Prime Minister Narendra Modi chairs a virtual meeting with Chief Ministers through video conferencing in New Delhi .(ANI)
Prime Minister Narendra Modi chairs a virtual meeting with Chief Ministers through video conferencing in New Delhi .(ANI)

HTLS 2020: The Covid-19 pandemic and the shift in domestic politics

All across the world, the pandemic has significantly enhanced the power of the state vis-a-vis its citizens.
By Shyam Saran | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON NOV 25, 2020 06:10 AM IST

Since the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, a considerable commentary has ensued on its impact on geopolitics, on economics and the role of technology. But these impacts are intertwined with how nations and societies are coping with the pandemic. It will soon be a year since the pandemic erupted. The record of countries and different political systems in dealing with its aftermath is now reasonably clear. We can make certain broad assessments on how the pandemic is changing and will change politics in countries around the world, and the Indian case is of special interest.

All across the world, the pandemic has significantly enhanced the power of the state vis-a-vis its citizens. Big government is back with a vengeance and this is unlikely to change even as the pandemic recedes. More state intervention will be required, for instance, in the distribution of vaccines. The phase of economic recovery, too, will demand greater state intervention and this is apparent already in economic stimulus packages unveiled in many states including India. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s pledge of “minimum government and maximum governance” has had a short shelf life. But while expanding government is a reality, governance is still far from “maximum”. The record in this respect remains patchy.

The pandemic has altered the relationship between the Centre and states and other constituent units, greatly enhancing the authority of the Centre at the expense of the latter even in federal dispensations. In India, the pandemic enabled the central government to take several steps beyond its strictly constitutional limits. The crisis nature of the pandemic muted resistance even from states ruled by non-BJP parties. The huge impact on revenue streams available to states and the reluctance of the Centre to deliver on its commitments to make up for losses incurred in GST collections have altered the power balance between the Centre and the states, greatly increasing the latter’s dependence on the Centre for sustaining financial viability. The Union government has utilised its enhanced authority to push through some major reforms in agriculture, education and health, which are normally state subjects and encountered only limited and sporadic opposition. Post-pandemic India will likely remain a more unitary state in practice irrespective of constitutional proprieties. But this also sows the seeds of future Centre-state tensions and incipient “fissiparous tendencies”, a term that one used to hear in the early days of our republic.

There has been a weakening of democratic polities across the world even before the pandemic, driven by rising inequalities, technological change and the spread of nationalist and populist sentiments. Globalisation led to a significant rise in wealth and incomes across the world, but in the absence of appropriate public policies to ensure equitable distribution created a small band of winners and a much larger number of those left behind. This undermined popular stake in democracy and left the door open for populist leaders to preach de-globalisation and populist policies. The success of authoritarian dispensations, in particular China, to deliver rapid growth and higher standards of living, posited another model for socio-economic development. The ability of China to stamp out the pandemic and ensure early economic recovery has further boosted the authoritarian brand. This weakening of democracy as we have known it, the preference for strong and decisive authoritarian leadership figures, despite their failings, is likely to linger. Liberal democracy has lost its brand value with Donald Trump in the US damaging it perhaps irrevocably. Joe Biden will have a tough time restoring its sheen. There is pessimism about democracy and more so in democratic countries. In India, too, there is impatience with the more measured and relatively gentle ways of a constitutional democracy and consensus politics. There is greater acceptance of coercive politics as a means of overcoming resistance to change. But I believe that India’s immense diversity and ingrained individuality of spirit will ultimately frustrate the politics of centralisation and enforced uniformity. This is a country which cannot be governed through a monochromatic frame.

The peculiar nature of the pandemic which puts a premium on social distancing and remote work has greatly accelerated the adoption of digital technologies. This is impacting the way in which economies of the future will be structured and change the ways of living and working but in what manner and to what degree remains uncertain and unpredictable. This will change politics as well. It is clear that states are already adopting these new technologies for more intrusive surveillance of their citizens’ lives while resisting scrutiny of their own conduct. But theoretically, I see the same technologies giving citizens the tools for compelling transparency and accountability in state action, though this may happen with a time lag or perhaps never at all. The state will resist this and citation of national security has already become a convenient argument to stay opaque. In India, too, security trumps almost every attempt at scrutiny of state action and ensuring democratic accountability.

Enhanced state authority can create a caring state, which is more responsive to the interests of its citizens. It can deploy its augmented powers to undertake long pending economic and social reforms, treating crisis as an opportunity. Perhaps, we will succeed in creating a more congenial setting for sustainable democracy eventually. One must remain hopeful.

Shyam Saran is a former Foreign Secretary and a Senior Fellow CPR

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Farmers take part in a protest against the three farm laws on the outskirts of Delhi.(Reuters Photo)
Farmers take part in a protest against the three farm laws on the outskirts of Delhi.(Reuters Photo)

Farmers likely to meet police officers today over proposed tractor rally

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 07:31 AM IST
The cops gave farmers the option to take out their rally on the Kundli–Manesar–Palwal Expressway instead of Outer Ring Road, but they did not agree.
Close
Reacting to the developments, Goswami, in a statement on Tuesday, said: “I am horrified that the Congress party actually thinks that any journalist in India expressing the views publicly stated by the Government is committing a crime.”
Reacting to the developments, Goswami, in a statement on Tuesday, said: “I am horrified that the Congress party actually thinks that any journalist in India expressing the views publicly stated by the Government is committing a crime.”

Congress steps up attack on Centre over Arnab Goswami's chats

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:59 AM IST
The Congress leaders claimed in a statement that the chats “conclusively prove leaks of top secret information detrimental to national security & integrity” and held members of Cabinet committee on security responsible for the leak.
Close
With the shipping of doses to Bhutan and the Maldives, India also became the first country to provide South Asian nations with vaccines as aid.(AFP)
With the shipping of doses to Bhutan and the Maldives, India also became the first country to provide South Asian nations with vaccines as aid.(AFP)

Bhutan, Maldives first to benefit from India’s ‘Vaccine Maitri’

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:50 AM IST
Two aircraft took off several hours apart, carrying 150,000 doses of Covishield vaccine for Thimphu and 100,000 doses for Male. The external affairs ministry has said India will initially provide vaccines to Bhutan, the Maldives, Bangladesh, Nepal, Myanmar and Seychelles.
Close
In Kerala, by contrast, the case trajectory has dropped only 34% —from 8,728 cases (seven-day average) on October 13 to 5,374 cases a day in the past week.(Sonu Mehta/HT PHOTO)
In Kerala, by contrast, the case trajectory has dropped only 34% —from 8,728 cases (seven-day average) on October 13 to 5,374 cases a day in the past week.(Sonu Mehta/HT PHOTO)

One in 3 new coronavirus cases recorded in Kerala

By Ramesh Babu, Thiruvananthapuram
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:47 AM IST
Since India’s Covid-19 peak in its first and only wave, the national case trajectory has dropped 85% — from 93,617 on September 16 to 14,376 on January 19.
Close
The last edition of the India Innovation Index, released in October 2019, was a first-of-its-kind metric for assessing the innovation capabilities of Indian states and Union territories.(AP Photo. Representative image)
The last edition of the India Innovation Index, released in October 2019, was a first-of-its-kind metric for assessing the innovation capabilities of Indian states and Union territories.(AP Photo. Representative image)

Karnataka retains top position at India Innovation Index ranking

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:29 AM IST
Maharashtra leapfrogged Tamil Nadu to take second place in the rankings, followed by Telangana, Kerala, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Uttar Pradesh and Punjab.
Close
An elderly farmer sits in the back of a tractor trolley as they block a highway in protest against new farm laws at the Delhi-Uttar Pradesh state border, outskirts of New Delhi. (AP PHOTO)
An elderly farmer sits in the back of a tractor trolley as they block a highway in protest against new farm laws at the Delhi-Uttar Pradesh state border, outskirts of New Delhi. (AP PHOTO)

Farm laws protests LIVE: SC-appointed panel to meet farmers' unions leader

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shankhyaneel Sarkar
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:28 AM IST
  • The protests against the farm laws at Delhi's border has entered its eighth week.
Nadda said that the BJP had set an example of how a political party can “effectively work as a potent tool of social service and help people in times of need”.(PTI)
Nadda said that the BJP had set an example of how a political party can “effectively work as a potent tool of social service and help people in times of need”.(PTI)

JP Nadda hails BJP cadre, sets goal of ‘historic’ poll wins

PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:24 AM IST
In an open letter to party workers, Nadda exuded confidence that the ‘lotus’, the party’s poll symbol, will bloom in West Bengal after the assembly elections.
Close
A worker disinfects the poultry farm in Shivapur village to protect chickens from bird flu decease.(HT Photo )
A worker disinfects the poultry farm in Shivapur village to protect chickens from bird flu decease.(HT Photo )

Bird flu: New cases trigger second wave concerns

By Ritesh Mishra, Ramesh Babu, Raipur/thiruvananthapuram
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:21 AM IST
The first case of bird flu was reported from Jhalawar in Rajasthan on December 29, and the infections, deadly for birds, spread to 10 other states, resulting in the deaths of thousands of poultry, and hundreds of common crows and some migratory species.
Close
Nearly 64 lakh students across Maharashtra are yet to have their Aadhar card or have not updated their details.(HT file)
Nearly 64 lakh students across Maharashtra are yet to have their Aadhar card or have not updated their details.(HT file)

4-1 verdict: Supreme Court dismisses pleas seeking Aadhaar ruling review

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:16 AM IST
By 4-1, a constitution bench affirmed the verdict delivered in September 2018 when the top court upheld the country’s biometric identity system and also cleared mandatory Aadhaar enrolment of recipients of government welfare benefits.
Close
Separately, CJI Bobde made an indirect appeal to the farmers to come on board and meet with the court-appointed committee that has been tasked with finding ways to address the impasse.(Sakib Ali/HT Photo)
Separately, CJI Bobde made an indirect appeal to the farmers to come on board and meet with the court-appointed committee that has been tasked with finding ways to address the impasse.(Sakib Ali/HT Photo)

Supreme Court turns down plea seeking to stop farmers’ tractor rally

By Utkarsh Anand, Abraham Thomas
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:11 AM IST
Declining to pass any order on the plea by the government, a bench, headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) SA Bobde, remarked that it was not for the court to remind the authorities of the policing power they have by passing an order in this regard.
Close
Facebook-owned WhatsApp rolled out a new privacy policy recently that included mandatory sharing of data with its parent company.(REUTERS)
Facebook-owned WhatsApp rolled out a new privacy policy recently that included mandatory sharing of data with its parent company.(REUTERS)

WhatsApp backs policy, says addressing ‘misinformation’

PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:04 AM IST
“We wish to reinforce that this update does not expand our ability to share data with Facebook. Our aim is to provide transparency and new options available to engage with businesses...” a WhatsApp spokesperson said.
Close
Because of Covid-19 safety protocols, the ECI has decided to reduce the average number of voters in each polling station from 1,500 to nearly 1,000.(PTI/ File photo)
Because of Covid-19 safety protocols, the ECI has decided to reduce the average number of voters in each polling station from 1,500 to nearly 1,000.(PTI/ File photo)

Electoral rolls, not NRC, to determine voters in Assam: Election Commission

By Utpal Parashar, Guwahati
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 06:00 AM IST
Around 1.9 million (of 33 million applicants) were left out of the updated NRC published for Assam on Augst 31, 2019. The NRC was a list intended to identify legal residents and weed out illegal immigrants from Assam.
Close
Union Minister Dr Jitendra Singh said Sikkim is a picturesque location for a Film City. (Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times Archive)
Union Minister Dr Jitendra Singh said Sikkim is a picturesque location for a Film City. (Sanjeev Verma/Hindustan Times Archive)

Film City in Sikkim: Union minister Jitendra Singh holds discussions

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 21, 2021 05:53 AM IST
The Film and Television Institute of India (FTII) campus in Arunachal Pradesh was established in 2018, the second in the country after Pune.
Close
The agency claims to have already established that Rishi took <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>30 lakh bribe in two tranches for facilitating the leak of information from the agency and that Dhankad had taken around <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>25 lakh from two companies.(Representative image)
The agency claims to have already established that Rishi took 30 lakh bribe in two tranches for facilitating the leak of information from the agency and that Dhankad had taken around 25 lakh from two companies.(Representative image)

CBI arrests two of its officials in bribery case

By Neeraj Chauhan
UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 05:47 AM IST
The allegation is that crucial case related information and documents have been leaked since 2018 to individuals/companies being investigated for bank frauds.
Close
The composition of this four-member committee triggered a controversy since all four had previously made statements in support of the reforms.
The composition of this four-member committee triggered a controversy since all four had previously made statements in support of the reforms.

Supreme Court irked over criticism of farm committee picks

UPDATED ON JAN 21, 2021 05:39 AM IST
Thousands of farmers, mostly from Punjab and Haryana, have been camping at several Delhi border points since November 26, demanding a complete repeal of the three farm laws and legal guarantee of minimum support price for their crops.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP