India, US in talks to break N-deal impasse

India and the US are making last-ditch efforts to break an impasse over a few ticklish issues at critical talks on the 123 agreement to implement their landmark civil nuclear deal.
HT Image
HT Image
Updated on Jul 16, 2007 01:25 PM IST
Copy Link
IANS | By, Washington

India and the US are making last-ditch efforts to break an impasse over a few ticklish issues at critical talks on the 123 agreement to implement their landmark civil nuclear deal.

A team of senior Indian officials including National Security Advisor MK Narayanan, Department of Atomic Energy Chairman Anil Kakodkar and Foreign Secretary Shivshankar Menon are having informal parleys at various levels Monday before plunging into a formal round on Tuesday.

The Indian team is expected to meet with US National Security Advisor Stephen Hadley at the White House Wednesday after a dinner Tuesday night by the key US negotiator on the nuclear deal under secretary of state for political affairs, R Nicholas Burns. He also "hosts" Tuesday's talks.

Both sides claim to be "making steady progress" on finalising the 123 agreement to implement the deal that would allow resumption of nuclear commerce between the two countries after a gap of 30 years. But a compromise formula has eluded them so far.

The sticky points essentially boil down to India's insistence on its right to reprocess US supplied nuclear fuel, conduct a nuclear test and guarantees for continued supply of fuel for the 14 civil reactors it has agreed to place under international safeguards under a separation plan. Eight other reactors designated military would not be subject to inspections.

Monday's parleys intriguingly begin with a closed door meeting with experts at the Carnegie Enodwment for International Peace, a leading US think tank which recently advised the US Congress not to "budge from the law it established last year to set parameters for a US-India nuclear cooperation agreement".

Testifying before a House committee recently George Perkovich, vice president for studies global security and economic development, said, "...The Hyde Act was imperfect, certainly from a non-proliferation point of view, but it was a decent balance of conflicting interests.

"Now India is pushing hard to depart from or alter the deal. The Administration may be tempted to yield to India or to fudge the matter in ways that would allow India to circumvent the minimal non-proliferation limits in the Hyde Act.

"Congress should stand firm. If it does not, many states will conclude that the rule-based non-proliferation regime is nothing but a sham - that US policy in truth is to bend the rules for itself and its friends such as India, while twisting other peoples' arms to impose the rules on states America does not like," Perkovich advised.

The Hyde Act is indeed the bone of contention with the Indian side contending that the Hyde Act restrictions go far beyond the scope of the joint statements issued by Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and US President George Bush on July 18, 2005 and March 2, 2006 that set the ball rolling for the deal.

The US side, on the other hand, has been pleading its unwillingness or inability to sidestep restrictions placed on India by the act passed by the US Congress last December approving the deal in principle.

The US Congress has to again approve the final 123 agreement in an up or down vote before the nuclear deal is implemented. Making any changes in the law now are considered an uphill task with the Democratic controlled Congress at loggerheads with President George Bush though the India deal has broad bipartisan support.

Ahead of the talks, Washington has signalled its readiness "to resolve the remaining outstanding issues on the 123 agreement", with an unusual State department statement expressing confidence that "that with continued hard work, flexibility, and good spirit, we will reach a final agreement."

The two sides have also sought to give a political push to the long-stalled deal with Singh speaking to Bush Wednesday ahead of the talks. Bush is equally if not more keen on the deal that may go down as a major foreign policy success for the embattled president on par with Richard Nixon's opening up to China in 1972.

The two leaders also had a brief exchange on the sidelines of the G-8 summit in Germany where the Indian side came up with a proposal for setting up a stand-alone dedicated facility for reprocessing US-origin fuel as a way out of the impasse.

Both sides are keen to conclude the deal at the earliest as there is only a small window left to present the 123 agreement to the Congress for final approval before it goes into another election cycle and President Bush leaves office in January 2009.

The composition of the Indian delegation that besides Narayanan and Kakodkar will include the ambassador to US Ronen Sen, New Delhi's envoy to Singapore and an expert in nuclear issues S. Jaishankar, and Venkatesh Varma, an official from the PMO, indicates a desire to get things going by keeping all the stakeholders in the loop.

The US too is leaving no stone unturned. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has cancelled a scheduled trip to the Middle East and Congo, while the meeting between two national security advisers is taking place at the White House.

Riding on the nuclear-and-technology proposal are tens of billions of dollars in potential deals for the American business in energy, aircraft, infrastructure and procurement sectors.


    Arun Kumar is Senior Assistant Editor with Hindustan Times. He has spent two-and-half decades covering Bihar, including politics, educational and social issues.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Police officers in riot gears stand guard to stop the supporters of the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) political party after they broke in to the Red Zone, during a protest march called by ousted Prime Minister Imran Khan, in Islamabad, Pakistan May 26, 2022. (REUTERS/Akhtar Soomro)

    Imran, PTI leaders booked over arson, vandalism by supporters during Azadi March

    In the first case, a First Information Report was registered for fire and vandalism on the Jinnah Avenue, while a second FIR was launched for arson and damage to property in the Express Chowk area of the city. Both the FIRs were registered on the complaint of police officials, but the second case clearly named Imran Khan and senior PTI leaders Asad Umar, Imran Ismail, Raja Khurram Nawaz, Ali Amin Gandapur and Ali Nawaz Awan among others.

  • Representational image.

    Instagram down for thousands of users: Downdetector

    Meta Platforms Inc's image-sharing platform Instagram was down for thousands of users on Thursday, according to outage-tracking website More than 6,000 users reported issues with Instagram on Downdetector, which tracks outages by collating status reports from several sources including user-submitted errors on its platform. The outage may be affecting a larger number of users. Meta did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment.

  • Peru's National Seismological Center said the quake had a magnitude of 6.9 and a depth of 240 kilometres.

    Powerful 7.2-magnitude quake rocks southern Peru

    A strong 7.2-magnitude earthquake rocked southeastern Peru on Thursday, the US Geological Survey said, with Peruvian authorities adding there were no dead or injured. The quake hit at 7:02 am local time (1202 GMT), at a depth of 218 kilometers (135 miles), according to the USGS, sending people fleeing into the streets. Peru's National Seismological Center said the quake had a magnitude of 6.9 and a depth of 240 kilometers.

  • Representative Image

    Facebook to roll out updated privacy policy from July 26

    Social media platform Meta, formerly Facebook, has started sending out notification to users about privacy policy update which it will roll out from July 26, the company said on Thursday. Meta in its post said that it has rewritten and re-designed its privacy policy to make it easier to understand and clearer about how it uses users' information.

  • The costume is estimated to have costed more than <span class='webrupee'>₹</span> 12 lakh.

    Man in Japan spends 12 lakh to look like a dog, pictures go viral

    In a bizarre incident, a man from Japan has fulfilled his lifelong dream to look alike a dog by spending a whopping amount of 12 lakh. The man didn't go for any medical procedure but commissioned a life-sized dog costume from a professional agency called Zeppet to look like a collie - dog breed. Japanese news portal news.mynavi reported that Zeppet is known for making sculptures for advertisements, movies, and amusement parks.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, May 27, 2022