Camphor, cardamom have no role in killing swine flu virus, say Bhopal docs

Updated on Mar 11, 2015 04:33 PM IST
For the last one month or so, a message has been circulating on social media and WhatsApp groups in Bhopal, claiming that “mixing equal parts of camphor and green cardamom, putting them in a cotton cloth and sniffing it on an hourly basis can save you from swine flu”.
Hindustan Times | By, Bhopal

For the last one month or so, a message has been circulating on social media and WhatsApp groups in Bhopal, claiming that “mixing equal parts of camphor and green cardamom, putting them in a cotton cloth and sniffing it on an hourly basis can save you from swine flu”.

With over 195 people having died from swine flu since January 1 in MP, people are paranoid and willing to attempt these measures, without knowing whether there is any scientific evidence to prove their efficacy.

To find out if these measures were derived from the alternative system of medicine and were capable of treating swine flu, HT spoke to allopathic, ayurvedic and Unani experts.

Pulmonary medicine specialist at Hamidia Hospital Dr Lokendra Dave says there is no scientific basis in such measures.

“Swine flu is a viral disease and camphor and cardamom have no role in killing the virus. Camphor does provide some symptomatic relief once you catch cold as it dilates the blood vessels. But sniffing it in no way can protect you from the flu.”

Doctors of alternative medicine say though there is no direct proof of their efficacy, attempting such measures will not cause any harm.

Ayurvedic doctor Dr Anurag Jain, who runs a clinic in Kolar, echoes Dave’s views.

“Camphor oil and cardamom, which are used in detoxification and cleansing in Ayurveda, have a limited effect in boosting your immunity. But that is not enough to protect you from the virus,” he says.

However, Ayurvedic doctor Dr Purnima Shrivastav, who runs a clinic at New Market says she advises her patients to not go in for such measures.

“When you sniff camphor and cardamom, it momentarily increases the temperature of the fine blood vessels inside your nasal cavity. And with the increase in temperature, the cold viruses don’t affect you that much. But once the effect wears off after some minutes, you feel more cold and this can aggravate your cold or make you susceptible to it,” she warns.

Hakim Suleman Khan, who runs a Unani Al Shifa clinic at Imami Gate, says though there is no proof the effectiveness against the flu, camphor is known for its cleansing and bacteria-killing properties in alternative medicine therapies.

“We use camphor for cleaning and killing microbes. So maybe it works against H1N1 too,” he says.


    He is principal correspondent based at Bhopal. He covers environment and wildlife, state administration, BJP and other saffron organisations. He has special interest in social issues based stories.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The skywalk near Viviana Mall in Thane Praful Gangurde/HT Photo

    Locals flag safety concerns on skywalk nearly two km from CM Shinde’s residence

    Four days after a college student was allegedly molested on a skywalk at Manpada, local residents have raised safety concerns over another skywalk in the heart of the city which they claim is taken over by miscreants at night as there are no adequate lights and CCTV cameras. Interestingly, this skywalk near Viviana Mall is barely a few metres from former minister Jitendra Awhad's home and around two km from chief minister Eknath Shinde's residence.

  • Mumbai, India – August 16, 2018: A view of Ramtek Bungalow, at Walkeshwar, in Mumbai, India, on Thursday, Aug 16, 2018. (Photo by Bhushan Koyande/HT) (HT PHOTO)

    Newly-appointed ministers lobby for posh Malabar Hill official bungalows

    With its private beach and a sprawling lawn, Ramtek bungalow in Malabar Hill leads the list, followed by Royal Stone, a colonial-style bungalow with wooden flooring located in Peddar Road. While Maharashtra Assembly Speaker Rahul Narvekar and revenue minister Radhakrishna Vikhe Patil have requested for Royal Stone, forest minister Sudhir Mungantiwar, labour minister Suresh Khade and Vikhe-Patil are vying for Ramtek bungalow, the largest bungalow after Varsha, the official residence of the chief minister.

  • Mumbai, India - August 15, 2022: Two senior citizens died after the ceiling portion from the first floor of the ground-plus-two Moti Chhaya Building collapsed on Monday evening at Mulund (East), in Mumbai, India, on Monday, August 15, 2022. (Photo by Satish Bate/ Hindustan Times) (Satish Bate/HT PHOTO)

    Mulund building collapse: Roof gives way, killing old couple

    Mumbai: Two senior citizens lost their lives after the ceiling of a residential structure in which they resided came down on Monday evening. The deceased were identified as Devshankar Nathalal Shukla (93) and his wife, Arkhiben Devshankar Shukla (87). According to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation's (BMC) disaster control cell, the incident took place at around 7.46 pm, on the first floor of the building.

  • Widespread protests had broken out across Shivamogga in February over the murder of 26-year-old Bajrang Dal activist Harsha. (Representational photo)

    Violence erupts over Savarkar, Tipu photos in Shivamogga

    Karnataka Police on Monday imposed curbs under Section 144 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) in Shivamogga town after a clash between two groups over banners featuring Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh ideologue V D Savarkar and 18th Century ruler Tipu Sultan. A senior police officer familiar with the matter said tension broke out after a banner featuring Savarkar was put up at Amir Ahmed Circle, in Shivamogga, as part of Independence Day celebrations.

  • A policeman salutes the national flag, in Bengaluru. (PTI)

    In a first, Tricolour hoisted at Idgah Maidan amid tight vigil

    In a first, the national flag was hoisted amid tight security on Monday morning at Idgah Maidan in Chamarajpet. The Tricolour was hoisted at the Idgah Maidan by assistant commissioner of Bengaluru (Urban) MG Shivanna. Chamarajpet MLA Zameer Ahmed Khan, member of Lok Sabha from Bengaluru Central constituency PC Mohan, additional commissioner of police (Bengaluru west) Sandeep Patil and deputy commissioner of police (Bengaluru west) Laxman Nimbargi were also present in the event.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, August 16, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now