Sun Yang of China(Getty Images)
Sun Yang of China(Getty Images)

WADA says Swiss court overturns swimmer Sun’s doping ban

At stake in a second CAS hearing would be Yang’s chance to compete at the pandemic-delayed 2020 Tokyo Olympics now set for July 2021. The Swiss court ruling appears to have swung on an objection by Sun’s lawyers to the chairman of the three-judge panel, former Italian foreign minister Franco Frattini.
By Press Trust of India | Lausanne
UPDATED ON DEC 24, 2020 09:24 AM IST

The World Anti-Doping Agency says a Swiss court has overturned an eight-year doping ban against Chinese swimmer Sun Yang and ordered the case back to the Court of Arbitration for Sport for a second time but with a different chairman of the judges.

In February, CAS found the three-time Olympic champion guilty of refusing to cooperate with sample collectors during a visit to his home in September 2018 that turned confrontational. WADA brought the case to the Court of Arbitration for Sport after world swimming governing body FINA had issued the now 29-year-old Yang with only a warning.

At stake in a second CAS hearing would be Yang’s chance to compete at the pandemic-delayed 2020 Tokyo Olympics now set for July 2021.

The Swiss court ruling appears to have swung on an objection by Sun’s lawyers to the chairman of the three-judge panel, former Italian foreign minister Franco Frattini.

On Wednesday, WADA said in a statement that it had been informed of a decision by the Swiss Federal Tribunal to uphold an application by Yang and to set aside the original February ruling.

“The Swiss Federal Tribunal’s decision upholds a challenge against the chair of the CAS Panel and makes no comment on the substance of this case,” WADA said in the statement.

“In the CAS award, WADA clearly prevailed on the substance of the case as it was able to show that there were a number of aspects of the original FINA decision that were incorrect under the World Anti-Doping Code . . . WADA will take steps to present its case robustly again when the matter returns to the CAS Panel, which will be chaired by a different president (chairman).

“At this stage, WADA has not received the tribunal’s full reasoned decision and therefore cannot comment further.” A clash between Frattini and Sun was one of the most dramatic moments in a 10-hour CAS hearing in Montreux, Switzerland in November 2019 that was a rare instance of a CAS process held in open court and live-streamed online. The hearing ended with Sun surprising his own legal team by waving his arms and calling another translator from the public seats to better articulate his closing statement.

“Who is this guy?” asked an incredulous Frattini. “It is not up to you to appear before the court. There are some rules.” Frattini has also upset Yang and his legal team for a series of past tweets, including one from April 23, 2019 that read: “Those horrible sadic chinese are the shame of mankind !! For how they torture animals they deserve the evil every day! And the chinese authorities tolerate and encourage.” Very few cases, at a rate of about one per year that includes around 400 arbitration and appeal processes, are successful at the Swiss tribunal.

It is even possible to overturn a CAS verdict in the federal court and still lose the re-trial. That happened to tennis player Guillermo Canas of Argentina in 2007.

Canas was initially banned for two years by the ATP Tour’s anti-doping tribunal, and saw that reduced to 15 months at CAS. When Canas went to federal court, Swiss judges ruled his right to be heard had been breached and sent back the case. A second CAS hearing also applied a 15-month ban.

The most vivid detail of the evidence submitted at the Yang’s November 2019 CAS hearing was a blood sample rendered useless for testing by a hammer blow.

The hearing was reminded of how a security guard instructed by Sun’s mother broke the casing around the vial to ensure the blood could not be used for anti-doping tests.

“The athlete failed to establish that he had a compelling justification to destroy his sample collection containers and forego the doping control when, in his opinion, the collection protocol was not in compliance,” the CAS panel of three judges agreed in an unanimous verdict announced in February.

Immediately, Sun said he planned to appeal to the Swiss Federal Tribunal, which is Switzerland’s highest court. That move proved to be successful this week, setting the scene for another CAS hearing ahead of the Tokyo Olympics and ensuring the case involving a controversial 2018 doping test continues into at least 2021.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close
(L-R) Boxers Pawan Goyat, Suman, Chandn ... ence at Press club, Delhi on Friday
(L-R) Boxers Pawan Goyat, Suman, Chandn ... ence at Press club, Delhi on Friday

Professional boxing to get a pro touch for the first time

PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 10:36 PM IST
  • ‘India Unleashed’, an event sanctioned by the Indian Boxing Commission (IBC), Goraya wants to rope in changes with USA styled boxing format and help ring in the changes for professional boxing in India.
Close
Six-time world champion MC Mary Kom (51kg)(PTI)
Six-time world champion MC Mary Kom (51kg)(PTI)

Simranjit, Jasmine in final; Mary Kom settles for bronze in Boxam International

PTI
UPDATED ON MAR 05, 2021 10:00 PM IST
The 37-year-old olympic-bound star lost in a split decision after an exhausting contest that was also messy in equal measure.
Close
Nikolai Snesarev(ANI)
Nikolai Snesarev(ANI)

Athletics coach Nikolai Snesarev found dead at NIS Patiala hostel room

By HT Correspondent | PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 05, 2021 09:19 PM IST
The body of the 72-year-old Snesarev, who returned to India after a gap of two years to be at the helm till the end of September, has been sent to a government hospital for post mortem.
Close
File photo of Rajeshwari Kumari
File photo of Rajeshwari Kumari

Indian women's trap team settles for silver in ISSF World Cup

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 04, 2021 10:40 PM IST
The Indian team engineered a fantastic comeback in the gold medal match on Thursday, coming back from 0-4 down to tie the final at 4-4. However, it could not hold on in the last series of 15-shot per team and had to be content with second best.
Close
India's Amit Panghal(AP)
India's Amit Panghal(AP)

Vikas, Manish in semis; Panghal bows out of Boxam International

PTI
UPDATED ON MAR 04, 2021 10:49 PM IST
The Olympic-bound Panghal, who is also an Asian Games and Asian Championships gold-medallist, went down in a split verdict to make a surprisingly early exit from the tournament.
Close
Sharath Kamal Achanta of India(Getty Images)
Sharath Kamal Achanta of India(Getty Images)

Sharath Kamal loses in pre-quarters, India's campaign over at WTT Contender Doha

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 04, 2021 08:49 PM IST
The World No. 32 Sharath, who was playing his first international tournament after a year's break due to the Covid-19 pandemic, couldn't gain momentum despite showing good resistance in the latter part of the match against the higher-ranked Yun-Ju.
Close
Rahul Chaudhari. (Rahul Chaudhari/Instagram)
Rahul Chaudhari. (Rahul Chaudhari/Instagram)

My sister-in-law was my biggest inspiration: Rahul Chaudhari

By hindustantimes.com, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 04, 2021 07:27 PM IST
  • With the advent of the Pro Kabaddi League in 2014, the indigenous sport has witnessed a major transition – from one that was closely followed in rural areas to a topic that was discussed over dinner in metro cities.
Close
FILE - A crane is used to lift a vehicle following a rollover accident involving golfer Tiger Woods(AP)
FILE - A crane is used to lift a vehicle following a rollover accident involving golfer Tiger Woods(AP)

Detectives look at SUV's 'black box' from Tiger Woods crash

PTI, Los Angeles
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 11:07 PM IST
The Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department said traffic investigators executed a search warrant Monday to retrieve the data from the device from the Genesis SUV that Woods was driving.
Close
MC Mary Kom: File photo(PTI)
MC Mary Kom: File photo(PTI)

Mary Kom enters semis of Spanish tourney; assured of medal

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 09:39 PM IST
The 37-year-old, who had not competed since her Tokyo qualification last year in Jordan, defeated Italian Giordana Sorrentino with a split verdict in the quarterfinal stage of the event.
Close
Achanta Sharath Kamal: File Photo(Agencies)
Achanta Sharath Kamal: File Photo(Agencies)

WTT Contender Doha: Sharath off to a flying start; Sathiyan bows out

PTI, Doha
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 09:32 PM IST
Sharath toiled hard before defeating Sirucek 17-15 9-11 11-6 8-11 11-9 in the first round.
Close
Manish Kaushik(Twitter)
Manish Kaushik(Twitter)

Manish Kaushik enters quarters of Spanish boxing tourney

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 05:28 PM IST
The world championship bronze-medallist defeated Spaniard Ammari Raddouane 5-0 on Tuesday night to make the last eight, where he will be up against Kazakhstan's Sufiullin Zakir -- a two-time Asian silver-winner.
Close
May Kom: File photo(HT Archive)
May Kom: File photo(HT Archive)

Mary Kom appointed as chairperson of AIBA champions and veterans committee

ANI, Lausanne
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 03:47 PM IST
Mary Kom thanked AIBA president and said she will give her best at the position.
Close
Sonam Malik(Twitter)
Sonam Malik(Twitter)

Freak injury forces Sonam to pull out of Rome event

PTI
PUBLISHED ON MAR 03, 2021 01:43 PM IST
Sonam, who had booked her seat in the Indian team in the 62kg after defeating Sakshi in the trials, got injured while training with the 2016 Olympic bronze medallist at the national camp in Lucknow, last week.
Close
Mercedes unveils new car for Lewis Hamilton(Lewis Hamilton / Twitter)
Mercedes unveils new car for Lewis Hamilton(Lewis Hamilton / Twitter)

Mercedes unveils car for Hamilton's record-breaking F1 bid

AP, Brackley, England
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 11:48 PM IST
The W12 car, presented Tuesday, retains the black introduced last year as part of the team's campaign against racism and discrimination and adds a touch of its more traditional silver.
Close
Bahrain runner Nelly Jepkosgei(World Athletics / Twitter)
Bahrain runner Nelly Jepkosgei(World Athletics / Twitter)

Bahrain runner Jepkosgei banned for faking car crash

AP, Monaco
PUBLISHED ON MAR 02, 2021 10:39 PM IST
The AIU ruling said Jepkosgei admitted the deception after the Kenyan anti-doping agency investigated her claims.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP