Indian attitudes toward African-Americans seem to be as much about how they perceive themselves on the colour bar as how they see African-Americans.(Illustration: Malay Karmakar)
Indian attitudes toward African-Americans seem to be as much about how they perceive themselves on the colour bar as how they see African-Americans.(Illustration: Malay Karmakar)

Let’s talk about racism | Why Indian Americans have a white skin fixation

Attitudes of Indians toward African-Americans seem to be as much about how they perceive themselves on colour bar
By Saeed Khan
UPDATED ON MAY 23, 2017 09:38 AM IST

The recent attacks against African students in India have touched off a national debate about a highly sensitive subject. The nation has received a considerable amount of negative media coverage criticising it as a racially intolerant country. This accusation is supported by the most recent round of reports published by the World Values Survey, an internationally reputable polling organisation, which found in 2013 that 43.5% of Indians would not want a neighbour of a different race, putting India second worldwide only to Jordan by that measure of racial intolerance.

While racism appears to be an issue in India, what about Indians around the world? Does the bigotry of immigrants travel with them as part of their cultural baggage, or is a new national ethos forged in the crucible of their adopted home? The Indian-American community offers some insights.

Indians in the United States are, arguably, the nation’s most successful immigrant group. According to the 2012 Pew Research Center report The Rise of Asian Americans, 70% of Indians aged 25 and over have college degrees, 2.5 times the national average. Their median household income, $88,000, is nearly double that of the average American. At 1% of the US population (3.1 million), Indians constitute 1% of the US Congress.

In America, unlike in Britain, the trappings of ‘whiteness’ are widely attainable. In an example of aspirational assimilation taken to a higher level of effort, there is the former South Carolina governor and current US Ambassador to the United Nations, Nikki Haley. Born Nimrata Nikki Randhawa, Haley marked “white” on her voter registration form in 2001.

While Haley may proactively pursue whiteness, conservative activist Dinesh D’Souza seeks to burnish his bona fides to the establishment through racism couched in political commentary. D’Souza took to Twitter on February 18, 2015 sniffing, “YOU CAN TAKE THE BOY OUT OF THE GHETTO…” in reference to a photograph of President Obama using a selfie stick in the Oval Office. In a 2010 article, he even excoriated Obama for excessive “anti-colonialism” derived from his Kenyan father. D’Souza’s bigoted criticism of the former president affirms the idea that some Indian Americans gravitate toward the white power structure for plaudits and profit.

As is the case in India, chromocracy prevails in the United States, where skin colour and socio-economic status are inextricably linked. In the 1991 movie, Mississippi Masala, a scene depicts a group of Indian ‘aunties’ at a wedding, musing over which of their daughters stands a chance to be married to the local highly eligible ‘alpha male’, Harry Patel: “You can be dark and have money, or you can be fair and have no money, but you can’t be dark and have no money and expect to get Harry Patel.” Keeping with the storyline of the movie, the town’s black population is clearly a bête noire for the Indian immigrant community, perceived as the antithesis of everything deemed desirable, successful, or even ‘American’.

Immigrant gravitation toward the dominant demographic group is hardly a new phenomenon in the United States. Sociologist Milton Gordon wrote how immigrants to America in the early 20th century assimilated by appropriating the majority white, Anglo-Saxon Protestant ethos. For Indian immigrants, much of this groundwork was established before ever reaching American shores due to British colonial rule. While notions of colour superiority existed in India well before the British East India Company ever set up shop in Calcutta, colonialism caused the Indian subjects to internalise the conceit that British were culturally superior; a correlation between such ‘greatness’ and skin colour was an easy inference for the population to draw even had the colonisers not inculcated it.

While some might think that being on the receiving end of racial marginalisation would have sensitised Indian immigrants to the experience of African Americans, the racial history of the United States is, in fact, markedly different from that of India. The United States still struggles to rectify the legacy both of slavery and of the institutionalised racism of the Jim Crow laws even two generations after the passage of the 1964 Civil Rights Act. This conflict is in large measure lost upon the Indian population, which has bought into the great American myth of the ‘pull yourself up by the bootstraps’ ethos for immigrant acceptance and success.

Many Indian Americans, for example, consider policies like affirmative action either an affront to meritocracy or a cumbersome holdover from the past. Groups such as the Indian American Forum for Political Education, the National Federation of Indian American Associations, and the Global Organization of People of Indian Origin signed a legal brief opposing race-conscious admissions in a Supreme Court case, Abigail Noel Fisher v. University of Texas, that challenged affirmative action in higher education.

Hate Crimes
Indians in the US have been singled out for racial attacks. Many such attacks have taken place since Trump won the Presidential poll
November 2016
Exactly two weeks after the presidential election, a middle-aged white man in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, told Indian resident, Ankur Mehta, that "things are different now ... I don’t want you sitting next to me, you people," and assaulted him. The man was later charged with a hate crime.
February 2017
Srinivas Kuchibhotla and Alok Madasani were shot at a bar in Olathe, Kansas, where they worked asengineers, by a middle-aged white man who asked them about their visas. Kuchibhotla was killed and Madasani was wounded. Police have arrested a suspect and the FBI is investigating the attack as a hate crime.
March 2017
  • Harnish Patel returned home from work at a convenience store in Lancaster, South Carolina, only to be shot and killed in his front yard.
  • Deep Rai, a Sikh US citizen born in Punjab and living in Kent, Washington, was approached outside his home by a masked white man who told him "go back to your country" and shot him in the arm.

Ironically, the Civil Rights Act has served as a legal support for affirmative action and the facilitator for removing immigration quotas from Asian countries, including India. Of course, some Indians have felt no moral conundrum in availing themselves of the very system they purportedly detest. Vijay Chokal-Ingam, brother of television star, Mindy Kaling, admitted that he lied about being black to gain admission, via affirmative action, to medical school.

“I know you and your folks can come down here from God knows where, and be as black as the ace of spaces, and as soon as you get here you start acting white, treating us like we’re your doormats. I know you and your daughter ain’t but a few shades away from this right here.”

With these words, spoken by Denzel Washington while pointing to his face and confronting the father of his Indian girlfriend, Hollywood’s Mississippi Masala tackled the issue of race relations between African Americans and Indians immigrants. Over 25 years after its release, the movie still resonates as a powerful depiction of how latent and overt forms of racism pervade segments of the Indian-American community.

It is difficult to ascertain whether Indian Americans who harbour racist sentiments do so because of attitudes they bring with them to America or whether they are adopting the prejudices of their new country upon arrival. The so-called Trump era has exposed, some might argue, routine habits of bigotry, releasing them from the country’s collective unconscious into broad daylight.

Whatever their cause, Indian attitudes toward African-Americans seem to be as much about how they perceive themselves on the colour bar as how they see African-Americans. Such prejudice is a form of self-denial.

(Saeed A Khan is lecturer of Near East & Asian Studies and Global Studies at Wayne State University, Detroit, USA. He tweets @saeedkhan1967)

This is the seventh part of Let’s Talk About Racism, a new HT campaign that addresses deep-rooted prejudices and discrimination in India. If you have faced racism, tweet using #LetsTalkAboutRacism or write to talktous@hindustantimes.com. HT’s earlier series, Let’sTalk About Rape and Let’s Talk About Trolls, focused attention on crucial issues.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
In some states, the price of petrol crossed <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>100 a litre due the current streak of rise in fuel prices.(Amal KS/ Hindustan Times)
In some states, the price of petrol crossed 100 a litre due the current streak of rise in fuel prices.(Amal KS/ Hindustan Times)

Nagaland cuts taxes on petrol and diesel, fuel prices come down

By Alice Yhoshü | Edited by Abhinav Sahay, Kohima
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:48 AM IST
  • Petrol and Diesel were being retailed at 90.41 and 83.99 in Kohima on Wednesday.
Close
Farmers congregate during the ongoing protest against the new farm laws at Ghazipur (Delhi-UP border) near Ghaziabad, India. (Sakib Ali /Hindustan Times)
Farmers congregate during the ongoing protest against the new farm laws at Ghazipur (Delhi-UP border) near Ghaziabad, India. (Sakib Ali /Hindustan Times)

Farm laws protests: Tikait to address rally at Todabhim

By hindustantimes.com, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:37 AM IST
  • Protests enter Day 90. Tikait says 40 lakh tractors will hit the streets.
Apart from Co-WIN 2.0, there will be other channels to register for vaccination starting from March 1. (PTI)
Apart from Co-WIN 2.0, there will be other channels to register for vaccination starting from March 1. (PTI)

Vaccination for senior citizens, and 45+ with co-morbidities: How to register

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Poulomi Ghosh
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:42 AM IST
A new version of the Co-WIN app will be launched soon where the option of self-registration will be there. Common service centres may also open windows to register people for 2nd phase vaccination.
Close
Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal addresses the Niti Aayog Governing Council Meeting, in New Delhi on Saturday. (ANI Photo)
Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal addresses the Niti Aayog Governing Council Meeting, in New Delhi on Saturday. (ANI Photo)

In video message, Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal thanks voters in Surat

By HT Correspondent, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:55 AM IST
“Gujarat has introduced a phase of new politics, which is politics of honesty, politics of work, politics of improved schools and hospitals, and politics of 24x7 free electricity,” said Kejriwal.
Close
The RSS worker was stabbed to death during the clashes with SDPI. Six others were also injured in Kerala's Alappuzha district. (HT Archive/For Representational Purposes Only)
The RSS worker was stabbed to death during the clashes with SDPI. Six others were also injured in Kerala's Alappuzha district. (HT Archive/For Representational Purposes Only)

RSS worker stabbed to death in Kerala during SDPI rally

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Shankhyaneel Sarkar, Hindustan Times, Thiruvananthapuram
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 07:54 AM IST
  • Police presence in Wayalar has been increased in the district in the wake of the violence.
Close
Leader of Opposition (LoP) in the Rajya Sabha, Mallikarjun Kharge. (Satish Bate/HT Photo)
Leader of Opposition (LoP) in the Rajya Sabha, Mallikarjun Kharge. (Satish Bate/HT Photo)

‘Differences will arise if laws are steamrolled’: Mallikarjun Kharge

By Vinod Sharma
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:52 AM IST
"The foremost requirement in the role I played was to be a strong Opposition voice on matters that impacted the people, especially the poor, the farmers, and the working class. They (the treasury benches) would insult us by pointing to our numerical weakness," Kharge said
Close
Under the 2019 law, a district forum can decide a consumer dispute up to <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>1 crore as against <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>20 lakh under the old law.
Under the 2019 law, a district forum can decide a consumer dispute up to 1 crore as against 20 lakh under the old law.

Citing poor infra, SC seeks legislative impact study on consumer law

By Utkarsh Anand, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:46 AM IST
A Supreme Court bench, headed by justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, directed the government to place the said study before the court to indicate if social, economic and institutional impacts were taken into account prior to replacing the 1986 consumer protection law with the 2019 law.
Close
Govt officials familiar with the matter cited attacks on security forces in the northeast and recovery of large amounts of arms and ammunition from several parts of Assam as a reason for the move.(AP file photo)
Govt officials familiar with the matter cited attacks on security forces in the northeast and recovery of large amounts of arms and ammunition from several parts of Assam as a reason for the move.(AP file photo)

Assam declared ‘disturbed area’ for six months

By Utpal Parashar, Guwahati
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:33 AM IST
The fresh order is an extension of a similar move on August 28 last year, when the state was declared a ‘Disturbed Area’ for six months. There is no official comment yet on the reason behind the extension.
Close
The bench of justices Ashok Bhushan and RS Reddy posted the matter to Tuesday.(HT file photo)
The bench of justices Ashok Bhushan and RS Reddy posted the matter to Tuesday.(HT file photo)

Punjab ‘shamelessly’ backing Mukhtar Ansari: UP govt in Supreme Court

By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:13 AM IST
When the apex court took up the petition by the UP government seeking Ansari’s transfer out of Punjab, an adjournment request was made by senior advocate Dushyant Dave appearing for the Punjab government.
Close
The young woman was found unconscious at her uncle’s residence on the outskirts of Hyderabad, police said.(HT Archives. Representative image)
The young woman was found unconscious at her uncle’s residence on the outskirts of Hyderabad, police said.(HT Archives. Representative image)

Hyderabad teen who made ‘false’ rape bid claim dies by suicide: Police

By Srinivasa Rao Apparasu, Hyderabad
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 05:56 AM IST
A case of suspicious death has been registered and an investigation is on. Family members told police that it was her second attempt to kill herself in the past 24 hours, according to a police official who did not want to be named.
Close
Outstanding problems with PLA at Depsang, Hot Springs and Gogra — friction points on the LAC — were discussed during the 10th round of talks between corps commander-ranked officers of the two sides on Feb 20.(AFP)
Outstanding problems with PLA at Depsang, Hot Springs and Gogra — friction points on the LAC — were discussed during the 10th round of talks between corps commander-ranked officers of the two sides on Feb 20.(AFP)

Long way to go for full LAC de-escalation: Army chief General Naravane

By Rahul Singh, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:28 AM IST
Naravane’s comments came four days after Indian and Chinese generals held talks in eastern Ladakh and agreed to resolve outstanding issues at friction points on the LAC in a “steady and orderly” manner and were unanimous that last week’s Pangong Tso disengagement provided “a good basis” for resolving pending problems.
Close
The court did not see merit in the grounds on which the candidates were seeking an extra chance, and was also worried about this setting the wrong kind of precedent.(HT file photo)
The court did not see merit in the grounds on which the candidates were seeking an extra chance, and was also worried about this setting the wrong kind of precedent.(HT file photo)

No extra chance for taking UPSC exam: Supreme Court

By Abraham Thomas
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 05:43 AM IST
In a February 5 hearing, the government offered candidates who have exhausted their chances an extra one, as a concession, but the court advised it against this, although it said the government is free to exercise its discretion in addressing the grievances of the petitioners.
Close
CRPF personnel being vaccinated against Covid-19, at Hindu Rao Hospital in New Delhi. (Sanchit Khanna/HT Photo)
CRPF personnel being vaccinated against Covid-19, at Hindu Rao Hospital in New Delhi. (Sanchit Khanna/HT Photo)

Paid shots from March 1 as India expands Covid-19 vaccine drive

By Rhythma Kaul, Anonna Dutt, Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON FEB 25, 2021 06:20 AM IST
The decision marks a significant opening up of the vaccination drive, with the roll-out for the general public being moved up from the previously estimated window of mid-March, and comes at a time when the country is on the brink of a second wave of infections.
Close
Digital media includes intermediaries such as Twitter and Facebook, and publishers of news and current affairs content. It also includes so-called curators of such content.(Reuters file photo)
Digital media includes intermediaries such as Twitter and Facebook, and publishers of news and current affairs content. It also includes so-called curators of such content.(Reuters file photo)

Govt rules for online media to include takedown power

By Deeksha Bhardwaj
PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 05:05 AM IST
Digital media, as defined in a document that lays out the government’s framework to regulate online content, will cover digitised content that can be transmitted over the internet or computer networks.
Close
Referring to the 2019 decision to scrap the special status of J&amp;K, Pujani said: “We reiterate that the entire union territories of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh are an integral and inalienable part of India."(AP file photo)
Referring to the 2019 decision to scrap the special status of J&K, Pujani said: “We reiterate that the entire union territories of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh are an integral and inalienable part of India."(AP file photo)

‘Patron of terror’: India hits out at Pakistan at United Nations

PUBLISHED ON FEB 25, 2021 04:48 AM IST
India’s “right of reply” to the Pakistani minister’s speech was delivered by Seema Pujani, second secretary in the permanent mission to the UN. She described Pakistan’s continued misuse of various platforms for “baseless and malicious propaganda against India is not new”.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP