Fact check: Are dietary supplements a rip-off? | Health - Hindustan Times
close_game
close_game

Fact check: Are dietary supplements a rip-off?

By | Posted by Tapatrisha Das
Mar 03, 2024 03:19 PM IST

Dietary supplements are a booming market. But promises of health benefits are often false.

Vitamin D, iron, omega 3: Dietary supplements are a booming market, heavily promoted on social media. But there is hardly any regulation of these supplements — and promises of health benefits are often false.

Food supplements should not replace a balanced diet (Sergiy Artsaba/Zoonar/picture alliance )
Food supplements should not replace a balanced diet (Sergiy Artsaba/Zoonar/picture alliance )

All around the world, more and more people are taking dietary supplements that promise better skin and hair, a strengthened immune system, or improved performance. Magnesium, vitamin C, and others are part of a market worth billions of euros.

Unlock exclusive access to the story of India's general elections, only on the HT App. Download Now!

Angela Clausen from the consumer advice center in North Rhine-Westphalia has been dealing with this topic for years.

"The problem is that a great many people see dietary supplements as a kind of natural medication, so they use them accordingly: for therapy, and to relieve or heal diseases," she says. "But dietary supplements are only really intended to supplement essential components that we don't get enough of from our diet."

In the best-case scenario, when consumers buy dietary supplements that don't benefit them, they're just wasting their money. However, some substances, such as vitamin D, iodine, or selenium can be harmful if too much is consumed.

Food supplements are also subject to far fewer controls, precisely because they are not medications. They can be marketed without having been tested for safety, quality, or effectiveness. Consequently, dietary supplements don't always contain the ingredients indicated on the packet, or may not do so in the quantities stated. Sometimes they even contain substances that are dangerous or banned.

On social media, there is even less monitoring of these claims. False promises about the healthy properties of dietary supplements are found everywhere, as demonstrated by a random investigation of hundreds of posts and stories conducted in 2021.

DW Fact Check did its own search for claims about dietary supplements on social media, then took three examples and analysed them.

Get smarter, with ginkgo biloba, bacopa monnieri, L-theanine and magnesium L-threonate

Claim: In this video, which has been viewed around 1.7 million times, a TikTok user claims: "You're not stupid, you just don't have enough circulation going to your brain, which is preventing you from focussing, concentrating effectively, and it's leading to really poor memory." Her top four recommended supplements to help with this are ginkgo biloba, bacopa monnieri, L-theanine und magnesium L-threonate.

Fact Check: False

Better cognitive performance and concentration thanks to these dietary supplements — unfortunately, it's too good to be true. The nutritionist Friederike Schmidt from the University of Lübeck analysed the video for DW.

"The TikToker talks about very specific metabolic mechanisms, and she does initially appear competent," says Schmidt. However, she points out that, with regard to many aspects of the preparations the woman mentions, "we actually have no idea what they do and whether they help at all."

For example, one of the claims made in the video is that the plant extract bacopa monnieri raises the level of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine in the brain, which improves memory.

"This is very far-fetched," says Schmidt. "As yet, there has been not one methodologically sound study, let alone several, in which people have been given this plant extract, had more acetylcholine in their brains, and were then better able to remember things."

Angela Clausen from the consumer advice center knows all too well that citing studies of little or no relevance or significance is a common tactic when advertising dietary supplements. "The studies presented are usually a disaster as far as the actual product is concerned," she says.

Overall, the TikToker's claims are not at all scientifically sound. There is no proof that her "top four supplement recommendations" improve cognitive performance in the way she describes.

Turmeric: A miracle cure?

Claim: According to this Spanish-language video, which has had more than 1.5 million views, powdered turmeric dissolved in water can help against eczema. It is also alleged to detoxify the body, prevent arthritis, and reduce the risk of cancer. Similar claims can be found here and here, as well as elsewhere.

Fact Check: False

Used as a spice, turmeric has long been held to be good for the digestion. However, according to Clausen, "All these claims are inadmissible; there are no existing studies to support them." There has indeed been research done into the active ingredient in turmeric, curcumin — but there are no "gold standard studies" relating to the imprecisely defined extracts used in the products. This would mean studies conducted in humans, in which neither the researchers nor the subjects knew who had received the placebo and who the active ingredient, and which have ideally been corroborated by at least one other study conducted by a different working group.

Studies have only shown that a specific turmeric extract, at a specific dosage, has an anti-inflammatory effect in laboratory tests, in vitro. But these effects can only be attributed to precisely this extract, in precisely this dosage, not simply to turmeric per se. The effect in humans can be completely different to the effect in a test tube.

"We are very far from being able to say that turmeric definitely helps," says Friederike Schmidt. The nutritionist explains that a particular problem with curcumin is that it is very reactive, meaning that in the laboratory it interacts with many other substances — which is presumably also why it is said to be effective against so many different diseases and problems. But this doesn't necessarily mean it will be effective in people.

Better skin, hair, nails and joints with collagen?

Claim: Posts on social media also ascribe many positive attributes to collagen. This viral video claims it will give you firmer skin, stronger nails, and shinier, stronger hair, while this TikTok clip asserts that it will also support your joints.

Fact Check: False

Collagen is a protein naturally produced by the body. It is important for bones, joints, muscles and tendons. Dietary supplements containing collagen are therefore derived from animals, usually slaughterhouse waste.

It is not clear how well the body is able to process collagen it receives externally. Even the best-known supposed effect of collagen — a rejuvenating effect on the skin — is still in need of further research, according to a meta-study conducted in 2023.

"None of these advertising promises are approved for use in the EU, certainly not the one about joint health," says the consumer advisor Clausen. There is no conclusive evidence it has this effect, she says. The consumer advice center even successfully sued the manufacturer of Glow25 Collagen Powder in 2022 for using the slogan "Healthy bones and joints." Furthermore, the suppliers acknowledged that their promises with regard to its effects on skin, hair and nails were inadmissible. Nonetheless, many posts online still make these claims.

Conclusion: Consumers are being misled

With dietary supplements, it is not easy to separate the truth from the hype. Generally speaking, the claims made on social media are often exaggerated, unscientific, or have even been prohibited.

"In many cases, we see that people are just spending money on things they don't need," says Schmidt. She describes it as "a very tempting idea: that you can do something for your health with a few capsules or powders."

Oscars 2024: From Nominees to Red Carpet Glam! Get Exclusive Coverage on HT. Click Here

Catch your daily dose of Fashion, Health, Festivals, Travel, Relationship, Recipe and all the other Latest Lifestyle News on Hindustan Times Website and APPs.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Share this article
SHARE
Story Saved
Live Score
OPEN APP
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, April 16, 2024
Start 14 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now
Follow Us On