Afghanistan disappointed by scale of China-India infrastructure project in country

India has conceded to China’s request to jointly implement a limited “capacity building” project in Afghanistan instead of a large-scale venture in the infrastructure or energy sectors, leaving Kabul “underwhelmed”, people familiar with the latest developments have said.
Afghanistan's Chief Executive Abdullah Abdullah (L) speaks at the 'Passage to Prosperity' India-Afghanistan Trade and Investment Show in Mumbai on September 12, 2018.(PTI)
Afghanistan's Chief Executive Abdullah Abdullah (L) speaks at the 'Passage to Prosperity' India-Afghanistan Trade and Investment Show in Mumbai on September 12, 2018.(PTI)
Updated on Sep 12, 2018 09:40 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times, Beijing | BySutirtho Patranobis

India has conceded to China’s request to jointly implement a limited “capacity building” project in Afghanistan instead of a large-scale venture in the infrastructure or energy sectors, leaving Kabul “underwhelmed”, people familiar with the latest developments have said.

Beijing seemingly convinced New Delhi to opt for a smaller project in Afghanistan, possibly to assuage the misgivings of its close ally Islamabad.

Three months after the project was announced – preceded by several months of trilateral discussions – diplomats here are tight-lipped about how much progress has been made in its implementation, or how much Pakistan was a factor in scaling down the venture.

The decision has left Kabul dismayed, as the Ashraf Ghani government -- part of long-drawn discussions on the venture -- had expected a bigger project, one that could directly benefit the citizens of the war-torn country, people familiar with the discussions said.  

Kabul was disappointed given New Delhi’s long history of being a “more effective donor” which addressed Afghanistan’s critical needs, they said.

Given that China is the world’s second largest economy and Afghanistan’s strategic partner since 2012, it was expected that Beijing would be more ambitious, they added.

India and China’s first third-country project was announced after the informal summit between Prime Minister Narendra Modi and President Xi Jinping in the central Chinese city of Wuhan in April. Xi brought up the prospect of a trilateral project in Afghanistan and Modi agreed.

Later, India’s foreign secretary Vijay Gokhale shared an outline. The two countries will undertake a capacity-building project in Afghanistan, Gokhale said after the two leaders met again on the sidelines of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) Summit in the coastal city of Qingdao in June.

The announcements were made at Wuhan and Qingdao, but the groundwork was done earlier. Discussions between New Delhi, Beijing and Kabul on the project had begun in 2016.

Several rounds of talks were held between Chinese, Indian and Afghan diplomats to frame a strategy and to analyse the feasibility of such a project. Equally crucial was the diplomatic message it would send out internationally – Pakistan was bound to be annoyed.

India initially agreed to implement a joint project in agriculture, infrastructure or energy and New Delhi told Kabul as much. The expectation was China would agree as well.

Days before the Wuhan summit, China floated the idea of a capacity building project. Such a venture will be valuable but a trilateral project in Afghanistan had – and still has - the potential and capacity to be more effective and useful, the people said.

It is now expected that the modest start will develop into something more substantial in later stages, they added.

However, the expectation for a big project was high, for one, as Kabul is already involved in other trilateral capacity building projects. Afghanistan and China are involved in projects with the US, the UK and Germany, involving the training of diplomats and mining experts and doing business.

China’s foreign ministry had a generic response when asked about the project and whether Beijing convinced India to scale it down. “During the informal summit in Wuhan, President Xi Jinping and PM Narendra Modi agreed on strengthening policy coordination in surrounding regions, and discussed about developing ‘Sino-India-Plus’ cooperation,” said an email response from the ministry.

“Leaders of both countries also agreed on keeping in contact and coordinating over the issue of Afghanistan, in order to jointly promote peace, stability and development in Afghanistan. The two sides are maintaining communication on the implementation of the consensus made by two leaders,” it added.

There is a rationale behind India and China opting for a low-profile project in Afghanistan, said Barnett Rubin from New York University. “It is a first step. Both are cautious. We should encourage bigger things. They are talking about them but not yet ready to move,” Rubin said, adding that “expectations must be realistic”.

For a disappointed Afghanistan, that’s the reality.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • A worker wearing a face mask and protective gown drives a cart along a street in Shanghai, China, Saturday. 

    Shanghai reopens some public transport, still on high Covid alert

    Shanghai reopened a small part of the world's longest subway system on Sunday after some lines had been closed for almost two months, as the city paves the way for a more complete lifting of its painful COVID-19 lockdown next week. Inside the carriages, passengers were seen keeping some empty seats between themselves. Four of the 20 lines reopened, and 273 bus routes. Most restrictions on movement will remain in place this month.

  • Biden said he was "not concerned" about new North Korean nuclear tests, which would be the first in nearly five years.

    Joe Biden says 'hello' to N.Korea's Kim Jong amid tensions over weapons tests

    US President Joe Biden, in Seoul before heading to Japan as part of his first Asia trip as president, had a simple message for North Korea's Kim Jong Un: "Hello... period," he told reporters on the last day of his visit to South Korea on Sunday. Biden said he was "not concerned" about new North Korean nuclear tests, which would be the first in nearly five years.

  • TOPSHOT - Ukrainian servicemen assist their comrades not far from the frontline in the eastern Ukrainian region of Donbas, on May 21, 2022. (Photo by AFP)

    Only diplomacy can end Ukraine war: Zelensky as Kyiv rules out ceasefire- top 10

    Only diplomacy can end the Ukraine war, the country's president, Volodymyr Zelensky, has insisted as Kyiv on Saturday ruled out settling for ceasefire or “concessions” to Russia. Here are ten updates on the Ukraine war: 1. The war-hit country has estimated its losses to be around $100 billion, reports have said. The Ukraine war has triggered a global fuel and food crisis. But it has also widened the differences between Russia and its neighbouring countries.

  • FILE - People watch a TV screen showing a news program reporting with an image of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, at a train station in Seoul, South Korea on May 16, 2022. North Korean propaganda describes an all-out effort to fight a suspected COVID-19 outbreak that has sickened nearly 2 million people. But defectors say fear is palpable among North Korean citizens who lack access to hospital care and struggle to afford even basic medicine. 

    Covid may be factor in lack of North Korea response to outreach: White House

    COVID-19 restrictions may be playing a role in North Korea's lack of response to offers of diplomatic talks, a senior U.S. administration official said on Sunday, a day after President Joe Biden said he had offered vaccines to Pyongyang. Biden is in South Korea before heading to Japan later on Sunday as part of his first trip through Asia as president.

  • Community members gather to look at a tree that was destroyed during a major storm in Ottawa, Canada, Saturday.

    Four dead in Canada after heavy storms wreak havoc in Ontario and Quebec

    Four people are dead and nearly 900,000 homes without power after severe storms pummeled the eastern Canadian provinces of Ontario and Quebec, authorities said Saturday. Ontario police said on Twitter that three people had died and several more were injured due to a strong summer thunderstorm. One man was killed when a tree fell on the trailer he was staying in. The fourth victim was a woman in her fifties.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Sunday, May 22, 2022