People’s power versus political opportunism

The BJP, which had been able to form governments even when it was not the single largest party, has simply not been able to do so in Maharashtra
Common people pack a political punch through their right to vote.(HT Photo)
Common people pack a political punch through their right to vote.(HT Photo)
Published on Nov 06, 2019 12:10 AM IST
Copy Link
Hindustan Times | By, Mumbai

Indian democracy always has a manner of course correction that could be both unbelievable and uplifting. The Maharashtra Assembly election results have given us another glimpse into the incredible manner in which the powerless people can prove to be more powerful than the high and mighty, sometimes even without compelling reasons.

Nearly a dozen days after the results, this becomes more obvious as the BJP, which had been able to form governments even when it was not the single largest party in the Assembly of a given state, has simply not been able to do so in Maharashtra, despite winning the elections. By now it should have been a cakewalk for it to get newly elected legislators from both the Shiv Sena and the Congress and NCP or even the substantial number of independents to, well, walk across the floor and into the arms of the ruling dispensation. Indeed, for at least the past couple of days, there has been heavy speculation on social media that at least 20 MLAs each from the Sena, Congress and NCP are ready for it. So why has it not happened so far?

This is where the people’s power kicks in. Amid rumours of defections from these parties are also reports that no legislator wants to risk losing his newly acquired hard won seat as was foolishly done by former NCP MP Udayanraje Bhosale. He quit the party in less than four months after a hard fought election and believed it would be a child’s play to win it back by recontesting on a BJP ticket. There was absolutely no reason why he should have quit the NCP, but for sheer opportunism and still less reason why he should have lost. The NCP could not even find a charismatic enough candidate to take on the 14th direct descendent of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj at the bypolls to the Satara seat and had to pull out a former bureaucrat and governor out of semi-retirement to take on Bhosale, who had the top leadership of the BJP campaigning for him extensively. But Shriniwas Patil’s large margin of victory despite that was stunning.

It reminded me of a story that former Prime Minister PV Narasimha Rao narrated in his book ‘The Insider’, said to be a fictionalised biography. He recounts the incident of the Congress putting up an impoverished freedom fighter for the legislative council polls in Andhra Pradesh against some moneybags who lures away the voting MLAs, sequesters them in a five-star hotel for 10 days and then buses them into the Assembly building at the last minute, so they can vote for him without the Congress leaders having enough time to persuade them otherwise. But when the first round results were declared, the freedom fighter simply fainted – he had to be rushed to hospital and the poll process halted until he recovered and returned to the counting hall.

For, expecting to lose, he had won five more votes than the stipulated number necessary for a victory. It turned out that all MLAs, despite their wining and dining, had decided against voting for the moneybags precisely because they thought he could use that wealth to contest the Assembly elections next time around and buy voters in their constituencies. It was safer not to empower him and elect a poor freedom fighter interested only in social work, thus posing no challenge to them in the future. Years later, the Satara result not just similarly defeated political opportunism and restored grassroots democracy, but also instilled a healthy fear in potential defectors, amid reports that leaders of all political parties, including the Shiv Sena, have come to a tacit, behind scenes understanding that were any of their legislators to defect, the other parties will not put up any candidate against the wronged party. With the BJP failing to cross the halfway mark against a completely devastated and fractious opposition, those likely to be poached are afraid they will not stand a chance against the combined opposition strength, in addition to incurring the kind of ire of the people that Bhosale did at his bypoll. Unlike those who quit the Congress and the NCP to join the BJP before the polls, they are at the start of their term and don’t want to risk frittering away their good fortunes so soon.

So our powerless common people do pack a political punch and they are all you need to get our skewered democracy back on its feet, one could say!


    I wonder if the Sena and the AIMIM know that Bal Thackeray was the first person ever in India to lose his voting rights and that to contest elections for hate speeches he had made during a 1987 byelection to Vile Parle.

Close Story

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • The IAS officer will be the fourth woman to occupy the post.

    CM Bommai names Vandita Sharma as Karnataka's new chief secretary

    The Karnataka government on Friday appointed senior IAS officer Vandita Sharma as the state's new chief secretary. Sharma, a 1986-batch IAS officer, is currently additional chief secretary and development commissioner. She will succeed P Ravi Kumar, who will retire on May 31. The senior IAS officer will be in office till November 2023. Hailing from Punjab, Vandita Sharma holds an undergraduate degree in Sociology and a post-graduate degree in English.

  • In a video message to the Sikh community on the 416th anniversary of Gurgaddi Diwas (anointment anniversary) of the sixth Sikh master, Guru Hargobind, on May 23, the Akal Takht jathedar had said: Every Sikh should try to keep licensed weapons, because the time that is coming, and the circumstances which are going to prevail, demand it. (HT file photo)

    Days after his remark over weapons, Punjab govt withdraws Akal Takht jathedar’s security

    Five days after the Akal Takht acting jathedar asked Sikhs to keep a licensed weapon in view of the “uncertain times”; a remark that did not go down well with chief minister Bhagwant Mann; the Punjab government withdrew half of Giani Harpreet Singh's security on Saturday. He, however, did not explain what circumstances he was referring to.

  • The syndicate of illegal coal suppliers caused tax losses worth <span class='webrupee'>₹</span>25 crore. (Representational Image)

    Illegal coal suppliers syndicate operating through bogus firm busted in Bihar

    The commercial taxes department has busted a syndicate supplying coal mined illegally to firms both in Bihar and Jharkhand, officials said. The syndicate operated through a bogus firm based in Madhubani making a transaction of 73 crore causing tax losses worth 25 crore, they said. Investigations have revealed that the bogus firm was owned by one rural woman, who had no knowledge of the activities of the firm.

  • The former Chief Minister was reacting to PM Modi lashing out at family-run political parties in Hyderabad on Thursday, saying 'parivaarvad' is democracy's "greatest enemy" in the country. (ANI File)

    HD Kumaraswamy: PM Modi's main goal is to root out regional political parties

    Prime Minister Narendra Modi's was reacting to Modi lashing out at family-run political parties in Hyderabad on Thursday, saying 'parivaarvad' is democracy's "greatest enemy" in the country. The comments have come while attempts are on to revive the third front with no BJP or Congress, and Telangana Chief Minister K Chandrasekhar Rao met former Prime Minister H D Deve Gowda, and jD (S) leader H D Kumaraswamy here on Thursday. They are said to have held discussions in this regard.

  • The former Karnataka CM was speaking on the controversy over a lesson regarding RSS founder Keshav Baliram Hedgewar in school textbooks. (HT Photo)

    Siddaramaiah: Are RSS members 'native Indians', 'Dravidians', or 'Aryans'?

    Targeting the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, senior Karnataka Congress leader Siddaramaiah on Friday questioned whether those who belonged to the outfit were "native Indians", "Dravidians" or "Aryans". The Leader of Opposition in the Karnataka Assembly also blamed the lack of unity within Indian society for the invasion of Mughals and British and their rule for a long period.

Story Saved
Saved Articles
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Saturday, May 28, 2022