In many senses, Palwankar Baloo was the first modern Dalit icon.(Illustration: Mohit Suneja)
In many senses, Palwankar Baloo was the first modern Dalit icon.(Illustration: Mohit Suneja)

India’s first Dalit cricketer Palwankar Baloo fought against caste barriers on the field and off it

India’s poor show in the recent England tour is almost a mirror image of its performance during its first-ever outing in 1911. But one man stood out by the grit of his spin and his fight against caste barriers on the field and off it. Why is he forgotten?
By Dhrubo Jyoti | Hindustan Times, New Delhi
UPDATED ON SEP 16, 2018 09:59 AM IST

In 1892, the Poona Club made a most curious hire. At a monthly salary of Rs 4, a 17-year-old boy was brought in to erect the nets, roll and mark the pitch meant exclusively for Europeans. The boy had had similar duties at a club run by Parsis, but now, he got an additional task: bowl to the British batsmen at the nets.

The hundreds of hours bowling at the net helped him grow up into one of modern India’s greatest cricketers. His name was Palwankar Baloo and he became the backbone of Indian cricket, leading the Hindu Gymkhana to many rousing victories against their erstwhile British rulers. He was also the only sliver of hope in an otherwise depressing tour of England in 1911 — the first by an all-Indian team — taking 114 wickets at an average of 18.84 with a best haul of 8/103 against Cambridge.

“He was an extraordinary cricketer who battled incredible discrimination,” said historian Ramachandra Guha, whose 2002 book, A Corner of A Foreign Field, chronicles, among many other things, the life of the Palwankar brothers.

But one of India’s first world-class players, and its first Dalit cricketer, has been neatly brushed out of the annals of history, save a handful of textual records and oral histories — an indictment of both India’s cricket writing and the erasure of Dalit heroes from mainstream history and consciousness.

An Indian great

The eldest of four brothers, Baloo was born in 1875 in Dharwad to a family of leather workers but his father was in the army. Baloo and his brother Shivram learnt to play cricket with equipment discarded by officers in Pune. “The army held out the promise of a degree of equality for Dalits impossible elsewhere in a caste-ridden society,” explained Shraddha Kumbhojkar, a professor at Savitribai Phule Pune University.

Indian cricket at the time was organised on caste and faith lines and the pinnacle of the season was a tournament in Bombay, where Hindu, Parsi, British, and, later, Muslim teams competed in three-day matches. Hindus in Pune had started a club but were in two minds over whether to invite Baloo. He was certainly the most talented bowler but breaking caste taboos was an anathema. But once picked, Baloo immediately made his presence felt and helped his team notch up several victories against the Europeans. “The Hindu team was otherwise weak. Baloo helped them match the British,” said Sadanand More, a Marathi historian.

By 1896, Baloo’s fame had spread and he moved to Bombay to play for the newly-commissioned Parmanandas Jivandas Hindu Gymkhana, one of the teams in the famed Bombay quadrangular. “The most deadly bowler on a sticky wicket. May be called (Wilfred) Rhodes of India,” said Dr ME Pavri, one of Baloo’s opponents at the time. In 1906, the Bombay quadrangular was held just as the independence movement was gathering steam. Each victory of the Hindu team, helmed by Baloo, was cheered wildly. The final saw the Hindus squaring off against the British. The Hindus batted first and posted 242, and then bowled the British out for 191. In the second innings, the Indians made 160, setting the British a target of 212. But fifers from Baloo and another bowler, Erasha, saw the Europeans crumble to 102, handing the Indians a famous victory.

By then, the growing cricket fervour had kindled the desire for an England tour. But the 1911 outing ended in disgrace. The visitors slumped to a defeat in 10 matches and won only two. The bright spot was Baloo, who enjoyed success against university and county sides alike: 5/87 against Oxford; 4/96 against the MCC; and 7/83 against Lancashire.

Upon their return to India, Baloo was celebrated, none more wildly than the depressed classes, who felt pride at one of them having bested not just the Brahmins but also the British. At this function, the welcome address was given a young college lecturer by the name of BR Ambedkar, the first public appearance of a man who would go on to write the country’s Constitution.

Caste bias

In 1896, a deadly plague broke out in Pune, wiping out almost half the population. But quarantine and treatment was hobbled by caste bias as high-caste neighbourhoods refused to mingle, even if death was the alternative. When the administration ordered the army to forcibly quarantine people, it sparked off angry protests because many armymen were Dalits. “This is how casteist Pune was then,” explained Kumbhojkar.

In this city began Baloo’s career. During the tea interval in matches, he would be served outside the pavilion in a disposable clay ‘matka’. If he wished to wash his hands and face, a fellow Dalit attendant would bring him water in a corner. He would eat lunch off a separate plate, at a separate table. When the caste barriers were finally lifted in Bombay, Baloo became one of the first public Dalit figure to inter-dine with upper-castes, said Raosaheb Kasbe, a former professor of philosophy at Pune University.

Baloo’s prowess on the field dulled the onslaught of prejudice but didn’t eradicate it, especially on the thorny question of captaincy. Every time Baloo was successful, it was heralded as a great moment for Hindu unity and cricket, but it was unthinkable for the selectors to choose a Dalit captain. Between 1910 and 1920, there was an unsuccessful campaign every year to make Baloo the captain. Despite this, there was widespread acknowledgement of Baloo’s talent, as reflected in 1913 when then captain MD Pai admitted, “The honour of captainship should have been given to my friend Mr Baloo.”

“This was remarkable because you don’t have Ganguly saying Dravid should be captain. Pai was discreetly saying Baloo was a better cricketer,” Guha said.

The insult was compounded in 1920, when Baloo was dropped from the team and his brother Vithal – by then an ace batsman and a idol of later legend Vijay Merchant – was passed over for captaincy in favour of a young Brahmin, DB Deodhar. In anger, Baloo’s brothers Vithal and Shivram withdrew from the team.

“Social or educational status has no place in sport…that such matters as caste should be the determining factor in cricket is more than we can quietly bow down to,” the brothers said in a letter. In the end, Baloo was made vice-captain. Three years and a string of similar boycotts later, Vithal captained the Hindu team and led them to a famous victory against the British. The shackles had finally crumbled.

Second innings

In many senses, Baloo was the first modern Dalit icon. “Dalits didn’t have a leader then, so he became a leader. He was known all over India,” said Kasbe. Indeed, in his speeches throughout the 1910s, Ambedkar drew connections to Baloo and spoke of how much he admired the cricketer. As late as 1927 and 1928, Ambedkar was telling village audiences of his attempts to promote the greatness of Baloo.

Fate, however, would pit them against each other.

In 1932, India’s politics was at an impasse over separate electorates for the depressed classes, a demand by Ambedkar that Gandhi strongly opposed. Baloo, a Chamar, was an early Gandhian who supported Gandhi’s fast and opposed Ambedkar, a Mahar. When Gandhi’s health deteriorated, Baloo and Tamil leader MC Rajah pressed on Ambedkar to accept a compromise, that of reserved electorates. Ambedkar relented, and Baloo, an unlikely leader, signed on the landmark 1932 Poona Pact.

Five years later, Baloo and Ambedkar sqauared off once again, this time for the Bombay assembly. By then, the cricketer had already publicly opposed Ambedkar’s decision to convert out of Hinduism, calling it a suicidal move.

Guha writes the decision to select Baloo was made by Vallabhbhai Patel for Baloo’s achievements and because his community made up a significant portion of the constituency. But the cricketer appeared deeply reluctant to fight Ambedkar, according to his nephew and son. According to the Bombay Chronicle, Baloo told a rally in January 1937 that he wasn’t interested in fighting elections and that he agreed without knowing which seat he would contest from. In the end, he lost narrowly, 11,225 votes to Ambedkar’s 13,245.

But why was such a remarkable life forgotten? Ramesh Kamble, a professor at Mumbai University, attributes this to two opposing thought in the movement, one that seeks space in the oppressor community and the other that sees oppression as structure, and therefore questions it. “Baloo represented the first and hence became a part of Gandhian protests.”

Guha thinks the reasons lie with cricket historians’ obsession with Test matches, which India began playing in 1932. Kasbe argues the anti-caste movement was still nascent and Baloo as a Chamar leader was not acceptable to all Dalits. And, of course, the institutional neglect of Dalits meant there is little written record of Baloo’s achievements.

Palwankar Baloo was the greatest Indian cricketer of his time who deserves to be remembered and celebrated for shining through oppressive caste prejudices. As Guha says, he must have been an exceptional left-arm spinner. “His figures were both remarkable and heroic, in fighting against prejudice that modern cricketers cannot dream of.”

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
FILE PHOTO: Tennis - Australian Open - Melbourne, Australia, January 14, 2018. Tennis balls are pictured in front of the Australian Open logo before the tennis tournament. REUTERS/Thomas Peter//File Photo(REUTERS)
FILE PHOTO: Tennis - Australian Open - Melbourne, Australia, January 14, 2018. Tennis balls are pictured in front of the Australian Open logo before the tennis tournament. REUTERS/Thomas Peter//File Photo(REUTERS)

3 more COVID-19 cases linked to Australian Open arrivals

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 07:22 AM IST
There are 72 players now in hard quarantine and unable to practice because of nine active coronavirus cases — an increase in three — among the incoming travelers to Melbourne.
Close
Arsenal's Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang celebrates scoring their first goal.(Pool via REUTERS)
Arsenal's Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang celebrates scoring their first goal.(Pool via REUTERS)

Aubameyang ends drought in Arsenal's 3-0 win over Newcastle

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 04:22 AM IST
It was a fifth consecutive clean sheet in all competitions for Arsenal and a fourth win in five league matches.
Close
File image of Rohan Bopanna.(File)
File image of Rohan Bopanna.(File)

Bopanna stuck in Australian Open quarantine, Gabba Test a solace

By Rutvick Mehta
PUBLISHED ON JAN 19, 2021 04:25 AM IST
First, India’s top-ranked doubles player learnt that his coach Scott Davidoff had to be quarantined as he was in the Los Angeles flight from which two positive cases came to light on Saturday.
Close
Milan's Zlatan Ibrahimovic, centre, celebrates after scoring the second goal of the game, with Samu Castillejo, left, and Alessio Romagnoli, right, during their Italian Serie A soccer match between Cagliari and Milan at the Sardegna Arena stadium in Cagliari, Italy, Monday, Jan. 18, 2021. (Spada/LaPresse via AP)(AP)
Milan's Zlatan Ibrahimovic, centre, celebrates after scoring the second goal of the game, with Samu Castillejo, left, and Alessio Romagnoli, right, during their Italian Serie A soccer match between Cagliari and Milan at the Sardegna Arena stadium in Cagliari, Italy, Monday, Jan. 18, 2021. (Spada/LaPresse via AP)(AP)

Ibrahimović scores 2 as Milan beat Cagliari 2-0 to go clear

AP
UPDATED ON JAN 19, 2021 04:21 AM IST
Milan substitute Alexis Saelemaekers was sent off after picking up two yellow cards in quick succession shortly after coming off the bench.
Close
File photo of Lionel Messi(REUTERS)
File photo of Lionel Messi(REUTERS)

Messi facing lengthy suspension for hitting opponent

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 10:29 PM IST
Messi could be suspended for up to 12 games for the red card he received in the final minutes of his team's 3-2 loss to Athletic Bilbao in Seville on Sunday.
Close
SC East Bengal held off Chennaiyin FC to a goalless draw(ISL/Twitter)
SC East Bengal held off Chennaiyin FC to a goalless draw(ISL/Twitter)

ISL: 10-man East Bengal hold Chennaiyin to draw

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 10:17 PM IST
Majumder made a slew of saves to keep CFC at bay for more than an hour after the red-and-gold were reduced to 10 players following Ajay Chhetri's send-off in the first-half. They stretched their unbeaten run to seven matches.
Close
Sports Minister Kiren Rijiju launches the 'Khelo India State Centre of Excellence' at the Shri Shiv Chhatrapati Sports Complex, Pune(Khelo India/ Twitter)
Sports Minister Kiren Rijiju launches the 'Khelo India State Centre of Excellence' at the Shri Shiv Chhatrapati Sports Complex, Pune(Khelo India/ Twitter)

Want to start 1,000 Khelo India centres at district level across India: Rijiju

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 07:04 PM IST
Sports Minister Kiren Rijiju pointed out that Maharashtra is the only state in the country to have three centres of excellence.
Close
File photo of Nick Kyrgios(REUTERS)
File photo of Nick Kyrgios(REUTERS)

Kyrgios calls Djokovic 'tool' after quarantine demands

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 08:49 PM IST
Passengers who arrived on three charter flights have been placed into hard quarantine, including more than 70 players who are unable to train outside their rooms for 14 days before the year's first Grand Slam starts on February 8.
Close
File image of Davis Cup.(Twitter/Davis Cup)
File image of Davis Cup.(Twitter/Davis Cup)

Davis Cup Finals up to 11 days in 2021, could be in 3 cities

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 08:30 PM IST
The ITF announced Monday that the international men's tennis team event will run from Nov. 25 to Dec. 5, with 18 countries participating in six groups of three.
Close
Photo of Indian badminton player PV Sindhu(Twitter)
Photo of Indian badminton player PV Sindhu(Twitter)

Sindhu and other Indian shuttlers look for better show at Thailand Open

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 03:23 PM IST
The Indian players seemed to struggle with their fitness as none of them could cross the second round at the Yonex Thailand Open, the first event of the Asia leg here.
Close
Representational Image(Twitter)
Representational Image(Twitter)

Bhavesh, Aakanksha win on final day of shooting trials

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 06:06 PM IST
Bhavesh shot 32 in the finals to leave Delhi's Arpit Goel at second on a score of 27. Haryana's Adarsh Singh came in third with 23.
Close
Serbia's Novak Djokovic(REUTERS)
Serbia's Novak Djokovic(REUTERS)

Groth slams 'selfish' Djokovic after quarantine 'demands'

Reuters
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 03:27 PM IST
A Spanish tennis website reported that Djokovic wrote to Tennis Australia boss Craig Tiley with a list of "demands", asking for reduced isolation periods.
Close
The giant Australian Open logo is seen full of tennis balls ahead of the 2019 Australian Open at Melbourne Park(Getty Images)
The giant Australian Open logo is seen full of tennis balls ahead of the 2019 Australian Open at Melbourne Park(Getty Images)

Tennis players getting on with life in Australia

AP
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:38 PM IST
Angelique Kerber, who won the Australian Open in 2016, spent her birthday in quarantine on Monday. At times in the past, she's spent the day playing or preparing for matches in the later stages of the tournament.
Close
Churchill Brothers S.C. players during a practice session.(ANI)
Churchill Brothers S.C. players during a practice session.(ANI)

Churchill Brothers face RoundGlass Punjab FC, look to keep top spot

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:15 PM IST
Churchill Brothers face RoundGlass Punjab FC, look to keep top spot
Close
Photo of Indian men's hockey team goalkeeper PR Sreejesh(The Hockey India/Twitter)
Photo of Indian men's hockey team goalkeeper PR Sreejesh(The Hockey India/Twitter)

Pro League will be the perfect test ahead of Olympics: Sreejesh

PTI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:11 PM IST
In the next leg of FIH Hockey Pro League matches, India is scheduled to play against Argentina in April, Britain, Spain and Germany in May.
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP