Running out of time

Fresh threats to Pakistan could make it lose interest in a a Kashmir solution, writes Prem Shankar Jha.
HT Image
HT Image
Updated on Mar 10, 2007 05:58 PM IST
Copy Link
None | ByPrem Shankar Jha

Given the visceral distrust that the intelligence agencies of India and Pakistan feel towards each other, the first meeting of the joint anti-terror mechanism has gone better than one could have hoped for.

What has made it a success is the commitment made to each other by the two countries - not wait for the formal quarterly meetings but pass on "information that needs to be conveyed on a priority basis".

They have agreed to help each other with ongoing investigations. If both sides adhere to these commitments, the wall of distrust that has divided them could come down in a matter of months.

Pakistan will disarm Indian sceptics the very first time it warns them of an impending terrorist attack.

India can reciprocate by doing whatever is necessary to convince Pakistan that it is not stoking the fires of separatism in Balochistan.

Neither should be hard to do, for they are in the interests of both countries. But they must be done soon because the window of opportunity for settling the Kashmir dispute and restoring a truly stable communal peace in the Indian subcontinent is about to close.

It is not closing because of the Congress' recent reverses in state and municipal elections.

Nor is it closing because President Musharraf will soon face an election in Pakistan and will be looking for ways to shore up his popu1arity.

It is closing because Pakistan is facing new threats to its stability and territorial integrity that could make it lose interest in a Kashmir settlement, if they develop further.

These threats arise from developments within the United States. Five years after its intervention in Afghanistan, its attempt to eradicate the Taliban has got nowhere.

The Taliban has revived and doubled the number of attacks upon US and NATO forces. It suffers from no dearth of recruits, and is awash in drug money from Afghanistan's 5,466-ton opium crop.

But US determination to eradicate it has not wavered. In its eyes, not only does the military operation have the sanction of the UN and NATO, but the Taliban made 9/11 possible and have, thus, to be punished to the fullest extent.

Cutting a deal with them is simply unthinkable. The Bush administration has therefore concluded that neither it nor NATO will be able to defeat it and restore peace in Afghanistan if Pakistan continues to give Taliban leaders sanctuary in Waziristan.

That is what the General Musharraf's Miranshahr agreement of September 5 with the tribal chiefs of North Waziristan, and a similar agreement a year earlier in South Waziristan have, in effect, done.

For the last six months, therefore, the US has been ratcheting up pressure on Musharraf to attack and destroy Taliban bases that it claims to have identified in Waziristan and Balochistan and to send in more of its army to seal the Afghan border.

The strategy it has adopted has evolved out of the working of American democracy and been used with devastating effect on other countries. It can be termed 'dancing on three legs'.

Pressure for change of policy first manifests itself in the media. The barrage of information it releases triggers demands for a change of policy in the US Congress.

That gives the administration the pretext it seeks to make the change. In this case, the pressure first became apparent in the American media when Musharraf arrived in New York for the UN General Assembly a few days after signing the agreement.

He was greeted by a spate of hostile articles that described the Miranshahr agreement as a deal brokered by the Taliban and a 'sell-out'.

Intelligence officials based in Peshawar and Islamabad suddenly could not stop talking to the media. Attacks by the Taliban, they claimed, had increased 300 per cent.

Pakistan's willingness to provide sanctuary was directly responsible. They forgot to mention that the figure referred to attacks since June, whereas the agreement was barely three-weeks-old.

In the months that have followed, the media have discovered Al-Qaeda training camps in Pakistan that are training Europeans for attacks in Europe and the US.

Mullah Omar has been seen in Quetta and when an American journalist visited the city - defying a ban on media visiting sensitive areas - and got roughed up by the Pakistan police, it was interpreted as proof that the government was protecting Mullah Omar.

The second 'leg' came down on the ground with a thump on March 2. At a hearing before the US Senate, a parade of senior army officials claimed that they could not defeat the Taliban as long as Pakistan did not deny them sanctuary in Waziristan.

They claimed that they had the right to attack Al-Qaeda and Taliban camps inside Pakistan and were prepared to do so if Pakistan did not do it on its own.

Senators supported them from both parties. A11the while administration officials remained studiously silent.

The message to Pakistan was clear - attack the Taliban and close the border, or we will do it for you. The day when the US will put the third leg down - administrative sanction followed by military action - may not be far away.

The NATO and the US have come to know that a Taliban spring offensive is on the way. A senior Taliban leader boasted to Al Jazeera TV recently that they had recruited 6,000 fighters, including hundreds of suicide bombers, for the offensive.

Pakistan has vigorously refuted the US right to launch attacks on its side of the border with Afghanistan.

Its ambassador in Washington, Mahmud Durrani, has warned the media that doing this would not only seriously endanger Musharraf but would destabilise Pakistan itself.

But there has been no let up in pressure. On the contrary, Canadian PM Stephen Harper is the latest in a long line of leaders who have urged Pakistan to 'do more'.

The Pakistan government is unlikely to survive if the people see it as complicit in a US onslaught on Pashtuns in Pakistan.

Today there are well over 20 million Pashtuns in the country, and they make up more than a fifth of the army Feelings are already running dangerously high against Musharraf for having supported the US in other parts of the country.

Even moderate Pakistanis feel that they have already done more than their fair share. Eighty thousand Pakistani troops are manning 1,000 points between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Seven hundred have lost their lives. Pakistan has delivered an equal number of Taliban and Al-Qaeda leaders and cadres to the Americans, including the Taliban's No 2, Mullah Obaidullah Akhund, only last week.

But control of the border is impossible because the same people live on either side. The US cannot ask Pakistan to commit suicide.

But Pakistan cannot expect the US and NATO to accept the present situation either. The only slim chance of finding a way out lies in India and Pakistan using their combined influence in Afghanistan to bring all parties to the conference table in the hope of brokering a new political settlement.

To say that this will not be easy is an understatement. But such an initiative stands a better chance of success than a military campaign without sufficient troops against an increasingly national Pashtun uprising, in one of the most difficult terrains in the world.

However, it cannot even get off the ground if Pakistan and India do not first bury their mutual mistrust.

India has made just this proposal forcefully to Pakistan on at least two occasions, but received no response.

Instead, sizeable sections of its military and intelligence still believe that India is its main enemy in Pakistan and its best course is to drive Indians out and ride to Kabul on the backs of the Taliban.

The US Senate hearing may finally have convinced the hawks that that option is firmly closed. President Musharraf has taken the warning seriously enough to summon six of his ambassadors for consultation including those in India, Afghanistan, Iran and the US.

The time is ripe for making a fresh start.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The style of architecture of the buildings at Xiol is more typical of the style found in regions further south.

    Mexico: Archaeologists uncover 1,500-year-old city full of palaces, pyramids

    Archaeologists working in the Yucatan region of Mexico have revealed the remains of a centuries-old Mayan city, local media reported on Friday. The area was first uncovered in 2018 on a construction site for a future industrial park close to the town of Merida on Yucatan's northern coast. Archaeologists from the National Institute for Anthropology and History then took over the site.

  • A report claimed Imran Khan was approached by several channels to withdraw his Azadi march. 

    Imran Khan ended Azadi march abruptly after talking to these 3 persons: Report

    Former Pakistan prime minister Imran Khan who was determined to carry on with his protest until the government announces a fresh election on May 26 ended the Azadi march which reached Islamabad leaving trails of violence and destruction in Punjab, Karachi and Lahore. Addressing his supporters, Imran Khan announced an end to the march and gave a six-day deadline to the government to announce the election.

  • Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi holding a meeting with Samoa Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mataafa after agreements signing ceremony between China and Samao in Apia. (AFP)

    China signs deal with Samoa to strengthen ties

    China and the island nation of Samoa on Saturday signed a deal to strengthen ties amid a flurry of diplomatic activity across a cluster of remote islands in the Pacific Ocean where Canberra, Washington and Beijing have begun to campaign and jostle for influence. The deal signed between visiting Chinese foreign minister Wang Yi and Samoan Prime Minister Fiame Naomi Mataafa promised “greater collaboration” between the two countries. Details of the deal remain unclear.

  • Bangladesh foreign minister AK Abdul Momen addressed the Asian Confluence River Conclave, NADI-3, in Guwahati on Saturday. (ANI Photo)

    Bangladesh says Rohingyas could turn to extremism, seeks help for repatriation

    Bangladesh foreign minister AK Abdul Momen on Saturday said that Rohingya refugees staying in his country could turn to extremism and sought help from India and other countries in the region to repatriate them to Myanmar. The session was attended by a host of dignitaries including external affairs minister S Jaishankar, Assam chief minister Himanta Biswa Sarma and ambassadors and high commissioners of several South East Asian countries including Myanmar.

  • US woman shoots dead man who fired rifle into crowd in West Virginia. (GETTY IMAGES.)

    US woman shoots dead man who fired rifle into crowd in West Virginia

    A woman in West Virginia fatally shot a man who began firing an AR-15-style rifle into a crowd of people that had gathered for a party, authorities said. Dennis Butler, 37, was killed Wednesday night after he pulled out the rifle and began shooting at dozens of people attending the birthday-graduation party outside an apartment complex in the city of Charleston, police said in a statement. No one at the party was injured.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, May 28, 2022