Homeless don’t live, they merely exist: HC

Updated on Jul 06, 2022 04:02 AM IST
Remarking that the homeless don’t live but merely exist, the Delhi high court directed the relocation of five slum dwellers who were shifted from one slum site to another to facilitate the expansion of the New Delhi railway station.
A homeless person in New Delhi . (PTI)
A homeless person in New Delhi . (PTI)
By, New Delhi

Remarking that the homeless don’t live but merely exist, the Delhi high court directed the relocation of five slum dwellers who were shifted from one slum site to another to facilitate the expansion of the New Delhi railway station.

The order comes on a petition by the slum dwellers, who had challenged their eviction from Lahori Gate, for the expansion of the New Delhi railway station, from nine platforms to 16.

Delivering the order on Monday (July 4), justice C Hari Shankar said the petitioner slum dwellers would be entitled to relocation if they produce correct documentary evidence that before moving to the second slum colony on the Lahori Gate side in 2003, they lived in the original slum colony, i.e. Shahid Basti jhuggi in Nabi Karim, from a date prior to November 30, 1998, then they would be entitled to an alternative accommodation under the relocation policy of the ministry of housing and urban affairs.

Also read: Slum rehabilitation housing: Secluding people, one floor at a time

“The homeless, who people the pavements, the footpaths, and those inaccessible nooks and crannies of the city from where the teeming multitudes prefer to avert their eyes, live on the fringes of existence. Indeed, they do not live, but merely exist; for life, with its myriad complexions and contours, as envisaged by Article 21 of our Constitution, is unknown to them,” the court said.

The court also held that the petitioners would be allotted alternative accommodation, in accordance with the relocation policy as expeditiously as possible, and not later than six months from the date of production of the requisite documents before the Railways.

Stating that slum dwellers are “hounded by poverty and penury” and do not stay there out of choice, the judge asserted that law, with all its legalese, is worth tinsel, if the underprivileged cannot get justice and courts should be sensitive when the underprivileged knock on the doors of justice.

“The court is required to remain alive to the fact that such litigants do not have access to exhaustive legal resources…As one of the three coequal wings of the government, albeit functioning independent of, and uninfluenced by, the other two, the judiciary is required to remain as sensitive…At the end of the day, our preambular goal is not law, but justice. Law is but the instrument, the via media, as it were, to attain the ultimate goal of justice, and law which cannot aspire to justice is, therefore, not worth administering,” the court said in a 32-page judgment.

“Even a bare attempt at imagining how they live is, for us, peering out from our gilt-edged cocoons, cathartic. And so we prefer not to do so; as a result, these denizens of the dark continue to eke out their existence, not day by day, but often hour by hour, if not minute by minute,” justice Shankar said.

Also read: Delhi govt enlists help from college students to survey slum residents

The petitioners claimed to have been residing in the Shahid Basti jhuggi (slum) cluster since the 1980s. They claimed that their names were entered in the electoral register and they were exercising their voting rights. They also claimed to be in possession of ration cards and other documents establishing their claim that, since the 1980s, they had been residing in the Shahid Basti slum colony.

In 2002-2003, the Railways, which was seeking to convert the New Delhi Railway Station into a “world-classfacility and in order to increase the number of platforms from nine to 16, desired to acquire the land on which the petitioners were situated.

The petitioners argued that they were shifted to another location on the opposite side of the tracks, and set up a slum colony there.

The court held that if a resident of the Lahori Gate slum had been a jhuggi dweller, albeit on the other side of the tracks, from a period prior to the cutoff date (November 30, 1998), it would be unjust, unfair and contrary to the avowed purpose and objective of the relocation policy to deny him the benefit or relocation.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Anand Mohan (right).

    6 cops suspended for providing special treatment to ex-MP and convict Anand Mohan

    Six police personnel, including a sub-inspector (SI), were suspended for allegedly providing 'special treatment' to convicted gangster-turned-politician Anand Mohan Singh when he appeared at a Patna court on August 12. Saharsa superintendent of police Lipi Singh took the action on Monday, including four DAP jawans and an SAP driver, and ordered departmental proceedings against them. Anand Mohan was accused of inciting a mob to lynch the young Dalit IAS officer on December 5, 1994.

  • A Shivneri bus HT Archives

    Shivneri buses to Pune from Thane and Borivali to be replaced with low-cost Shivai

    Come October, commuters headed to Pune from Thane and Borivali will have a low-cost, yet comfortable transport facility. The Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation is planning to replace the iconic Shivneri buses on this route with electric Shivai buses. However, the Shivneri buses will continue to ply between Dadar and Pune. Currently, Shivneri buses charge ₹450 per passenger.

  • Students in the process of getting admission at Miranda House College in New Delhi. The admission process is on for the new academic session in Delhi University. (Photo by Sushil Kumar/Hindustan Times)

    Only 20% FYJC aspirants confirm admission in four days, deadline on Wednesday

    Mumbai: Blame it on the long weekend and travel plans or students refusing to alter their college preference, just 20% first-year junior college (FYJC) aspirants from the second merit list have confirmed admissions until Monday. College principals have attributed this low admission acceptance to students travelling during the long weekend. The second merit list was released by the office of the deputy director of education (DyDE) on August 12, where 69,691 students were allotted seats.

  • On the day of the incident, the couple had a heated exchange of words at night and after which Mukhtar fled from the area. Since he is absconding, it appears that he had killed his wife, said the police officer, adding that there are strangulation marks on her neck. (HT Photo)

    Man strangulates wife over petty issue, flees

    Mumbai: A 33-year-old man allegedly killed hMukhtar'swife by strangulating her over a trivial issue in wee hours on Sunday and fled from the house. JJ Marg police have launched a manhunt for him. According to the police, the deceased was identified as Manzila Shaikh, 30, who was staying in Imamwada area along JJ Marg along with her husband, Sukhchand Shaikh alias Mukhtar, 33.

  • Officials declined to clarify their decision on this proposal for the time being, but added that compensatory afforestation to offset this loss is proposed to be carried out by the PGCI on 45 hectares of degraded forest land in the Boisar range, in Palghar itself. (HT Photo)

    1,436 more trees to be axed for Mumbai-Ahmedabad bullet train

    A total of 1,436 trees in the Dahanu forest range, in Palghar district, are proposed to be felled to make way for the upcoming Mumbai-Ahmedabad Bullet Train. The 1,400 odd trees are located on 22 hectares of forest land across three villages (Betegaon, Valva and Shigaon) in Palghar. The proposal was considered by the REC on August 10.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 15, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now