Bombay HC vacates stay on felling trees for Metro-4 corridor

Updated on Nov 26, 2019 04:03 AM IST
The plea challenged two notifications issued by the urban development department, on June 30, 2018 and January 2, 2019.
the Bombay high court (HC) on Monday vacated its interim order passed on September 20, which restrained the authority from felling any tree for Metro-4(HT Photo)
the Bombay high court (HC) on Monday vacated its interim order passed on September 20, which restrained the authority from felling any tree for Metro-4(HT Photo)
Hindustan Times, Mumbai | ByKanchan Chaudhari, Mumbai

In a major reprieve for the Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority (MMRDA), the Bombay high court (HC) on Monday vacated its interim order passed on September 20, which restrained the authority from felling any tree for Metro-4 (Wadala to Kasarwadavli in Thane).

“A public project cannot be stopped like this,” said a bench of justice SC Dharmadhikari and justice RI Chagla, while hearing a public interest litigation (PIL) challenging the permission to develop the elevated corridor. The petitioner, Thane Nagrik Pratishthan, wanted the line to be developed as an underground corridor.

The plea challenged two notifications issued by the urban development department, on June 30, 2018 and January 2, 2019. Objecting to the first notification, which appoints MMRDA as a special planning authority, the petitioner stated that Section 40 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 empowers the state only to appoint a special planning authority for an undeveloped area, not a project. The second notification, which exempts the authority from obtaining permissions from planning authorities, flouts provisions of the Development Control Regulations, as 11 of the 32 stations are planned on narrow roads with a width of less than 20m, the plea stated. At some points, the line is close to the existing buildings, posing a threat to life and property, along with a safety concern, it claimed. The petitioner also complained that the MMRDA has not obtained the mandatory prior environmental clearance for the line.

On Monday, the bench asked the petitioner: “Are you suggesting that trees can’t be cut even for infrastructure projects?”

Senior advocate Gayatri Singh, who represented the petitioner body, justified the interim order, pointing out that the Thane Municipal Commissioner had in August granted permission to cut 36 trees and transplant more than 900 trees for the project, in breach of provisions of the Maharashtra (Urban Areas) Protection and Preservation of Trees Act, 1975. Singh said only the tree authority could have passed such an order. The bench, however, felt the petitioner could not have obtained such an order, without a notice to other parties and there was no justification to continue the interim order.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The threat calls were made to a phone number of Sir HN Reliance Foundation Hospital that is run by the Reliance Foundation (Mint File Photo)

    Mumbai man who made 9 calls threatening Mukesh Ambani is a 56-yr-old jeweller

    A 56-year-old jeweller in north Mumbai was arrested on Monday on charges that56-year-old jeweler, Vishnu Vidhu Bhowmik, who has a jewelry shop in south Mumbaie made nine threat calls to the Sir HN Reliance Foundation Hospital in south Mumbai and threatened to harm Reliance Industries Limited chairman Mukesh Ambani and members of his family. The phone calls were made between 10:39am and 12.04pm on Monday. Police earlier said it appeared that the nine calls were made by the same person.

  • Anand Mohan (right).

    6 cops suspended for providing special treatment to ex-MP and convict Anand Mohan

    Six police personnel, including a sub-inspector (SI), were suspended for allegedly providing 'special treatment' to convicted gangster-turned-politician Anand Mohan Singh when he appeared at a Patna court on August 12. Saharsa superintendent of police Lipi Singh took the action on Monday, including four DAP jawans and an SAP driver, and ordered departmental proceedings against them. Anand Mohan was accused of inciting a mob to lynch the young Dalit IAS officer on December 5, 1994.

  • A Shivneri bus HT Archives

    Shivneri buses to Pune from Thane and Borivali to be replaced with low-cost Shivai

    Come October, commuters headed to Pune from Thane and Borivali will have a low-cost, yet comfortable transport facility. The Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation is planning to replace the iconic Shivneri buses on this route with electric Shivai buses. However, the Shivneri buses will continue to ply between Dadar and Pune. Currently, Shivneri buses charge ₹450 per passenger.

  • Students in the process of getting admission at Miranda House College in New Delhi. The admission process is on for the new academic session in Delhi University. (Photo by Sushil Kumar/Hindustan Times)

    Only 20% FYJC aspirants confirm admission in four days, deadline on Wednesday

    Mumbai: Blame it on the long weekend and travel plans or students refusing to alter their college preference, just 20% first-year junior college (FYJC) aspirants from the second merit list have confirmed admissions until Monday. College principals have attributed this low admission acceptance to students travelling during the long weekend. The second merit list was released by the office of the deputy director of education (DyDE) on August 12, where 69,691 students were allotted seats.

  • On the day of the incident, the couple had a heated exchange of words at night and after which Mukhtar fled from the area. Since he is absconding, it appears that he had killed his wife, said the police officer, adding that there are strangulation marks on her neck. (HT Photo)

    Man strangulates wife over petty issue, flees

    Mumbai: A 33-year-old man allegedly killed hMukhtar'swife by strangulating her over a trivial issue in wee hours on Sunday and fled from the house. JJ Marg police have launched a manhunt for him. According to the police, the deceased was identified as Manzila Shaikh, 30, who was staying in Imamwada area along JJ Marg along with her husband, Sukhchand Shaikh alias Mukhtar, 33.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Monday, August 15, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now