How safe are e-cigarettes? Where’s what science says | Health - Hindustan Times
close_game
close_game

How safe are e-cigarettes? Where’s what science says

Hindustan Times | By
Sep 02, 2018 09:54 AM IST

Are e-cigarettes safer than traditional cigarettes or are they pathways to nicotine addiction? The debate remains highly polarised on whether e-cigarettes should be banned or not.

The health ministry this week asked all states to ban electronic cigarettes (e-cigarettes) and other heat-not-burn vaping devices over risks to public health and ensure they are not “sold, manufactured, distributed, traded, imported and advertised”. The advisory followed a week after the Delhi High Court gave the ministry seven days to file an affidavit giving a time frame within which regulatory measures will be enforced to control the sale of e-cigarettes.

Supporters say the nicotine vapour in e-cigarettes is less harmful than conventional tobacco and helps in smoking cessation, while critics ask a ban because of its potential for misuse as a gateway device to nicotine addiction and smoking.(Shutterstock)
Supporters say the nicotine vapour in e-cigarettes is less harmful than conventional tobacco and helps in smoking cessation, while critics ask a ban because of its potential for misuse as a gateway device to nicotine addiction and smoking.(Shutterstock)

Are e-cigarettes safer than traditional cigarettes or are they pathways to nicotine addiction? The debate remains highly polarised on whether e-cigarettes should be banned or not. Its supporters say the nicotine vapour in e-cigarettes is less harmful than conventional tobacco and helps in smoking cessation, while critics ask for a ban because of its potential for misuse as a gateway device to nicotine addiction and smoking. There’s evidence to show that young e-cigarette users are at increased risk for both starting to smoke and becoming long-term users of combustible tobacco products, according to the American Cancer Society position statement on e-cigarettes issued in February, 2018.

Hindustan Times - your fastest source for breaking news! Read now.

While the jury is still out on a ban, everyone across the board supports stringent regulation and a ban on indoor vaping because of its link with heart disease and promoting tumours. Nicotine vapour also affects foetal growth and lowers brain development in children and adolescents, leading to learning and anxiety disorders.

What’s in a vape?

The vapour (aerosol) contains several toxicants that damage human health, such as glycols, aldehydes, volatile organic compounds (VOCs), polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAHs), tobacco-specific nitrosamines (TSNAs), metals, silicate particles and other elements. The toxicants on average are lower than in cigarette smoke, but heavy metals such as lead, chromium, and nickel and chemicals like formaldehyde are often more in the vapour of e-cigarettes than in traditional cigarettes, according to the World Health Organization report on e-cigarettes. Some toxicants are specific to e-cigarettes, such as glyoxal, which causes gastric irritation and kidney damage.

The levels of toxicants vary enormously across and within brands and are sometimes higher than in tobacco smoke because of thermal decomposition of e-liquid ingredients and difference is battery voltage and unit circuitry, which can alter how the product heats the solution to an aerosol.

Ban or regulate?

With evidence still inconclusive on how effective e-cigarettes are in helping smokers completely quit nicotine addiction, scientists advise caution. The UK’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee report on e-cigarettes released in August supports e-cigarettes as a harm-reduction tool and recommends its use on prescription for tobacco cessation. It notes that they don’t contain tar and carbon monoxide and are substantially less harmful—by around 95%—than conventional cigarettes, but also underline the need for regulation because “there are uncertainties, especially about any long-term health effects, because the products have not yet had a history of long use”.

The American Cancer Society also warns the health effects of long-term use are not known and asks for closer monitoring and discouraging the dual use of e-cigarettes and combustible cigarettes.

Making sense of the latest evidence on e-cigarettes, journal The Lancet warns “e-cigarettes are big business, with tobacco companies having a large stake in many of the products. It is naive and premature... of the (UK House of Commons) Committee to confuse an absence of evidence with an absence of harm.”

Based on available scientific evidence, e-cigarettes must be regulated not as consumer products but as an addictive drug that can be prescribed only to help users stop smoking. With industry trends showing India’s e-cigarette market will grow at a compound annual growth rate of 34%, up from 4.1 billion in 2017 to 7.4 billion in 2019, according to GlobalData Plc, the drug regulator must ensure it’s only used as a harm reduction device to quit nicotine addiction.

Follow @htlifeandstyle for more

Oscars 2024: From Nominees to Red Carpet Glam! Get Exclusive Coverage on HT. Click Here

Catch your daily dose of Fashion, Health, Festivals, Travel, Relationship, Recipe and all the other Latest Lifestyle News on Hindustan Times Website and APPs
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Share this article
  • ABOUT THE AUTHOR
    author-default-90x90

    Sanchita is the health & science editor of the Hindustan Times. She has been reporting and writing on public health policy, health and nutrition for close to two decades. She is an International Reporting Project fellow from Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies at the Bloomberg School of Public Health and was part of the expert group that drafted the Press Council of India’s media guidelines on health reporting, including reporting on people living with HIV.

SHARE
Story Saved
Live Score
OPEN APP
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Thursday, March 28, 2024
Start 14 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Follow Us On