In recent times, there has been a spike in the number of cases judges refusing to hear for unknown reasons.
In recent times, there has been a spike in the number of cases judges refusing to hear for unknown reasons.

Do citizens have a right to know why a judge has opted out of a case?

Two judges have recused themselves from hearing the AAP government’s petition against the Centre on administrative control over Delhi in as many days
By Satya Prakash | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JUL 05, 2016 11:19 PM IST

Two judges have recused themselves from hearing the AAP government’s petition against the Centre on administrative control over Delhi in as many days.

A day after Justice JS Khehar distanced himself from the case; Justice L Nageshwar Rao recused himself on Tuesday.

But no one knows why.

In recent times, there has been a spike in the number of cases judges refusing to hear for unknown reasons.

In March alone, three judges of the Supreme Court opted out of cases without disclosing the reasons for their recusal. In some of these cases, the judges had heard the matters for several months.

On March 10, Justice V Gopala Gowda recused himself from hearing the CBI’s challenge to the 2010 Allahabad High Court verdict dropping criminal conspiracy charges against BJP leaders, including LK Advani and others in the Babri Masjid demolition case.

In February, he had himself given this date to hear the matter.

This had happened two days after Justice J Chelameswar opted out of the case pertaining to Bangalore blast accused Abdul Nazir Maudany. In the open court, the judge – who had heard the matter for almost two years -- simply adjourned the matter but the written order said it would be listed before another bench.

In recent years, there have been many instances from high courts where judges referred the cases to the chief justice for sending them to another bench, mostly without disclosing the reasons for their recusal.

Should judges disclose the reasons for recusal? Do citizens have a right to know why a particular judge has opted out of a case?

Read: SC defers AAP versus Centre petition over Delhi govt’s powers to Friday

Justice Kurian Joseph answered it in the affirmative. “Being an institution whose hallmark is transparency, it is only proper that the judge discharging high and noble duties, at least broadly indicate the reasons for recusing from the case… it is the constitutional duty, as reflected in one’s oath, to be transparent and accountable, and hence, a judge is required to indicate reasons for his recusal from a particular case,” Justice Joseph said in his verdict on National Judicial Appointments Commission.

“Reasons for recusal must be assigned whether they are personal or public,” says senior advocate Rajiv Dhavan.

“In a large number of cases, judges recuse themselves because either they have dealt with it as a judge or as an advocate. The reasons are often explicit without being put to writing. The conflict is recognised by the judge and the lawyer in the case. But in all other cases they must disclose the reasons,” says Dhavan.

“People have a right to know why judges recuse themselves from cases. The need for people to know increases when judges – one after the other offer recusal, especially in matters of public and constitutional significance.”

Instances of recusal of SC judges

July 4, 2016: Justice JS Khehar recuses from hearing AAP govt petition against Centre on administrative control over Delhi.

July 5, 2016: Another judge, Justice L Nagesjwar Rao, says he does not want to hear AAP government’s petition on same subject.

March 8, 2016: Justice J Chelameswar recuses from a case on Bangalore blasts accused Abdul Nazir Maudany.

March 9, 2016: Justice AR Dave’s bench says it is unable to hear activist Teesta Setalvad’s anticipatory bail plea and referred it to CJI for listing it before another bench.

March 10, 2016: Justice VG Gowda recuses from hearing CBI’s plea challenging May 2010 Allahabad HC verdict dropping criminal conspiracy charge against BJP leaders LK Advani and others in Babri case.

April 28, 2011: Bench of justices DK Jain and HL Dattu recuses from hearing then Sikkim HC Chief Justice PD Dinakaran’s petition seeking a stay on Rajya Sabha-appointed inquiry panel against him.

March 2, 2012: Bench of Justices HL Dattu and CK Prasad choses not to hear a petition challenging validity of the USD 8.5 million Cairn Energy-Vedanta deal.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Bhardwaj said that the DDA owes close to <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>535 crore to the south corporation.(ANI)
Bhardwaj said that the DDA owes close to 535 crore to the south corporation.(ANI)

AAP says DDA owes civic bodies 2,000 cr; BJP says pursuing matter with Centre

UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 02:04 AM IST
AAP’s chief spokesperson Saurabh Bhardwaj questioned the BJP as to why the corporations had not initiated the process to get the funds back from the DDA.
Close
Bharti said he believes in the judiciary and would file an appeal against the judgment in the higher court.(ANI Photo )
Bharti said he believes in the judiciary and would file an appeal against the judgment in the higher court.(ANI Photo )

AAP MLA Somnath Bharti gets two years in jail for attack on AIIMS staff

By Richa banka
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 01:57 AM IST
Additional chief metropolitan magistrate Ravindra Kumar Pandey also imposed a fine of 1 lakh on Bharti, the MLA from Malviya Nagar. The judge, however, granted Bharti bail to enable him to file an appeal before the high court against the conviction and jail term.
Close
On January 22, the Kotwali police learnt about the body in the mortuary and showed it to the missing woman’s parents, who identified it as that of their daughter.(HT Archives. Representative image)
On January 22, the Kotwali police learnt about the body in the mortuary and showed it to the missing woman’s parents, who identified it as that of their daughter.(HT Archives. Representative image)

25-year-old woman kidnapped by two men in a car, strangled to death

By karn pratap singh
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 01:48 AM IST
On Saturday, the police claimed to have solved the kidnapping and murder case after arresting the two suspects and recovering the Santro car in which the murder allegedly took place.
Close
Farmers raise slogans during an ongoing protest against the new farm laws, at the Singhu border in New Delhi.
Farmers raise slogans during an ongoing protest against the new farm laws, at the Singhu border in New Delhi.

Sonepat cops’ clean chit to man held by farmers at Singhu border

By HT Correspondent, Rohtak
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 01:30 AM IST
Addressing a press conference on Saturday, Sonepat superintendent of police Jashandeep Randhawa said the force had formed a three-member team of senior officials to investigate the matter.
Close
On Saturday, three districts reported over 100% coverage for centres giving Serum Institute of India’s Covishield – Shahdara, South, and North-East Delhi.(HT Photo)
On Saturday, three districts reported over 100% coverage for centres giving Serum Institute of India’s Covishield – Shahdara, South, and North-East Delhi.(HT Photo)

Covid-19: Highest 1-day turnout in Delhi as 86% beneficiaries get jabs

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 12:55 AM IST
The jump of 17 percentage points when compared to Thursday’s vaccination number was largely due to the government’s Co-WIN platform being tweaked to allow out-of-turn jabs for registered beneficiaries.
Close
Police teams will escort the tractors on the day of the rally to maintain law and order.(Reuters file photo)
Police teams will escort the tractors on the day of the rally to maintain law and order.(Reuters file photo)

Police give ‘in principle’ nod for Republic Day tractor rally in Delhi

By Fareeha Iftikhar, karn pratap singh
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 12:46 AM IST
According to farmer leaders, police have allowed them to enter the national capital from five different routes that will be decided by the Sanyukt Kisan Morcha — a group of several farmer organisations protesting against the three new farm laws across the country— by Sunday.
Close
HT Image
HT Image

AAP MLA Somnath Bharti disqualified after court sentences him to two years in jail in 2016 assault case

By Richa Banka, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:49 PM IST
Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) MLA Somnath Bharti stood disqualified on Saturday after a city court sentenced him to two years’ imprisonment in a 2016 case for assaulting All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) security staff and destroying public property
Close
HT Image
HT Image

Varsities have crucial role to play in generating employment, post-Covid, says Sisodia

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:45 PM IST
Delhi education minister Manish Sisodia on Saturday said the Covid-19 pandemic has led to massive unemployment across the world and universities will now play a crucial role in fighting the situation
Close
HT Image
HT Image

Police give ‘in principle’ nod for tractor rally in Delhi

By Fareeha Iftikhar and Karn Pratap Singh, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:44 PM IST
Delhi Police on Saturday gave an ‘in principle’ nod to farmers protesting at Delhi’s borders to carry out their proposed “tractor march” on Republic Day, covering a distance of around 100km within the national capital
Close
HT Image
HT Image

25-year-old woman kidnapped by two men in a car, strangled to death

By Karn Pratap Singh, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 11:41 PM IST
A 25-year-old woman, who worked as an accountant at a medicine wholesale shop in Chandni Chowk, was abducted in a car allegedly by two men -- one of them was a friend of hers -- and driven around the city for nearly four hours before being strangled to death and her body dumped at an isolated spot in outer Delhi’s Alipur area on January 19, police said
Close
On Monday, the city had recorded 161 cases, the lowest in nearly nine months, with a positivity rate of 0.32 per cent.(HT PHOTO.)
On Monday, the city had recorded 161 cases, the lowest in nearly nine months, with a positivity rate of 0.32 per cent.(HT PHOTO.)

Delhi records 197 fresh coronavirus cases; positivity rate dips to 0.26 per cent

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 06:20 PM IST
From January 15-22, the daily figures stood at 295; 299; 246; 161; 231; 228; 227 and 266 respectively.
Close
AAP MLA Somnath Bharti leaves after attending the Delhi Assembly monsoon session in New Delhi.(Sonu Mehta/HT Photo)
AAP MLA Somnath Bharti leaves after attending the Delhi Assembly monsoon session in New Delhi.(Sonu Mehta/HT Photo)

Injustice with Somnath Bharti in AIIMS security staff assault case: AAP

By hindustantimes.com | Written by Susmita Pakrasi, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 04:53 PM IST
  • Earlier in the day, a Delhi court sentenced Bharti to two years in jail in a case registered in 2016.
Close
Trudeau was the first world leader to comment on the farmers’ protest, telling a Facebook video interaction on Tuesday that the situation in India was “concerning”.(PTI)
Trudeau was the first world leader to comment on the farmers’ protest, telling a Facebook video interaction on Tuesday that the situation in India was “concerning”.(PTI)

As farmers' protest continues, Delhi Police bolster border security

By HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 02:36 PM IST
The farmers alleged that the Haryana police have planted some men among the protesters to fuel violence at the protest site.
Close
The minimum temperature rose to eight degrees Celsius as a result of easterly winds and a cloud cover over the national capital, an IMD official said.(Raj K Raj / HT Photo)
The minimum temperature rose to eight degrees Celsius as a result of easterly winds and a cloud cover over the national capital, an IMD official said.(Raj K Raj / HT Photo)

Delhi's minimum temperature rises to 8 degree Celsius

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 10:31 AM IST
A fresh Western Disturbance (WD) affecting the western Himalayas provided some relief from the chill.
Close
An authority notice said no non-scheduled flight will be allowed to operate from 10am-1pm from January 20 to 26.(Vipin Kumar/HT PHOTO)
An authority notice said no non-scheduled flight will be allowed to operate from 10am-1pm from January 20 to 26.(Vipin Kumar/HT PHOTO)

No flights to, from Delhi airport from 10am-12.15pm till January 26

PUBLISHED ON JAN 23, 2021 07:34 AM IST
However, the restriction will not be applicable to the movements of the Indian Air Force, the Border Security Force, the Indian Army or helicopters, the notice said.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP