Ahead of Davos summit, VIPs face criticism over private jet use: How polluting are they?

Published on Jan 14, 2023 03:18 AM IST

During last year's week-long event, 1,040 private planes flew in and out of airports serving the resort of Davos, found a new report commissioned by campaign group Greenpeace.

Demonstrators pretend to resuscitate the Earth while advocating for the 1.5 degree warming goal to survive at the COP27 U.N. Climate Summit.(AP file)
Demonstrators pretend to resuscitate the Earth while advocating for the 1.5 degree warming goal to survive at the COP27 U.N. Climate Summit.(AP file)
Reuters | | Posted by Nisha Anand

Political and business leaders will meet at the Swiss resort of Davos next week for the World Economic Forum, where issues from geopolitical instability to climate change are on the agenda. Yet as they seek consensus and solutions for global challenges, environmental campaigners argue that their travel arrangements may prove more significant - as hundreds of attendees are set to arrive by high-polluting private jets.

During last year's week-long event, 1,040 private planes flew in and out of airports serving the resort of Davos, found a new report commissioned by campaign group Greenpeace. Those flights caused four times more planet-heating carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions than during an average week - equivalent to the emissions of 350,000 cars, the report found.

Also Read: Yogi Adityanath to attend World Economic Forum-2023 meet, Uttar Pradesh government plans to set up pavilion at Davos

"For a forum where people actually claim to solve climate issues ... it seems quite hypocritical," said Klara Maria Schenk, transport campaigner at Greenpeace Europe.

But it's not just Davos. Private jet use by the super-rich and political leaders is increasingly fuelling public outrage. Pop star Taylor Swift has faced criticism for her jetsetting habits, while British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak recently came under fire for taking a 36-minute domestic flight in England.

So what is the impact of private jets on the environment, and what do experts think could be done in response?

Also Read: UK is set to ban single-use plastic cutlery and plates: What this would entail

HOW POLLUTING ARE PRIVATE JETS?

A private jet can emit two tonnes of carbon dioxide in an hour - which is equivalent to a few months of an average person's greenhouse gas emissions in the European Union, according to the European NGO Transport & Environment (T&E).

Private planes are between five and 14 times more polluting than commercial jets per passenger, and 50 times more than high-speed rail, according to T&E data.

"If you break it down by passenger and kilometre, it is actually the most polluting way to travel in existence," Schenk of Greenpeace said in an interview.

At Davos last year, more than half of the flights travelled less than 750km, and the shortest flight recorded was only 21km, the Greenpeace research found.

"Many of these flights would be replaceable by a few hours of train ride," Schenk added.

WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR CLIMATE CHANGE?

The aviation sector accounts for about 2.8% of global CO2 emissions. While that proportion seems relatively minor, experts point to the outsized impact caused by a small number of people.

Just 1% of the global population is responsible for 50% of the CO2 emitted by commercial aviation, according to a 2020 study in the Global Environmental Change journal.

"Frequent flyers and private jet users are by far the worst offenders when it comes to aviation emissions," said Denise Auclair, corporate travel campaign manager at T&E.

Private jets are "emblematic" of the climate crisis as "people who are not flying, not contributing to the problem are suffering the effects," like droughts and wildfires, she said.

HOW POPULAR ARE PRIVATE JETS?

Despite concerns over their climate impact, private planes have become more and more popular in recent years.

While celebrities from U.S. media personality Kylie Jenner to Tesla and Twitter CEO Elon Musk have made the headlines, with their private flights tracked and published on social media, the trend is also becoming more common in wider business travel.

Private jet travel "started booming" during the COVID-19 pandemic, when most commercial flights were grounded, said Schenk from Greenpeace.

"While we were sitting at home, these people flew in their private jets," she said.

In the United States, private business jets now account for a quarter of all flights, approximately twice their pre-pandemic share, according to aviation consultancy WINGX.

CAN AIR TRAVEL BECOME SUSTAINABLE?

The airline industry has said sustainable aviation fuels can help it reach net zero by 2050. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) says these fuels can reduce emissions by up to 80% during their lifecycle compared to conventional fuel.

Meanwhile, airlines such as Air Canada and U.S. carrier United Airlines have been buying electric planes earmarked for short trips.

Yet environmental groups say that an increase in sustainable fuels could lead to deforestation as vast amounts of lands are cleared to grow bioenergy crops such as palm and soy oils.

There are also concerns about how long it would take for these cleaner fuels to be used at scale - which made up less than 0.1% of aviation fuels in 2021, according to the International Energy Agency.

"We have to admit to ourselves ... sustainable fuels are not going to get us on the decarbonisation path that we need to be on today," said Auclair of T&E.

She said a combination of measures will be needed to accelerate emissions reductions over the next decade, including a rethink of what kind of flights are really necessary.

WHAT ARE GOVERNMENTS DOING ABOUT IT?

Governments in Europe have started to explore steps to reduce private jet flights, and encourage passengers to take cleaner forms of transport.

In December, France won approval from the European Commission to ban short-haul flight routes of less than two-and-a-half hours for which there are direct rail options.

Belgium, meanwhile, will impose new taxes on private jets and short-haul flights from April.

Auclair said taxes could provide an incentive to reduce air travel while funding the acceleration of sustainable aviation developments.

She also said corporate leaders need to set targets and create clear travel policies as part of their climate plans.

"If you're saying as a leader that your organisation is taking steps to address climate change, then it just doesn't really make sense for you to be taking a private jet to Davos," Auclair said. "We need to get serious."

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
My Offers
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, February 03, 2023
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Register Free and get Exciting Deals