Weight of the matter: What are Eman Ahmed’s doctors, sister fighting over?

Doctors say Eman has lost 333kg over the past two months, while her sister estimates that Eman is just 60kg lighter.
Doctors say Eman’s condition has improved by 70%, which her sister Shaimaa Selim denies.(HT Photo)
Doctors say Eman’s condition has improved by 70%, which her sister Shaimaa Selim denies.(HT Photo)
Updated on Apr 26, 2017 12:04 PM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | ByHT Correspondent

The spat between the sister of 36-year-old Eman Ahmed and doctors at Mumbai’s Saifee Hospital seems to have turned uglier, with the Egyptian’s doctors saying they would no longer attend to her.

What are they fighting over? We break it down for you:

Eman’s health

What doctors say: Eman spoke four sentences in Arabic – for the first time in years – after a speech therapy session on Tuesday. The CT scan report proves she has not suffered a stroke since arriving at Saifee Hospital.

What her sister says: Eman has been critical for one-and-half months and she has been put on massive medication to stop her brain activity. Her face and hand are bluish.

The amount of weight Eman has lost

What doctors say: Eman has lost 333kg since she arrived in Mumbai on February 15 for treatment.

What her sister says: I don’t think she has lost more than 60 kg.

If Eman is fit enough to take a flight back home

What doctors say: Eman’s condition has improved by ‘70%’ compared to her health before treatment. She is ‘medically fit’ to take a flight back home. She needs rehabilitation and her medications need to be continued, which can be done at home, said Dr Aparna Govil Bhasker.

What her sister says: Eman is very sick. She suffered thrombosis 10 days ago. It’s the second time that has happened after she got here. She is being fed through a feeding tube, owing to which she’s not able to talk

Getting a second opinion

What doctors say: Eman’s sister Shaimaa Selim refused to take prior permissions before she called the doctor. To get a second opinion, there is an application form, which Selim refused to sign. So, we didn’t allow the doctor from Egypt to examine her, said Dr Bhasker.

What her sister says: A doctor who had travelled from Egypt to examine Eman was not allowed to see her.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Delhi reported 393 new Covid-19 cases on Tuesday.

    Delhi reports 393 new Covid-19 cases, 2 deaths; minor dip in positivity rate

    The national capital on Tuesday reported 393 new Covid-19 infections in the last 24 hours, the Delhi government health bulletin stated. The figures were 16 more than Monday's tally. Delhi reported two deaths due to the contagious virus, the health bulletin read. On Monday, the positivity rate had stood at 3.37 per cent. The capital had on Sunday logged 613 Covid cases with a positivity rate of 2.74 percent and three more deaths.

  • The grandfather was told by the applicant that his grandson had caused injury to a girl and that the youngster was ill-cultured and there were no chances of reformation as he was from the slums (HT File)

    HC refuses pre-arrest bail to school chairman accused of abetting student’s suicide

    Mumbai The Bombay high court (HC) recently refused anticipatory bail to a school chairman, who also happened to be the member of the school's disciplinary committee, whose tirade resulted in a student's suicide. The chairman was booked after the student took the drastic step, as he was berated and abused by the applicant in front of a teacher. HC rejected his pre-arrest bail plea, observing that his custodial interrogation was necessary.

  • BJP leader Devendra Fadnavis HT File Photo

    Sena likens Fadnavis to Vibhishan, calls his Ram bhakti superficial; are you Ravana, asks BJP

    Shiv Sena on Tuesday took on leader of opposition Devendra Fadnavis over his recent address to north Indians, saying his Ram bhakti was superficial and that he behaved like Vibhishan (younger brother of Ravana). An editorial in Sena mouthpiece Saamana said till Shiv Sena and the Thackerays were there, nobody could “bite off” Mumbai and Vidarbha from Maharashtra. The editorial said when Lord Ram was in exile, he resided in Panchvati, Nashik, and Ramtek, Nagpur.

  • A Congress supporter holds the party flag on the concluding day of the party's Nav Sankalp Chintan Shivir, in Udaipur on Sunday (ANI)

    Rajasthan Congress asks district units to comply with 50% youth quota. Minister disagrees

    The Rajasthan Congress on Tuesday told party leaders to ensure that 50% of office-bearers at the district level and below were below 50 years of age in compliance with the youth quota introduced in the party's Udaipur Chintan Shivir's declaration. The Rajasthan Congress appointed district presidents in 13 of the state's 38 districts in December last. Party leaders said district presidents of the remaining 25 districts will be appointed within the next two months.

  • A special POCSO court on Tuesday sentenced a 65-year-old man to rigorous life imprisonment for raping a minor girl in 2018. (HT FILE PHOTO.)

    Bihar court awards life term to 65-year-old for raping minor

    Darbhanga: A special POCSO court on Tuesday sentenced a 65-year-old man to rigorous life imprisonment for raping a minor girl in 2018. The convict will have to undergo a jail term for as long as he lives. Special judge Binay Shanker handed a life term to the convict, a tuition teacher, who had raped the girl, then 9 years old, on July 17, 2018. The crime had taken place under Hayaghat police station limits.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Tuesday, May 17, 2022