TRP case audit: Mumbai Police say have proof; Republic TV rubbishes it; BARC says not right to comment

Updated on Dec 26, 2020 01:05 AM IST
Forensic auditors appointed by BARC analysed the data of 44 weeks in their audit. The police also alleged that it appears from the audit that the ratings were pre-decided and accordingly manipulated
Partho Dasgupta, the former chief executive officer of BARC India outside the Killa court on Friday.(Anshuman Poyrekar/HT Photo)
Partho Dasgupta, the former chief executive officer of BARC India outside the Killa court on Friday.(Anshuman Poyrekar/HT Photo)
ByManish K Pathak

The Mumbai Police’s crime branch, which is probing the television rating points (TRP) manipulation case, has claimed that a recent forensic audit conducted by the Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) has brought out a lot of incriminating material, and revealed how data was manipulated to bring Republic TV at the number one position among English news channels.

Joint commissioner of police Milind Bharambe said the data manipulation was mostly done between 2016 and 2019. Forensic auditors appointed by BARC analysed the data of 44 weeks in their audit. He also alleged that it appears from the audit that the ratings were pre-decided and accordingly manipulated.

The number one news channel at the time was thus brought to the second position, said the police.

“Three methods were used for the manipulation, and data was selectively chosen to ascertain and analyse TRP for the particular [accused] channel,” said Bharambe.

Police have also discovered some emails and WhatsApp chats exchanged between the ex-employees of BARC and channels on the BARC servers. Bharambe said one of the chats read, “Please find below numbers on English news, as required. Times Now numbers were changed while Republic remains same”.

Another chat stated: “Pls find below English news channels-Times Now and CNN News 18 –will be changed. The equations of Times Now have decreased drastically across the universe”.

Republic TV in its statement said the claims are “laughable”. In support of its claim, the channel said BARC had sent e-mails to Republic on October 17 and November 20, stating that there was no question of any manipulation by the channel.

“The [forensic report] Mumbai Police is referring to is from July. BARC’s emails to us are from November and December. It defies common sense why BARC would give Republic Media Network a complete clean chit in November and December.”

It has further claimed for the past three months, Mumbai Police has done everything possible to “target” Republic Network, and has “fallen flat” every time. “This ridiculous and bizarre witch-hunt was exposed once again today,” it adds.

A spokesperson from BARC India said, “The development related to the two ex-employees of BARC India is a part of an ongoing investigation for which BARC management continues to extend its support and cooperation to the law enforcement agencies. It would consequently be inappropriate for BARC to comment any further at this stage. Every employee of BARC India is expected to conform to a Code of Conduct & Ethics and any infringement invites suitable disciplinary action. We will continue to ensure that what Indian watches is reported accurately and with utmost integrity. It’s a responsibility we owe all our stakeholders.”

The audit report also mentioned manipulation being done for some entertainment channels.

Meanwhile, Partho Nirmal Dasgupta, former CEO of BARC, who was arrested from Pune on Thursday after his role cropped up during investigation, is also suspected to be involved in manipulation of TRP. Dasgupta worked in from 2013 to 2019. He allegedly misused his position to manipulate TRP of some channels.

He was produced before a magistrate on Friday and has been remanded to police custody till December 28.

“We have got very strong evidence with us against the officials who are responsible for TRP fraud. BARC has cooperated very well and helped in the investigation,” Bharambe added.

The investigation in the case started on October 6. The first charge-sheet has been filed against some of the accused.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Traffic chaos at JVPD signal, at Juhu (Vijay Bate/HT Photo)

    JVPD flyover sees light of day; work to start in October: BMC

    Mumbai: Construction of the much-awaited 1.65 kilometre flyover between Juhu Versova Link Road (JVLR) and Mayor Hall near the CD Barfiwala flyover is expected to commence in October, Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation officials said. The civic body floated a ₹350 crore tender on August 8. The flyover, once built, is expected to reduce travel time from Juhu circle to Western Express Highway (WEH) from 45 minutes to five minutes.

  • Police got information that Padelkar was seen in the Sion area from where police arrested him on Wednesday (HT)

    BMC employee arrested for duping 20 job aspirants

    Mumbai: A 31-year-old employee of Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation was arrested on Wednesday for allegedly duping people on the pretext of providing them jobs in the civic body. The Park Site police officials said, the accused, Sameer Baban Padelkar, works as a labourer with the D-Ward office of BMC for over a decade. He cheated over 20 people in the last four years and took at least ₹3 to ₹4 lakh from each of them.

  • Police said the shooters left a note written in Hindi that if any one does business outside the centre, they will kill them, said a police officer. (Satish Bate/HT PHOTO)

    Unidentified persons fire rounds outside shopping centre in Bandra, threaten hawkers

    Mumbai: Three unidentified persons on a bike, fired a few rounds outside Gazebo shopping centre in Bandra (west) and also directly at the board. Deputy commissioner of police Manjunath Singe of Zone 9 said, “Unidentified persons fired in the air and on the board of Gazebo Shopping centre situated on Linking Road in Khar. No one was injured in the firing.” The incident occurred around 7:45pm on Thursday.

  • New Delhi, India - Aug. 11, 2022: A hawker selling Indian flags ahead of Independence Day celebrations at Ring Road in New Delhi, India, on Thursday, August 11, 2022. (Photo by Raj K Raj/ Hindustan Times) (Hindustan Times)

    Residents concerned about disposal of national flag post I-Day celebrations

    With several thousands of households, streets, markets and offices expected to be adorned with the national flag between August 13 and August 15, as part of the “Har Ghar Tiranga (tricolour on every household)” campaign to mark the 75th year of Independence, residents have legitimate concerns about whether these flags would be disposed of in a dignified and safe manner once the celebrations are over.

  • Yamuna flows over danger mark at old Iron Bridge in 2021. (Sanchit Khanna/HT Photo)

    Flood warning issued as Haryana releases 300,000 cusecs of water in the Yamuna

    The irrigation and flood control department of the Delhi government on Thursday issued the first flood warning for the city after over 300,000 cusecs of water was released into the Yamuna from the Hathnikund barrage in Haryana's Yamuna Nagar on August 11, 2022. A senior irrigation and flood control Department said the first warning is being issued as more than 300,000 cusecs of water was released from the barrage located 228km upstream of Delhi.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Friday, August 12, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now