigad district, nearly 200km from Mumbai, early on Thursday. A police officer said some local residents went to check out the boat that appeared to have drifted to the beach. They found a box containing assault rifles and ammunition and immediately called the police.

  • Arun Singh, Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) national general secretary in-charge of Karnataka, met Yediyurappa on Thursday. (HT Photo)

    Karnataka: Arun Singh meets Yediyurappa, says "party will expand under him"

    A day after former Karnataka Chief Minister BS Yediyurappa was inducted into the new BJP parliamentary board, state BJP in-charge, Arun Singh met Yediyurappa on Thursday. "I congratulate him on his appointment. He is a senior leader and has been CM four times. BJP would be able to expand throughout southern parts of the country under him," said Arun Singh after meeting him. Union Minister Nitin Gadkari was also dropped from the Parliamentary board.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, August 18, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now