Accidental CM with no sense of history | Opinion

Devendra Fadnavis needs to take some contemporary history lessons before dictating terms to the best home minister Maharashtra has ever had
Former CM Devendra Fadnavis(Satish Bate/HT Photo)
Former CM Devendra Fadnavis(Satish Bate/HT Photo)
Updated on Dec 25, 2019 11:05 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By

Of late, former chief minister Devendra Fadnavis has been flailing out against chief minister Uddhav Thackeray and NCP president Sharad Pawar so often that it led one senior Marathi journalist to describe, on Twitter, his cribbing as “kulle aaptane” – when a child, denied a toy, sits on the floor and jumps on his bottom in the same place again and again with loud cries of protest.

Others recalled Vilasrao Deshmukh who lost office not once, but twice for no valid reason but the whims of the party leadership. Yet he accepted his fate with dignity after having, unexpectedly like Fadnavis, become the chief minister simply for being in the right place at the right time. Even Manohar Joshi, of the Shiv Sena, accepted his sudden loss of office with the same dignity. The only other person who could not was Narayan Rane, who bullied his party supremo Bal Thackeray into replacing Joshi with him in that office and then, like Fadnavis, was unable to win a majority at the subsequent election. But even he was not as petulant as Fadnavis while blaming everybody, but himself for his circumstances. Now, however, for the accidental chief minister that Fadnavis really was, he seems to have so much wisdom for not just Thackeray but also Pawar who has been among the most able, deserving and accomplished chief ministers of Maharashtra.

Pawar was the state’s home minister before Fadnavis was born and had handled a crisis far worse than the Bhima-Koreagaon aftermath with far more skill and compassion than Fadnavis has shown even to trees in the Aarey forests which were cut down with such ruthlessness as has been rarely seen in recent times. Last week, Pawar issued a call to the Pune police to revisit their investigation of the Elgar Parishad by Dalit activists and sympathisers and make a course correction in the injustice that may have been perpetrated on those who have been unfairly and arbitrarily incarcerated in the case. Fadnavis responded by “advising” Pawar not to demoralise the police but, having no sense of history, he might not know that Pawar, as the minister for home, had withdrawn many cases of sedition and treason against Dalit activists in the early 1970s simply on compassionate grounds, understanding the reason why they had been burning the national tricolour and copies of the Indian Constitution. Several years after Independence, Dalit groups found they still had no basic rights – upper castes in the villages had been grabbing their lands or turning them into slave labour, they were still discriminated against and despite reservations, they were unable to take their place as equals in society. But burning the tricolour and Constitution was an act not to be countenanced and, with far less reason than the Fadnavis government had against the Bhima-Koregaon activists, the police had rightfully filed cases against them under the draconian British -era laws. There was no way the judiciary would let off these seditious activists and Niloufer Bhagwat, today a noted civil rights lawyer, was arguing one of the first cases in court for one such Dalit activist. Pawar had been barred from Dalit events despite being such a powerful home minister. When Bhagwat met him to explain why – the lack of compassion the government was showing towards Dalits who found they were being denied their rights despite constitutional guarantees – Pawar showed a rare understanding of the situation. “He came in with a face looking like a thunderstorm but as I explained to him that if the flag and the Constitution do not guarantee them their rights what choice do they have but to reject that flag and that Constitution, his face began to lighten and an understanding dawned in his eyes,” Bhagwat told me recently.

As the home minister, Pawar was within his rights to take corrective action and that is what he did – no more cases were filed against Dalit activists, but simultaneously police were also instructed to take stern action against those upper castes in villages and elsewhere who were using their wealth and political clout to circumvent the Constitution and harass the Dalits. All jailed activists were released and social unrest that could have destroyed the nation neatly avoided.

No policeman was demoralised by those reversals and it is unlikely any will be now for doing his duty by his uniform and the Constitution. Pawar was never good at self-hype, but Fadnavis needs to take some contemporary history lessons before dictating terms to the best home minister Maharashtra has ever had.


    I wonder if the Sena and the AIMIM know that Bal Thackeray was the first person ever in India to lose his voting rights and that to contest elections for hate speeches he had made during a 1987 byelection to Vile Parle.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • In 2003, Swiderski’s fiancee Pragnesh Desai allegedly gave a contract to three persons -- Patel, Altaf Gafoor Patel and Farooq Banarasi -- to strangulate her and dump her body near a hotel on the Kashimira highway. (HT PHOTO)

    Court remands Vipul Patel in 14-day judicial custody in 2003 model murder

    Thane: The Thane court has remanded Vipul Patel, who has been extradited from Prague for allegedly killing a US-based model in 2003, to 14 days of judicial custody on Saturday. Patel is one of the main accused in the murder of Leona Swiderski (33) in February 2003. Patel was extradited from Prague on Friday by a four-member team from Mira Bhayander Vasai Virar Commissionerate (MBVVC).

  • SpiceJet flight returns to Mumbai after noticing windshield crack. (REPRESENTATIVE PHOTO)

    SpiceJet plane, headed for UP, returns to Mumbai due to windshield crack

    A Mumbai-Gorakhpur SpiceJet plane on Saturday returned to base at the Chhatrapati Shivaji International Airport after a crack was observed on the windshield of the aircraft, according to an official statement. "On May 28,, SpiceJet Boeing 737 aircraft was scheduled to operate SG-385 (Mumbai-Gorakhpur). During cruise, windshield outer pane was observed to be cracked," SpiceJet spokesperson said in a statement. The pilot-in-command decided to return to Mumbai due to the crack, the spokesperson said.

  • NSS students of LU (Lucknow University) performing a street play to promote menstrual health and hygiene. (Sourced)

    World Menstrual Hygiene Day: LU exhorts girl students to break period taboos

    On the occasion of World Menstrual Hygiene Day, a team from University of Lucknow went to four colleges-- Rajkiya High School , Khandasara; Rajkiya High School, Saspan; Rajkiya High School, Dhari; Virangana Uda Devi Rajkiya Balika Inter College of Mall region and interacted with girl students in an attempt to break the taboo and stigma associated with menstrual cycle.

  • The portion of a wall at Nulkar wada located at Sadashiv peth collapsed due to an ongoing excavation work next to the old structure on Friday night. (HT PHOTO)

    Wall collapse at Pune’s Nulkar wada, no casualty reported

    Pune: The residents of Nulkar wada located at Sadashiv peth had a scare as the portion of a wall collapsed due to an ongoing excavation work next to the old structure. No casualty was reported as the wada was unoccupied when the incident happened on Friday night. Only kitchen items were damaged as the house was locked when the wall collapsed. Most of the occupants in the wada were civil services examination aspirants.

  • Samata Parishad ’s workers on Saturday removed the board of a BJP party leader’s relative which was placed on an arch in front of Mahatma Phule wada in Ganj peth. (Ravindra Joshi/HT PHOTO)

    Samata Parishad removes board on Mahatma Phule wada arch put up by BJP leader

    After the Salisbury Park garden naming issue, the Bharatiya Janata Party faces criticism for placing the board of a party leader's relative on an arch in front of Mahatma Phule wada (Mahatma Phule's residence). Samata Parishad 's workers removed the board on Saturday. The board carried picture of Laxmibai Narayan Harihar, relative of a former BJP corporator; names of BJP MP Girish Bapat, MLA Mukta Tilak and former mayor Murlidhar Mohol.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, May 28, 2022