Top U.S. infectious disease experts say the findings underpinning the carriers’ safety claims aren’t that conclusive.(Unsplash)
Top U.S. infectious disease experts say the findings underpinning the carriers’ safety claims aren’t that conclusive.(Unsplash)

Airlines stir doubts with ‘flying is safe’ claim on Covid spread

Airlines have loudly insisted that it’s safe to fly during the coronavirus pandemic, and U.S. travel is surging before the Thanksgiving holiday despite a nationwide spike in virus cases.
By Bloomberg | Posted by Jahnavi Gupta | U.S.
UPDATED ON NOV 25, 2020 01:03 PM IST

Airlines have loudly insisted that it’s safe to fly during the coronavirus pandemic, and U.S. travel is surging before the Thanksgiving holiday despite a nationwide spike in virus cases.

Yet top U.S. infectious disease experts say the findings underpinning the carriers’ safety claims aren’t that conclusive.

Concerned about the “misinterpretation” of their findings, researchers on a Defense Department study that has been widely cited by the industry added a cautionary revision. A senior expert in travel-health issues declined to participate in an airline trade group’s press conference, citing what he called their “bad math.”

“The airline industry got a little ahead of itself trying to say the risk is zero,” said David Freedman, a University of Alabama at Birmingham professor emeritus who balked at appearing with an International Air Transport Association event that cited his work.

U.S. airlines, hit with an unprecedented drop in demand since the virus began spreading widely in March, are enjoying their strongest week since then. Even as health officials warn against travel during the Thanksgiving holiday because of a surge in Covid-19 cases, more than 4 million people traversed airports between Friday and Monday.

The risk of being infected with the novel coronavirus on planes -- which have highly effective filters that remove virus from the air and where mask usage is required -- is probably fairly low, scientists say.

But the research is far from clear and some recent cases have documented transmission on flights even when passengers wore masks and sat far apart, according to a review of recent cases and interviews with academics and disease specialists.

“I definitely can say it’s premature to say that air travel is very safe,” said Qingyan Chen, an engineering professor at Purdue University in Indiana who’s written extensively on disease transmission on planes.

Airline officials, responding to the historic drop in passengers, have repeatedly defended the protections against infection on flights.

“Flying is safe,” Nicholas Calio, president of Airlines for America, a trade group for large carriers, said at a Nov. 12 briefing. “I will state that categorically.”

A4A declined to add additional comments. It has highlighted the efforts to force passengers to wear masks and to remain apart during boarding and exiting, and to disinfect aircraft. Montreal-based IATA defended its use of Freedman’s data on confirmed in-flight transmissions, saying it never characterized the results as definitive.

A4A has frequently cited a study by the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, which was funded by the trade group and other aviation industry sources, that concluded the risk of transmission on an airliner was “very low.” But authors cautioned that their projections depended on adherence to mask usage and they also urged airlines to improve ventilation while planes are parked at the gate.

Another study airlines point to was conducted by the Defense Department with the assistance of United Airlines Holdings Inc. and Boeing Co. It attempted to measure how aerosol virus particles were exhaled by a simulated masked passenger.

United said in promotional materials released October 15 the study “determined the risk is almost non-existent.”

However, after news coverage of the study, the authors added a revision, saying they were “concerned about the potential misinterpretation of the findings.” They also acknowledged they based their results on a person exhaling relatively few virus particles, an amount well below levels documented in some cases.

The airplane filters and mask usage “significantly reduces” exposure to infectious aerosols, they wrote. “However, the current established scientific understanding of SARS-CoV-2 transmission dynamics is not sufficient to calculate definitive SARS-CoV-2 transmission risk from these measurements of aerosol transport.”

United spokeswoman Leslie Scott responded in an email that “Throughout the pandemic, our top priority has been the health and safety of our customers and crew.”

“It’s why we supported military officials, medical experts and aviation engineers in their work demonstrating that aircraft cabins are among the safest of public indoor environments thanks to advanced air filtration systems, required mask-wearing and diligent cleaning protocols,” she added.

Overall, there are few confirmed reports of infections linked to flights. However, because of limited contact tracing in the U.S. and the difficulty of finding transmission cases, it’s hard to say for sure what that means, researchers said.

“I haven’t seen any studies come out and say it’s highly risky,” said Byron Jones, an engineering professor at Kansas State University who has studied airliner cabin-air safety. “But I haven’t seen the study that says it’s definitively safe either.”

Overseas reports

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control summarizes the risks from air travel this way on its website: “Most viruses and other germs do not spread easily on flights because of how air circulates and is filtered on airplanes. However, keeping your distance is difficult on crowded flights, and sitting within six feet of others, sometimes for hours, may increase your risk of getting Covid-19.”

While some studies have shown cases in which no one on a flight became infected in spite of the presence of contagious passengers, other data have documented in-flight transmissions.

Purdue’s Chen said he’s been following news reports in China of possible infection between passengers on a Nov. 9 Air China flight from Los Angeles to Tianjin.

Ten people who weren’t connected to each other and resided in different parts of the U.S. tested positive for Covid-19 after arrival. All the passengers had tested negative for the disease before the flight, suggesting at least some of the transmission occurred on the plane, he said.

Such incidents are confounding because they seem to contradict Chen’s own earlier research showing mask usage can dramatically lower risks of infection, he said.

“That’s why I’m having doubts about what’s going on in airplanes,” he said.

Government researchers in Ireland documented as many as 13 cases linked to a single flight last summer, according to a paper published in October. The infections in five of the cases were genetically linked, “strongly suggesting a single point source of infection,” the authors said.

The widebody jet was largely empty, people were spaced out on the plane and almost everyone whose activity could be documented said they wore masks. Nevertheless, the authors estimated that 10-18% of passengers became infected.

“It is interesting that four of the flight cases were not seated next to any other positive case, had no contact in the transit lounge, wore face masks in-flight and would not be deemed close contacts under current guidance from the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control,” the authors said.

(This story has been published from a wire agency feed without modifications to the text.)

Follow more stories on Facebook and Twitter

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Passenger Ioanna Karagiannidou speaks with driver Konstantinos Bekios following their ride in his taxi that he turned into a 'night club', amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, in Thessaloniki, Greece, January 14, 2021.(Reuters)
Passenger Ioanna Karagiannidou speaks with driver Konstantinos Bekios following their ride in his taxi that he turned into a 'night club', amid the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, in Thessaloniki, Greece, January 14, 2021.(Reuters)

Nightclub taxi drives away the blues in lockdown Greece

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 09:57 PM IST
"I saw that people were always stressed, sad, everyone was in a bad mood," says Greek taxi driver Konstantinos Bekio, who is doing his bit to lift his passengers' spirits amid coronavirus lockdown, turning his cab into a nightclub.
Close
France has announced that people travelling from non-EU countries will no longer be able to get into the country by presenting a negative result from a quick, readily-available Covid-19 test.(Yahoo)
France has announced that people travelling from non-EU countries will no longer be able to get into the country by presenting a negative result from a quick, readily-available Covid-19 test.(Yahoo)

France toughens Covid-19 testing rules for non-EU travellers

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 04:55 PM IST
France has announced that people travelling from non-EU countries will no longer be able to get into the country by presenting a negative result from a quick, readily-available Covid-19 test.
Close
The Southeast Asian country, which has recorded its first case of a new variant that was first found in Britain, has the second highest number of Covid-19 cases and casualties in Southeast Asia. (Unsplash)
The Southeast Asian country, which has recorded its first case of a new variant that was first found in Britain, has the second highest number of Covid-19 cases and casualties in Southeast Asia. (Unsplash)

Philippines extends travel ban, steps up safeguards over Covid-19 variant

Reuters, Manila
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 03:03 PM IST
The Philippines on Friday extended by two weeks a ban on travellers from more than 30 territories and countries where a more transmissible Covid-19 variant has been detected
Close
Representational Image(Unsplash)
Representational Image(Unsplash)

How to think about travelling now that Covid vaccines are out

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 02:42 PM IST
Ready for a vacation? So are we. Here’s the real talk on what to expect, even after your second shot.
Close
Travelers are "yearning for what was taken away from them," Chesky said at the Reuters Next conference. (Reuters)
Travelers are "yearning for what was taken away from them," Chesky said at the Reuters Next conference. (Reuters)

Airbnb CEO says travel never going back to the way it was before pandemic

Reuters, United Kingdom
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 10:11 AM IST
Airbnb Chief Executive Officer predicted travel would permanently change due to the pandemic with people seeking out thousands of smaller cities and spending more time visiting friends and family.
Close
The Cook Islands is one of the few countries to remain Covid-free.(Unsplash)
The Cook Islands is one of the few countries to remain Covid-free.(Unsplash)

One-way Cook Island travel bubble to New Zealand to start next week

Reuters, Wellington
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 09:31 AM IST
People from the Cook Islands can start quarantine-free travel to New Zealand next week, but New Zealand-based people will have to wait until later in the year to visit the Cook Islands.
Close
UK bans arrivals from South America, Portugal on Variant(Pexels)
UK bans arrivals from South America, Portugal on Variant(Pexels)

UK to ban flights from Portugal and South America over new coronavirus strain

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 15, 2021 08:03 AM IST
A new strain of coronavirus has emerged in Brazil and in order to contain its spread, the United Kingdom has banned flights coming in from South America, Panama, Portugal and Cape Verde.
Close
Airlines hope the new testing requirements will clear the way for the administration to lift the restrictions that reduced travel from some European countries by 95% or more.(Unsplash)
Airlines hope the new testing requirements will clear the way for the administration to lift the restrictions that reduced travel from some European countries by 95% or more.(Unsplash)

White House still considering lifting European, Brazilian travel restrictions

Reuters, Washington
UPDATED ON JAN 14, 2021 11:50 AM IST
The White House is still considering rescinding entry bans for most non-U.S. citizens who recently were in Brazil and much of Europe in the final days before President Donald Trump leaves office.
Close
Sudan lifts ban on travel from countries with new coronavirus variant(Pexels)
Sudan lifts ban on travel from countries with new coronavirus variant(Pexels)

Sudan to remove travel ban on countries with new coronavirus strain

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 14, 2021 07:26 AM IST
Sudan will be allowing travellers from Britain, Netherlands and South Africa. The visitors will have to quarantine for 14 days and show a negative Covid test report.
Close
The Gujarat government on Tuesday announced its new tourism policy for 2020-25 with special focus on attracting new investments in the state's "high priority tourism centres" by offering lucrative incentives to entrepreneurs.(Unsplash)
The Gujarat government on Tuesday announced its new tourism policy for 2020-25 with special focus on attracting new investments in the state's "high priority tourism centres" by offering lucrative incentives to entrepreneurs.(Unsplash)

Gujarat unveils new tourism policy, focus on 'high priority' areas

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 13, 2021 05:00 PM IST
The Gujarat government on Tuesday announced its new tourism policy for 2020-25 with special focus on attracting new investments in the state's "high priority tourism centres" by offering lucrative incentives to entrepreneurs.
Close
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik on Tuesday directed officials to develop the Chandrabhaga and Talsari beach with world class amenities to attract more domestic and foreign tourists.(Yahoo)
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik on Tuesday directed officials to develop the Chandrabhaga and Talsari beach with world class amenities to attract more domestic and foreign tourists.(Yahoo)

Odisha to develop Chandrabhaga & Talsari beach

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 13, 2021 11:06 AM IST
Odisha Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik on Tuesday directed officials to develop the Chandrabhaga and Talsari beach with world class amenities to attract more domestic and foreign tourists.
Close
The country will remain on virus alert level 3, and the alcohol ban that was due to expire on January 15 will remain in place. (Unsplash)
The country will remain on virus alert level 3, and the alcohol ban that was due to expire on January 15 will remain in place. (Unsplash)

South Africa extends alcohol ban, curbs travel amid virus surge

Bloomberg
PUBLISHED ON JAN 12, 2021 12:24 PM IST
South African President Cyril Ramaphosa extended a prohibition on alcohol sales and restricted travel through border posts as the nation’s hospitals struggle to cope with soaring coronavirus infections.
Close
From 4 a.m. Tuesday, travellers arriving in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland from the UAE will need to self-isolate for 10 days. (Pixabay)
From 4 a.m. Tuesday, travellers arriving in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland from the UAE will need to self-isolate for 10 days. (Pixabay)

UK removed UAE from travel corridors list amid increase in Covid-19 cases

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 12, 2021 11:20 AM IST
Britain removed the United Arab Emirates from its travel corridors list following a concerning increase in confirmed Covid-19 cases
Close
"Given the high rates of infection in many countries and evidence of the global spread of more transmissible variants, it's clear that most global air routes will be of critical concern for the foreseeable future,"(Pixabay)
"Given the high rates of infection in many countries and evidence of the global spread of more transmissible variants, it's clear that most global air routes will be of critical concern for the foreseeable future,"(Pixabay)

New Zealand asks international travellers for negative virus test before flying

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 12, 2021 09:32 AM IST
New Zealand will ask international travelers from most countries to show negative Covid-19 test results before boarding flights to the country as new contagious variants of Covid-19 spread across globally.
Close
Thailand's Tourism Minister said on Monday he had proposed a plan to allow foreigners to quarantine in some of the country's many golf resorts to boost the ailing tourism sector during the coronavirus pandemic.(Reuters)
Thailand's Tourism Minister said on Monday he had proposed a plan to allow foreigners to quarantine in some of the country's many golf resorts to boost the ailing tourism sector during the coronavirus pandemic.(Reuters)

Thai minister proposes 'golf quarantine' to boost tourism

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 11, 2021 03:49 PM IST
Thailand's Tourism Minister said on Monday he had proposed a plan to allow foreigners to quarantine in some of the country's many golf resorts to boost the ailing tourism sector during the coronavirus pandemic.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP