Saeed Ajmal chucking ban only highlights a growing problem

It is no secret that Pakistan off-spinner Saeed Ajmal bends his arm, and with it the rules on illegal bowling that are deemed too liberal.
By N Ananthanarayanan | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON SEP 10, 2014 02:38 AM IST

It is no secret that Pakistan off-spinner Saeed Ajmal bends his arm, and with it the rules on illegal bowling that are deemed too liberal. The bowler is an integral part of the Pakistan team, much like Muttiah Muralithan was for Sri Lanka, but like the Sri Lankan star, his action has come under as much scrutiny as his wickets.



The International Cricket Council (ICC) banned the 36-year-old on Tuesday from bowling in international cricket after bio-mechanic analysis showed all his deliveries exceed the 15 degrees of elbow flex allowed. Ajmal, who was reported after the first Test in Sri Lanka last month and underwent tests, can apply to the ICC for a re-assessment after he modifies his bowling action.



For Pakistan, this is a huge jolt in the near and long term. They face Australia in a Test and limited-overs series in the United Arab Emirates and Ajmal will be crucial to their hopes at next year's World Cup in Australia and New Zealand.



But the ban of the most high-profile current spinner in the world also points to a malaise that has spread roots in the game. While there is much noise over corruption, chucking is no longer seen as something that needs to be rooted out with equal aggression.



There are several aspects to the problem. It has a regional bias, youngsters taking up spin bowling see the likes of Muralitharan and Ajmal, and before him Saqlain Mushtaq, as role models. Young boys give up the classical bowling action, and try to imitate the jerky approach. This gets them into trouble once they develop, when it becomes too late to change things.



Some blame should be laid on junior coaches while the pressure to succeed across formats, and hence the need to bowl quick through the air as well as a variety of deliveries, adds to the problem.



Former India spinner Maninder Singh, lays the blame on the way cricket administrators handled the case of Muralitharan. He was cleared with his action blamed on hyperextension of his elbow. Muralitharan being called for chucking in Australia in the 1995 led to a major stand-off between Sri Lanka and Australia. However, world cricket eventually accepted his success as the ICC settled on its controversial 15 degree rule.



Maninder says, "The problem started with Muralitharan. The menace should have been stopped then. If that had happened, all boards would have taken steps to prevent this," he told HT. "Now it (chucking) has become a norm, it is like 'if he (Murali) can do it, anyone can'."



Many bowlers in the sub-continent grow up with jerky actions that are not corrected early. And few agree the doosra delivery, leaving the right-hander, can be bowled without chucking.Off-spinners wearing longer sleeves have only added to the suspicion.



In India, too, Harbhajan Singh and Rajesh Chauhan were reported for chucking and had to undergo remedial action. But letting Muralitharan off the hook had a fallout in India in the form of Gujarat off-spinner Mohnish Parmar.



Parmar modelled his action on Muralitharan and even played for India under-19. He was called for chucking and cleared by a Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) panel in 2009. But it again banned him from bowling in 2010, and Parmar returned in 2012 after working for a year to change his action.



Picking the wrong bowlers as role models has only worsened the problem, feels Maninder. "This has ruined careers. Whether you call it 12 or 15 degrees, it is to be blamed."



Why is this problem not acute in England or Australia? "People there are basically honest, and they will own up. We don't, and in fact start backing them."



Pakistan fast bowler Shoaib Akhtar too was called for chucking, but allowed to bowl again after it was deemed because of a hyperextended elbow.



Experts insist the doosra cannot be bowled without bending the elbow. "Even in my academy, so many boys bend their elbows. They see lot of cricket on TV and try to imitate them. It gets difficult to correct them once they are set in their ways," said former India all-rounder Madan Lal.



Lal, also a former India coach, is surprised the ICC waited until this long. "Ajmal has almost taken 200 wickets (178 wickets, 35 Tests) and the ICC has suddenly woken up." Ajmal's was reported in 2009, but subsequently cleared.



Not many are convinced that administrators are going all out to tackle the problem. In fact, some believe they are trying to persuade TV commentators, mostly former players, from saying what they see. They toe the line for fear of losing their jobs.





SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
BCCI president Sourav Ganguly(AFP)
BCCI president Sourav Ganguly(AFP)

Two stents implanted after fresh angioplasty, Sourav Ganguly stable

UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:16 PM IST
Earlier in the day, doctors carried out a series of medical tests on Ganguly, who was hospitalised on Wednesday for the second time in a month, because of a cardiac condition.
Close
Bharat Arun and Ravi Shastri(Twitter)
Bharat Arun and Ravi Shastri(Twitter)

'If bowlers concede a boundary, Ravi Shastri shouts at me': India bowling coach

By hindustantimes.com
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 05:51 PM IST
Bharat Arun, who has been one of the main reasons behind India’s rise in producing a pool of Test-match quality fast bowlers, said head coach Ravi Shastri watches the match from the dressing room shouts at him when a bowler is hit for a boundary.
Close
Indian team with the trophy after beating England 3-0 at home in 1992-93 series(Getty Images)
Indian team with the trophy after beating England 3-0 at home in 1992-93 series(Getty Images)

India vs England: History of Tests in India - Part 2 - (1972-73 to 1992-93)

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 03:04 PM IST
  • England in India: In part two we will look at the series between 1972-73 to 1992-93.
Close
India's Rishabh Pant falls as he hits the ball for four runs during play on the final day of the fourth cricket test between India and Australia at the Gabba, Brisbane, Australia, Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021.(AP)
India's Rishabh Pant falls as he hits the ball for four runs during play on the final day of the fourth cricket test between India and Australia at the Gabba, Brisbane, Australia, Tuesday, Jan. 19, 2021.(AP)

'Was following IND vs AUS series and thought I bat the same way as Rishabh Pant'

By hindustantimes.com
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 09:01 PM IST
Further explaining the rationale behind his comment, Jermaine Blackwood said Rishabh Pant always puts the bowler under pressure, which is pretty similar to the way he bats in Test cricket.
Close
Ashantha de Mel(Twitter)
Ashantha de Mel(Twitter)

Sri Lanka chief selector quits after 0-2 defeat against England

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 08:24 PM IST
Sri Lanka Cricket (SLC) said in a statement that Ashantha has resigned from the post with immediate effect, citing personal reasons.
Close
Hasan Ali's photo shared by ICC on its official social media handles(ICC/Twitter)
Hasan Ali's photo shared by ICC on its official social media handles(ICC/Twitter)

Twitter can't keep calm after ICC trolls Pakistan's Hasan Ali on social media

By hindustantimes.com
UPDATED ON JAN 28, 2021 07:55 PM IST
ICC's post on Hasan Ali went viral on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. There were mixed reactions from the Twitteratis. While some had no issues with the humour, the others were not pleased with ICC’s decision to troll a cricketer.
Close
Pakistan's Abid Ali celebrates with teammates after taking the catch of South Africa's Rassie van der Dussen during the third day of the first cricket test match between Pakistan and South Africa in Karachi.(AP)
Pakistan's Abid Ali celebrates with teammates after taking the catch of South Africa's Rassie van der Dussen during the third day of the first cricket test match between Pakistan and South Africa in Karachi.(AP)

Pakistan seize control of 1st test with 3 late wickets

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:55 PM IST
Aiden Markram and Rassie van der Dussen led South Africa's resistance in overturning a 158-run first-innings deficit.
Close
File image of Dilhara Lokuhettige.(Twitter)
File image of Dilhara Lokuhettige.(Twitter)

Former SL cricketer Lokuhettige guilty under ICC anti-corruption code

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:17 PM IST
Lokuhettige was charged under the ICC Anti-Corruption Code in November 2019 for his involvement in match-fixing during a T20 tournament in UAE in 2017, where a Sri Lankan team participated.
Close
England captain Joe Root (L) shaking hands with Indian captain Virat Kohli (R)(HT Archive)
England captain Joe Root (L) shaking hands with Indian captain Virat Kohli (R)(HT Archive)

IND vs ENG series opener only a week away but TV rights remain undecided in UK

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 06:05 PM IST
The rights, worth around 20 million pounds, are expected to be awarded soon for the four-Test series, which is part of the World Test Championship.
Close
Photo of former England coach Andy Flower(Twitter)
Photo of former England coach Andy Flower(Twitter)

Andy Flower backs England’s ‘formidable combination of players’ for India Tests

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 05:44 PM IST
Flower denied to pick a favourite for the upcoming Test series but mentioned that the England side has a ‘formidable combination’ of players who are capable of putting themselves in 'winning situations'.
Close
File photo of former England spinner Monty Panesar(Getty Images)
File photo of former England spinner Monty Panesar(Getty Images)

‘He’s become smarter’: Panesar says tackling Indian spinner will be key for ENG

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 02:50 PM IST
Monty Panesar suggested that Ashwin will come into the series ‘with tons of confidence’ after a terrific series on the Aussie soil.
Close
Rajasthan batsman Mahipal Lomror playing a shot during Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy quarter-final match - 4 against Bihar(Twitter)
Rajasthan batsman Mahipal Lomror playing a shot during Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy quarter-final match - 4 against Bihar(Twitter)

Mushtaq Ali T20: TN holds edge over Rajasthan; Punjab favourites vs Baroda

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 02:06 PM IST
Rajasthan's top-scorer in the tournament is Ankit Lamba (198 runs) but he would like to improve on his strike-rate. Rajasthan will, however, depend on their premier leg spinner Rahul Chahar (11 wickets) who has been named as a stand by for England series
Close
File photo of umpire Bruce Oxenford.(Twitter/ICC)
File photo of umpire Bruce Oxenford.(Twitter/ICC)

Umpire Bruce Oxenford calls time on international career

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 01:25 PM IST
  • Before becoming an umpire, Oxenford represented Queensland in eight first-class matches as a leg-spin bowler and lower-order batsman.
Close
Photo of South African pacer Kagiso Rabada(AP)
Photo of South African pacer Kagiso Rabada(AP)

Kagiso Rabada cleans up Hasan Ali to claim his 200th Test wicket - WATCH

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 28, 2021 01:17 PM IST
Kagiso Rabada, playing his 44th test, is now the youngest South African to complete 200 test wickets. He returned with figures of 3-70.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP