Central Bureau of Investigation Chief Alok Verma at Supreme Court in New Delhi on July 30.(PTI Photo)
Central Bureau of Investigation Chief Alok Verma at Supreme Court in New Delhi on July 30.(PTI Photo)

Alok Verma wins CBI vs CBI as SC overrules Centre, reinstated as agency chief

The top court said it intends to maintain the independence of CBI, and protect and insulate the office of the CBI director.
By HT Correspondent | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 09, 2019 12:03 AM IST

In a setback to the ruling National Democratic Alliance (NDA), the Supreme Court on Tuesday reinstated Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) director Alok Verma, overturning the government’s October 23 order divesting him of his powers and sending him on leave.

The top court said it intends to maintain the independence of CBI, and protect and insulate the office of the CBI director.

The court, however, barred Verma from taking any significant decision until a panel that selects the agency’s chief decides whether he should stay on.

Union finance minister Arun Jaitley, a lawyer by profession, while defending the government’s move called the court’s ruling “a balanced decision” that upheld the independence and dignity of CBI. The Congress said in a Twitter post that it welcomed the verdict “lambasting the government against their illegal removal of Alok Verma as CBI director,” linking his ouster to a probe he planned into the deal to purchase Rafale warplanes from Dassault Aviation of France.

Read more| ‘Balanced decision’, says Jaitley on SC reinstating Alok Verma as CBI boss

A bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Ranjan Gogoi and justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul and KM Joseph gave the selection committee headed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, which also comprises the CJI and the Leader of the largest opposition party in the Lok Sabha, a week’s time to study the report of a probe against Verma and decide on his continuation.

“The transfer of the director without the consent of the selection committee negates the legislative intent that is to ensure independence of CBI,” said the judgment, which was read out by justice Kaul as CJI Gogoi, who authored the order, was on leave.

 Watch: Politicos react over SC’s verdict on Alok Verma restored as CBI director

--

“Within a week, the selection committee, led by the PM, will meet and look into the aspect of whether Verma needs to be removed or not,” said the bench, which had on December 6 reserved its judgment after hearing arguments on behalf of Verma, the Centre and the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC), which has administrative superintendance over CBI and conducted the probe against Verma. The other two members of the panel are the CJI and the leader of the largest opposition party in the Lok Sabha.

The Centre acted in October after a feud played out in public between Verma, whose two-year tenure ends on January 31, and his deputy, special director Rakesh Asthana, who accused each other of corruption. On the midnight of October 23, it divested both officers of their powers and sent them on leave.

Verma, who approached the apex court against the government’s move, was on Tuesday asked by the bench led by Gogoi to “cease and desist” from taking any major policy decision unless the selection panel decides on his continuation or otherwise.

“Only administrative decisions can be taken as in day-to-day working,” the court said.

The Centre told the apex court that it had been forced to intervene because of the rift between Verma and Asthana, against whom a CBI team had launched a criminal investigation. After sending both on leave, the government, in an interim measure, appointed CBI’s joint director M Nageswara Rao, a 1986 batch Odisha-cadre Indian Police Service officer, as the agency’s temporary chief.

With Rao’s approval, orders were issued to transfer and reassign 13 officials, including those who were probing the case against Asthana.

Read more| ‘Some justice done’, says Rahul Gandhi as SC reinstates Alok Verma as CBI chief

Verma had contended that the move to send him on leave amounted to removing, which he argued cannot be done without the concurrence of the high-powered committee that approves the CBI director’s appointment.

The court also heard a plea moved by NGO Common Cause, which sought a court-monitored special investigation team (SIT) probe into the allegations of corruption against various CBI officers, including Asthana. Asthana has moved the Delhi high court requesting it to quash the first information report (FIR) registered against him by the agency for allegedly accepting gratification. The high court has reserved its order.

Challenging the government’s decision, Verma’s counsel and senior advocate Fali S Nariman argued that the CBI director was appointed on February 1, 2017, and “the position of law is that there will be a fixed tenure of two years and this gentleman cannot be even transferred”. He argued there was no basis for the CVC to pass an order recommending that Verma be sent on leave.

Attorney general KK Venugopal justified the Centre’s intervention and said it was well within “its right” to send both officers on leave. “Only God knows where and how this fight between the two top officers would have ended” if the government would not have taken the action which was aimed at restoring public faith in CBI, the law officer had argued.

Finance minister Jaitley said: “The government’s action was perfectly bonafide as there were cross allegations made by both the officers and in accordance with the recommendations of the CVC. The government had felt that in the larger interest of fair and impartial investigation and credibility of CBI, the two officers must recuse themselves.”

“The Supreme Court has upheld CBI’s dignity, honour and independence. The CBI legislation says that in matters related to corruption, the CVC has jurisdiction,” he said. “The CVC had exercised its power under the power of superintendence... If superintendence results in the chief relinquishing his powers temporarily then the jurisdiction of the committee comes into play. Therefore, the court has referred the matter to that committee to decide on that issue within one week. And in accordance with the directions of the court, it will be complied with and the government will act in the same manner. The government is not biased,” Jaitley said.

“CBI chief was removed at 1am in the night because he was about to begin an investigation in the Rafale scam. Now that he has been reinstated, some justice has been done. Now let’s see what happens,” Congress president Rahul Gandhi alleged. He was referring to the government’s R59,000-crore purchase of French-made Rafale jet fighters in which the Congress has alleged corruption.

Party leader in the Lok Sabha Kharge also welcomed the Supreme Court order saying it was a “lesson for the government”. Kharge has separately petitioned the Supreme Court against the midnight order removing Asthana, saying that he, being a member of the selection panel that appoints a CBI chief, be heard before any order is passed.

Delhi chief minister and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) chief Arvind Kejriwal tweeted, “SC reinstating CBI director Alok Verma is a direct indictment of the PM. Modi govt has ruined all institutions and democracy in our country. Wasn’t CBI director illegally removed at midnight to stall the probe in Rafale scam which directly leads to PM himself?”

The government has repeatedly denied Congress’s allegations of wrongdoing and corruption in the Rafale deal.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
In this file photo, Indian army trucks drive near Pangong Tso lake near the India China border in Ladakh area. (AP)
In this file photo, Indian army trucks drive near Pangong Tso lake near the India China border in Ladakh area. (AP)

India, China hold another round of military talks to defuse LAC tensions

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 25, 2021 12:07 AM IST
  • The situation in the Ladakh sector remains tense and the ongoing military and diplomatic dialogue has not yielded results.
Close
A woman walks past a painting of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi a day before the inauguration of the Covid-19 vaccination drive on a street in Mumbai, India, January 15, 2021. (REUTERS)
A woman walks past a painting of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi a day before the inauguration of the Covid-19 vaccination drive on a street in Mumbai, India, January 15, 2021. (REUTERS)

Covid-19 vaccination: Over 16 lakh inoculated in 9 days, Karnataka leads the way

Written by Arpan Rai, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 11:07 PM IST
The government data also said that only 10 Adverse Events Following Immunization (AEFIs) have been reported till 7.30 pm on Sunday.
Close
Villagers said the district administration broke the lock of the main gate of Government Primary School and shifted the cows. (Representational image/HT Photo)
Villagers said the district administration broke the lock of the main gate of Government Primary School and shifted the cows. (Representational image/HT Photo)

In Tikamgarh district of MP, primary school converted into cow shelter

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 11:01 PM IST
  • A school teacher said more than 200 cows destroyed the kitchen garden and at least 100 plants of flowers, fruits and medicinal plant in the school premises.
Close
Rahat Abrar said that the historic ceremony would be carried out by Vice Chancellor Professor Tariq Mansoor.(HT File Photo)
Rahat Abrar said that the historic ceremony would be carried out by Vice Chancellor Professor Tariq Mansoor.(HT File Photo)

Time capsule to be buried on Republic Day to mark 100 years of AMU

PTI, Aligarh
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:59 PM IST
AMU spokesman Rahat Abrar said that "The steel capsule which weighs 1.5 tonne would be buried at a depth of 30 feet in front of Victoria Gate, the iconic structure, which marks the heart of this historic institution."
Close
The rally will be held from Delhi's three border points -- Singhu, Tikri and Ghazipur -- and adequate security will be provided to it, police said.(REUTERS)
The rally will be held from Delhi's three border points -- Singhu, Tikri and Ghazipur -- and adequate security will be provided to it, police said.(REUTERS)

Delhi Police Commissioner issues circular for tractor rally

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:57 PM IST
  • The circular said that all officers and personnel as well as CAPF and any other force deployed for the Republic Day Parade security arrangements should be made aware and be prepared that they will be required for law and order arrangements immediately after the official celebration is over.
Close
The police said no traffic will be allowed on Vijay Chowk from 6.00 pm on January 25 till the parade is over, wheras Rajpath is already out of bounds.(ANI)
The police said no traffic will be allowed on Vijay Chowk from 6.00 pm on January 25 till the parade is over, wheras Rajpath is already out of bounds.(ANI)

Delhi Traffic Police issues advisory for road movement ahead of Republic Day

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:49 PM IST
  • Delhi traffic police requested road users to accordingly plan their journies and avoid the route of parade and tableaux, from 4 am to 12:30 pm for their own convenience.
Close
“I am thinking of Netaji, I am thinking of my countrymen” said the Prime Minister.
“I am thinking of Netaji, I am thinking of my countrymen” said the Prime Minister.

‘Thank you West Bengal’ tweets PM Modi as he shares video of his Kolkata visit

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Ayshee Bhaduri, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:52 PM IST
The video includes pictures and videos of the Prime Minister’s at Victoria Memorial to mark the occasion of ParakramDivas, Shubhash Chandra Bose’s residence amongst others, with sound bites from his speech at the former added for effect.
Close
Union minister Smriti Irani, S Jaishankar shared photos with their daughters on the occasion of national Girl Child Day.
Union minister Smriti Irani, S Jaishankar shared photos with their daughters on the occasion of national Girl Child Day.

Gird Child Day: Leaders, eminent personalities laud contribution of daughters

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:32 PM IST
India celebrates National Girl Child Day, an initiative of the ministry of women and child development, every year on January 24.
Close
The tiger skin that was seizied by the Chhattisgarh police on Sunday in Dhamtari district.(Sourced)
The tiger skin that was seizied by the Chhattisgarh police on Sunday in Dhamtari district.(Sourced)

Chhattisgarh police arrest man trying to sell tiger skin

PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:07 PM IST
  • According to the FIR registered by the police, the estimated value of the tiger skin that was seized is 40 lakh in the international market.
Close
File photo of Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar.(HT Photo)
File photo of Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar.(HT Photo)

Nitish Kumar wishes speedy recovery to Lalu, but won't call. Here's why

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Amit Chaturvedi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 10:04 PM IST
Lalu Prasad Yadav was airlifted to Delhi from Ranchi where he is being treated for multiple ailments.
Close
According to officials, this is one of the biggest GST frauds detected in recent times(Representational photo)
According to officials, this is one of the biggest GST frauds detected in recent times(Representational photo)

Eight CAs among 258 arrested since mid-November in GST fraud

By Rajeev Jayaswal
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 09:52 PM IST
  • One CA was arrested on Saturday along with four businessmen in Jaipur for operating 25 fake firms to fraudulently avail and pass on input tax credit.
Close
While addressing a press conference here, Congress General Secretary Ajay Maken alleged that excise duty on diesel has been hiked by 820 per cent and 258 per cent on petrol in the last six years.(ANI)
While addressing a press conference here, Congress General Secretary Ajay Maken alleged that excise duty on diesel has been hiked by 820 per cent and 258 per cent on petrol in the last six years.(ANI)

Congress slams Center over petrol, diesel price hike

ANI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 09:50 PM IST
  • While addressing a press conference, Congress General Secretary Ajay Maken demanded an explanation of how exactly has the government spent 20 lakh crore that it "collected by multiple hikes in excise duty on both petrol and diesel" in last six years.
Close
A child wearing a blanket walks through an alley of a residential area on a cold winter day in New Delhi on January 24, 2021. (Photo by Sajjad HUSSAIN / AFP)(AFP)
A child wearing a blanket walks through an alley of a residential area on a cold winter day in New Delhi on January 24, 2021. (Photo by Sajjad HUSSAIN / AFP)(AFP)

Fresh grip of chill in north, central India over next 3-4 days: IMD

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 09:27 PM IST
This fresh spell of chill has been caused by the movement of the western disturbance further northeastwards on Sunday from Jammu and Kashmir.
Close
The gold was kept in safes and vaults of the Surana Corporation under the CBI’s lock and seal. (HT Photo)
The gold was kept in safes and vaults of the Surana Corporation under the CBI’s lock and seal. (HT Photo)

Gold worth Rs4.50 crore seized at Chennai airport, 9 held

PTI, Chennai
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 09:19 PM IST
Acting on inputs that 17 passengers, including four women passengers, who had arrived from Dubai on Friday, were involved in gold-smuggling, the Customs sleuths intercepted them on suspicion and recovered the precious metal.
Close
Roji Behera (second from right) says she wants to work till she saves enough to pay off her college dues.(HT PHOTO)
Roji Behera (second from right) says she wants to work till she saves enough to pay off her college dues.(HT PHOTO)

Odisha Dalit girl works as labourer to clear pending dues of engineering college

By Debabrata Mohanty
PUBLISHED ON JAN 24, 2021 09:17 PM IST
  • The girl claims that the college has withheld her diploma certificate for non-payment of dues.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP