Supreme Court to examine if limits can be placed on HC orders in times of crisis | Latest News India - Hindustan Times
close_game
close_game

Supreme Court to examine if limits can be placed on HC orders in times of crisis

ByAbraham Thomas, New Delhi
Jul 15, 2021 02:25 AM IST

In its May 21 order, the top court advised high courts not to pass orders that were incapable of being implemented.

The Supreme Court is all set to consider what limits can be placed on decision-making powers of high courts to ensure that in times of crisis, such as the Covid-19 pandemic, the personal views of judges do not form part of judicial orders which are hard to be implemented by the executive.

Supreme Court (REUTERS)
Supreme Court (REUTERS)

The top court was faced with a situation arising out of an Allahabad high court judgment that remarked on May 17 that the Uttar Pradesh’s medical system was “ram bharose” (left to the mercy of God), and directed the state to provide two ambulances with ICU facility in all 97,000 villages, nursing homes in the state to be equipped with ventilator support and BiPAP machines, import vaccines, and upgrading medical colleges, among other directions.

Hindustan Times - your fastest source for breaking news! Read now.

Although this order was stayed by the Supreme Court on May 21, the bench of justices Vineet Saran and Dinesh Maheshwari on Wednesday said, “All of us have good personal suggestions during a crisis. But we have to ask ourselves if those suggestions can result in an order passed by a constitutional court. Will not the courts be entering into the executive arena?”

The bench said it will consider this aspect on August 12 and asked the court-appointed amicus curiae (friend of court) senior advocate Nidhesh Gupta to present suggestions on that date. Solicitor general Tushar Mehta, appearing for the UP government, was also asked to assist.

The court did not doubt the good intentions of the high courts in passing orders to serve public welfare. “Howsoever laudable be our intentions, it doesn’t give anybody a right to enter into the executive arena. There are norms within which every constitutional body has to work. The executive has benefit of expert knowledge. If there is anything wrong, the judiciary is there… In a crisis, everybody has to be cautious of what needs to be done and by whom.”

Mehta was of the view that the matter could be sent back to the high court, where the issue pertaining to management of Covid-19 in the state is being heard by a bench headed by the acting chief justice. The state filed an affidavit in the top court indicating the steps being taken in the state to increase number of ambulances fitted with basic life support and advanced life support facilities.

Gupta submitted that for the present, the state can be asked to provide what it has agreed to provide in its affidavit.

In its May 21 order, the top court advised high courts not to pass orders that were incapable of being implemented.

Unveiling Elections 2024: The Big Picture', a fresh segment in HT's talk show 'The Interview with Kumkum Chadha', where leaders across the political spectrum discuss the upcoming general elections. Watch now!

Get Current Updates on India News, Election 2024, Mukhtar Ansari Death News Live, Bihar Board 10th Result 2024 Live along with Latest News and Top Headlines from India and around the world.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Share this article
SHARE
Story Saved
Live Score
OPEN APP
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, March 29, 2024
Start 14 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Follow Us On