The court’s decision Monday means ballots must be received by Election Day to count in Wisconsin(REUTERS)
The court’s decision Monday means ballots must be received by Election Day to count in Wisconsin(REUTERS)

US Supreme Court lays out path to help Donald Trump win a contested race

Although Trump is trailing Democrat Joe Biden in national polls, the race is tighter in Wisconsin and other swing states that will determine who wins and are the focus of the two campaigns.
By Bloomberg | Posted by Nilavro Ghosh | Washington
PUBLISHED ON OCT 28, 2020 06:58 PM IST

The U.S. Supreme Court’s conservatives started carving a path that could let President Donald Trump win a contested election, issuing a far-reaching set of opinions just as Amy Coney Barrett was getting Senate confirmation to provide what could be a crucial additional vote.

In a 5-3 decision released minutes before the Senate vote Monday night, the court rejected Democratic calls to reinstate a six-day extension for the receipt of mail ballots in Wisconsin, a hotly contested state that is experiencing a surge of Covid-19 cases. The Supreme Court as a whole gave no explanation for the decision.

The outcome was bad enough for Democrats, but an opinion by Trump-appointed Justice Brett Kavanaugh bordered on catastrophic. Kavanaugh suggested sympathy for Trump’s unsubstantiated contentions that votes received after Election Day would be tainted by fraud, warning that “charges of a rigged election could explode” if late-arriving ballots change the perceived outcome.

Most states “want to avoid the chaos and suspicions of impropriety that can ensue if thousands of absentee ballots flow in after election day and potentially flip the results of an election,” Kavanaugh wrote. “And those states also want to be able to definitively announce the results of the election on election night, or as soon as possible thereafter.”

Although Trump is trailing Democrat Joe Biden in national polls, the race is tighter in Wisconsin and other swing states that will determine who wins and are the focus of the two campaigns. Two other pivotal states, Pennsylvania and North Carolina, are awaiting Supreme Court action in cases raising similar issues.

Kavanaugh’s vote -- and those of fellow Trump appointees Barrett and Neil Gorsuch -- could be crucial in any post-election dispute. With Chief Justice John Roberts showing less willingness to second-guess state election decisions, Trump could need the support of all three of his appointed justices to overturn election results that seem to favor Biden.

All three Democratic appointees dissented Monday night. Writing for the group, Justice Elena Kagan blasted Kavanaugh’s word choice, as well as his reasoning.

“There are no results to ‘flip’ until all valid votes are counted,” Kagan wrote for herself and Justices Stephen Breyer and Sonia Sotomayor. “And nothing could be more suspicious or improper than refusing to tally votes once the clock strikes 12 on election night.”

The court’s decision Monday means ballots must be received by Election Day to count in Wisconsin. Democrats were seeking to revive an extension that had been ordered by a federal trial judge because of the Covid outbreak and then blocked by an appeals court.

Kagan said the worsening pandemic in Wisconsin means that without the extension voters would have to “opt between braving the polls, with all the risk that entails, and losing their right to vote.” Kavanaugh countered that the high court order wouldn’t disenfranchise any voter who had adequately planned ahead.

The dueling opinions, however, went well beyond the Wisconsin circumstances. Kavanaugh embraced a legal theory that could let Republican-controlled state legislatures override results certified by Democratic officials. That argument, developed by three conservative justices in the 2000 Bush v. Gore case, says the Supreme Court should intervene in a presidential election dispute even when a state court is interpreting its own laws.

Citing that opinion, Kavanaugh pointed to a constitutional provision that says state legislatures get to determine how electors are appointed to the Electoral College, the body that formally selects the U.S. president.

“The text of the Constitution requires federal courts to ensure that state courts do not rewrite state election laws,” Kavanaugh wrote. He was one of three current justices, including Roberts and Barrett, who worked as lawyers for Republican George W. Bush in the 2000 election fight.

Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, North Carolina and Michigan all have Republican-controlled legislatures and Democratic governors, creating the possibility those states could send duelling slates of electors to the Electoral College in the event of a disputed election.

Kavanaugh’s opinion doesn’t necessarily mean he would invalidate votes that arrive after Election Day in states where extensions are in place, said Edward Foley, director of the election law program at Ohio State University’s Moritz College of Law.

“There’s a due process principle, at least that’s recognized by lower courts,” Foley said. “You’re not supposed to change rules governing elections after ballots have been cast. That might come into play.”

The Kavanaugh opinion nonetheless left many liberals alarmed at the growing possibility of a replay of Bush v. Gore, when the Supreme Court reversed the Florida Supreme Court and stopped ballot recounts that might have led to Democrat Al Gore’s election.

Kavanaugh “signaled that at least some of the conservative justices are willing to stop both state and federal courts, and state agencies, from easing voting restrictions and fixing voting problems when doing so deviates from the wishes of the state legislature,” said Rick Hasen, a election-law expert who teaches at the University of California, Irvine School of Law.

Gorsuch expressed views similar to Kavanaugh’s, if in less detail. “The Constitution provides that state legislatures -- not federal judges, not state judges, not state governors, not other state officials -- bear primary responsibility for setting election rules,” Gorsuch wrote in an opinion Kavanaugh joined.

Kavanaugh’s and Gorsuch’s opinions distinguished them from Roberts. Although Roberts joined the majority in the Wisconsin case, he wrote his own opinion to explain why he previously voted to allow an extra three days for ballots to arrive in Pennsylvania. The court split 4-4 in that case last week, leaving the extension intact for the time being.

Roberts said the difference was that the Pennsylvania case involved a state court applying its own constitution.

“Different bodies of law and different precedents govern these two situations and require, in these particular circumstances, that we allow the modification of election rules in Pennsylvania but not Wisconsin,” he wrote Monday.

Pennsylvania Republicans have now filed a new request to block the extension, aiming to take advantage of Barrett’s arrival on the court.

Barrett, who began work as a justice Tuesday after taking the second of two required oaths, could now be positioned to cast the deciding vote in a 2020 version of Bush v. Gore. The dynamic “is putting Justice Barrett on the spot to make that decision,” Foley said.

Although Democrats have called on Barrett to disqualify herself from Trump-related election cases, she has given no indication she will do so.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
FILE PHOTO: An illuminated Google logo is seen inside an office building in Zurich, Switzerland December 5, 2018. REUTERS/Arnd Wiegmann/File Photo(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: An illuminated Google logo is seen inside an office building in Zurich, Switzerland December 5, 2018. REUTERS/Arnd Wiegmann/File Photo(REUTERS)

'We will change Alphabet': Google workers announce global union alliance

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 10:41 PM IST
After years of protests over working conditions and business practices, 200 Google workers formed Alphabet Workers Union in early January.
Close
White House said President Joe Biden believes that gender identity should not be a bar to military service.(AP)
White House said President Joe Biden believes that gender identity should not be a bar to military service.(AP)

Joe Biden overturns Trump ban on transgender troops: White House

Reuters
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 09:49 PM IST
Former Democratic President Barack Obama in 2016 allowed trans people to serve openly and receive medical care to transition genders.
Close
Senator Rob Portman speaks during a Senate Finance Committee executive session in Washington, DC.(Bloomberg)
Senator Rob Portman speaks during a Senate Finance Committee executive session in Washington, DC.(Bloomberg)

Republican US senator Rob Portman of Ohio won't seek re-election

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 09:32 PM IST
Portman's announcement comes the same day the Senate is receiving the House impeachment article against former Republican President Donald Trump.
Close
According to the suit, Rudy Giuliani touted false claims about Dominion while marketing gold and silver coins on his YouTube show.
According to the suit, Rudy Giuliani touted false claims about Dominion while marketing gold and silver coins on his YouTube show.

Dominion Voting Systems sues Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani for $1.3 billion

Bloomberg
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 09:12 PM IST
The suit against Giuliani comes after the bogus conspiracy helped inspire a deadly insurrection at the US Capitol on January 6.
Close
The justices threw out Trump’s challenge to lower court rulings that had allowed lawsuits to go forward alleging that he violated the Constitution’s emoluments clause by accepting payments from foreign and domestic officials who stay at the Trump International Hotel and patronize other businesses owned by the former president and his family.(Reuters/ File photo)
The justices threw out Trump’s challenge to lower court rulings that had allowed lawsuits to go forward alleging that he violated the Constitution’s emoluments clause by accepting payments from foreign and domestic officials who stay at the Trump International Hotel and patronize other businesses owned by the former president and his family.(Reuters/ File photo)

Supreme Court ends Donald Trump's emoluments lawsuits

AP
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 09:00 PM IST
The high court also ordered the lower court rulings thrown out as well and directed appeals courts in New York and Richmond, Virginia, to dismiss the suits as moot now that Trump is no longer in office.
Close
A handout satellite photo taken on November 1, 2020 and obtained from Planet Labs Inc on January 20, 2021, shows a newly constructed Chinese village in an area along the disputed India-China border. (AFP)
A handout satellite photo taken on November 1, 2020 and obtained from Planet Labs Inc on January 20, 2021, shows a newly constructed Chinese village in an area along the disputed India-China border. (AFP)

No record of Sikkim clash in PLA patrol log: Chinese state media

By Sutirtho Patranobis I Edited by Vinod Janardhanan
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 08:57 PM IST
“This is fake news. Based on what I learned, there is no record of this clash in the patrol log of the Chinese side,” wrote Hu Xijin, the high-profile editor of the nationalist tabloid Global Times, on Twitter.
Close
A plane carrying two million doses of AstraZeneca/Oxford vaccines against the coronavirus disease from India lands at Galeao Air Base in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on January 22. (Reuters file)
A plane carrying two million doses of AstraZeneca/Oxford vaccines against the coronavirus disease from India lands at Galeao Air Base in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on January 22. (Reuters file)

China plays down India’s vaccine diplomacy

By Sutirtho Patranobis I Edited by Vinod Janardhanan
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 08:28 PM IST
It is up to each country to decide which Covid-19 vaccine it wishes to use, and there should not be vicious competition or confrontation, Chinese foreign ministry said on Monday.
Close
France has sided with Greece in a dispute over boundaries in the Aegean Sea and eastern Mediterranean that has brought NATO members Greece and Turkey to the brink of war several times in recent decades. (Representative Image)(PTI file photo)
France has sided with Greece in a dispute over boundaries in the Aegean Sea and eastern Mediterranean that has brought NATO members Greece and Turkey to the brink of war several times in recent decades. (Representative Image)(PTI file photo)

Greece, France to sign $2.8 billion fighter jet deal

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 08:10 PM IST
Florence Parly, the French defense minister, signed the agreement in Athens to deliver 12 used and six new aircraft built by Dassault Aviation over two years, starting in July.
Close
NIH National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Director Anthony Fauci listens to a reporter's question.(REUTERS)
NIH National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases Director Anthony Fauci listens to a reporter's question.(REUTERS)

Dr Anthony Fauci reveals ‘disturbing’ incidents under Trump administration

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Kunal Gaurav
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 07:55 PM IST
Fauci, who now serves as the chief medical adviser to President Joe Biden, frequently contradicted Trump over the latter’s statements related to virus response.
Close
The pub first opened in 1566 and was moved to its present location on St Giles, a broad thoroughfare in the city centre, in 1613. It is owned by St John's College, one of 45 colleges and private halls that make up the University of Oxford.(REUTERS)
The pub first opened in 1566 and was moved to its present location on St Giles, a broad thoroughfare in the city centre, in 1613. It is owned by St John's College, one of 45 colleges and private halls that make up the University of Oxford.(REUTERS)

Loved by students, scholars and writers for 450 years, Oxford pub shuts down

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 07:49 PM IST
The Lamb and Flag, once frequented by the likes of "Lord of the Rings" author J.R.R. Tolkien and his friend C.S. Lewis, who wrote "The Chronicles of Narnia", has suffered a disastrous loss of revenues since the start of the pandemic.
Close
The government has been delaying the signing of a collective bargaining deal with health workers for 18 months and the workers have been on strike since December. (Representative Image)(AFP)
The government has been delaying the signing of a collective bargaining deal with health workers for 18 months and the workers have been on strike since December. (Representative Image)(AFP)

Bosnia health workers protest for rights, wages amidst pandemic

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 07:30 PM IST
The union of health workers in the Herzegovina-Neretva region also set up a large tent in front of the regional government building and said they would camp there until the government has met their requests.
Close
Opinion polls have been split on the Catalonia election. But some, including one by the Centre for Sociological Studies (CIS), have shown Illa's Socialists, now the fourth-largest party in the regional parliament, on track to win the biggest share of the vote in the February 14 election.(REUTERS)
Opinion polls have been split on the Catalonia election. But some, including one by the Centre for Sociological Studies (CIS), have shown Illa's Socialists, now the fourth-largest party in the regional parliament, on track to win the biggest share of the vote in the February 14 election.(REUTERS)

Spain's health minister quits amid pandemic to run for regional Catalan election

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 07:00 PM IST
"Salvador Illa starts today his last 24 hours at the helm of the ministry," the office of Socialist Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez said in a statement. "Tomorrow Tuesday will be his last cabinet meeting and his replacement will be disclosed."
Close
"Guided by science, reason and humanitarian spirit, the world has achieved initial progress in fighting Covid-19," the president said.(AFP)
"Guided by science, reason and humanitarian spirit, the world has achieved initial progress in fighting Covid-19," the president said.(AFP)

Pandemic far from over, but winter cannot stop arrival of spring: Xi Jinping

PTI, New Delhi/davos
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 06:36 PM IST
In a special address at the World Economic Forum's online Davos Agenda Summit, Jinping also said the pandemic should be an excuse for reversing gains from globalisation and promised further opening up of the Chinese economy.
Close
The UAE has ramped up its immunisation campaign with the aim of vaccinating more than 50% of its roughly 9 million population before the end of March. (Representative Image)(REUTERS (Representative Image))
The UAE has ramped up its immunisation campaign with the aim of vaccinating more than 50% of its roughly 9 million population before the end of March. (Representative Image)(REUTERS (Representative Image))

Dubai replaces health authority chief as UAE sees surge in Covid-19 cases

Reuters
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 06:17 PM IST
Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum appointed Awad Saghir al-Ketbi as the new director general of the Dubai Health Authority, replacing Humaid al-Qutami, according to a statement issued on Sunday.
Close
The United Nations agency noted that most people who lost work stopped looking for a job altogether, likely because of restrictions on businesses that hire in big numbers like restaurants, bars, stores, hotels and other services that depend on face-to-face interactions. (Representative Image)(AFP)
The United Nations agency noted that most people who lost work stopped looking for a job altogether, likely because of restrictions on businesses that hire in big numbers like restaurants, bars, stores, hotels and other services that depend on face-to-face interactions. (Representative Image)(AFP)

Job losses from virus four times as bad as 2009 financial crisis: UN report

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 25, 2021 05:37 PM IST
The International Labor Organization estimated that the restrictions on businesses and public life destroyed 8.8% of all work hours around the world last year.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP