Sign in

Supreme Court stresses balancing privacy rights with press freedom in data protection act

The plea argues that the data protection framework fails to distinguish journalism in public interest from other forms of processing personal data.

Updated on: Oct 28, 2026, 07:48:02 IST
Share
Share via
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
Copy link
  • copy link

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stressed the need to strike a balance between citizens’ right to privacy and the media’s freedom to investigate and report, as it issued notice on a petition by the Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA) challenging provisions of the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, and the rules framed under it in 2025.

The Supreme Court will hear the matter on November 17.
The Supreme Court will hear the matter on November 17.

‘A balance has to be struck’

A bench, comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, also issued notice on the association’s interim prayer for a stay on the operation of the challenged provisions. The court will hear the matter on November 17.

“You are the best person to suggest to the Union and us how you will ensure there is no misuse,” the bench told senior advocate Madhavi Divan, appearing for the DNPA, as the bench underlined that the privacy rights of ordinary citizens would have to be protected alongside the media’s constitutional freedoms.

“There will be rights of innocent citizens and then there is your right. A balance has to be struck,” CJI Kant said.

Divan told the bench that the petition was the first comprehensive challenge by what she described as “legacy media”, representing conventional news publishers. She argued that the law could fundamentally alter the way journalism is practised by requiring news organisations to obtain consent before collecting or processing personal information for reporting.

“News has to be new…what is the point if I have to ask for permission and consent?” she asked, warning that the framework could effectively introduce pre-censorship and leave newsrooms unable to pursue stories involving public officials and government offices.

“Newsrooms will shut down…regime of pre-censorship…what’s news otherwise?” said Divan, adding that publishers were already subject to regulatory mechanisms, including the Press Council of India.

If a report was inaccurate, she said, the publisher should face the consequences rather than be required to obtain prior permission before publication.

The bench reiterated that the competing rights would have to be reconciled. When Divan asked how journalists could report under the proposed framework, the court suggested the association might also explain how it would ensure that reporting did not infringe the rights of individuals.

Removal of public interest disclosure

The plea is important because it challenges not merely the general framework to protect digital personal data, but also the absence of a specific exemption for journalistic work. The DNPA represents 21 news publishers, including media firms associated with the Adani and Ambani groups, as well as several prominent newspaper and television networks. HT is also part of the DNPA.

At the heart of the challenge is Section 44(3) of the DPDP Act, which amended Section 8(1)(j) of the Right to Information Act, 2005. The association contends that the amendment removes the earlier public-interest disclosure safeguard for personal information and could restrict access to records relevant to public accountability.

Also Read I Claude’s unauthorised access to US voter data raises concerns

The plea argues that the data protection framework fails to distinguish journalism in public interest from other forms of processing personal data.

Without such a distinction, reporters could face demands for consent, withdrawal of consent and erasure of personal information even when the information is relevant to investigations into corruption, corporate wrongdoing or misconduct by public officials, it contends.

  • Utkarsh Anand
    ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    Utkarsh Anand

    Utkarsh Anand is the National Legal Editor at Hindustan Times, where he leads the newspaper's coverage of the Supreme Court, constitutional law, the judiciary and the Union law ministry. He joined Hindustan Times in 2020 after stints at Press Trust of India (PTI), The Indian Express and CNN-News18, and has over two decades of experience reporting on law, governance and public policy. His work has focussed on some of India's most consequential constitutional and legal developments, including the Supreme Court's judgments on Article 370, marriage equality, decriminalisation of homosexuality, the Babri Masjid dispute, electoral reforms and judicial appointments. He specialises in making complex legal proceedings and judgments accessible to readers while examining their wider social and political impact. Beyond daily reportage, Utkarsh has led investigative projects and enterprise reporting that have shaped public debate and prompted institutional responses. His work has received several journalism awards, including the Ramnath Goenka Excellence in Journalism Award. As National Legal Editor, he has also played a key role in expanding Hindustan Times' legal journalism footprint, mentoring reporters and strengthening coverage across platforms. A Chevening South Asia Journalism Programme Fellow, Utkarsh regularly writes analyses on the judiciary and constitutional issues, and his reporting is widely followed by lawyers, judges, policymakers, academics and readers seeking clarity on India's evolving legal landscape.Read More

Get Latest News, breaking headlines, and top India News, and today real-time updates from across the nation. Stay informed on politics, government policies, crime, Today Weather, and major developments on Hindustan Times