Don’t be overly critical of Udta Punjab: HC

Published on Jun 11, 2016 12:31 AM IST
A bench of judges SC Dharma-dhikari and Shalini Phansalkar-Joshi observed that the Shahid Kapoor-starrer, Udta Punjab, did not prima facie appear to glorify drug abuse, one of the main contentions of the censor board seeking several cuts to the film co-produced by Bollywood showman Anurag Kashyap.
Bollywood film Udta Punjab actors Shahid Kapoor and Alia Bhatt at a press conference in Mumbai.(AP)
Bollywood film Udta Punjab actors Shahid Kapoor and Alia Bhatt at a press conference in Mumbai.(AP)
Hindustan Times | By, Mumbai

The Bombay high court came down heavily on the censor board on Friday, saying it was “overly critical” of a controversial drug-themed film, but also asked its producers to delete a potentially offensive scene and tone down expletives.

A bench of judges SC Dharma-dhikari and Shalini Phansalkar-Joshi observed that the Shahid Kapoor-starrer, Udta Punjab, did not prima facie appear to glorify drug abuse, one of the main contentions of the censor board seeking several cuts to the film co-produced by Bollywood showman Anurag Kashyap. “If the movie is glorifying use of drugs then ban the entire movie,” the court said.

Read: ‘Udta Punjab’ flies into row over co-producer’s AAP-link

The bench said it will pass an order on Monday on the other cuts suggested by the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) which has triggered a debate on creative freedom amid allegations of political interference.

Assembly polls are due in Punjab early next year and the AAP and Congress have accused the BJP of influencing the censor board to hide the menace of drug abuse that has allegedly crippled a generation in the state. The BJP is a partner of the SAD in Punjab’s ruling alliance.

The controversy has seen almost all of Bollywood come out to oppose the notoriously sensitive censor board, which blocked the release of a toned-down version of “Fifty Shades of Grey” last year and deemed two James Bond kissing scenes unsuitable for an Indian audience.

“Everybody has a choice. Let (the) people decide whether a movie is good or bad…Handover the remote to people…let them decide what to watch and when to switch off, whether it is television or cinema,” the Bombay high court judges said.

“If they (film producers) produce bad movies, they will suffer in the long run.” At the same time, the judges asked the producers Phantom Films to delete a scene showing the lead character urinating in public and also told him to tone down expletives and vulgar scenes.

The court was critical of the CBFC’s direction to delete any reference to Punjab, saying “the crux of the film will be lost”.

“If the idea of the maker is to be critical of a place or person then that place or person will have to be shown,” the bench said.

But the judges agreed with the board’s suggestion of deleting a scene “where a character is shown scratching a body part in a graphic manner”.

“This need not be shown in any form. Similarly, for all the cuss words used, a disclaimer can be displayed. Is it really necessary for a creative person to rely on expletives? You have to tone it down a bit,” justice Dharmadhikari said.

The judges also felt that movies do not attract crowds for their use of abusive language but the long lasting creative impact they make.

“In this age only those movies having a strong content and script line do well and just using expletives will not work for the movie, and hence the CBFC need not be overly critical.”

(With agency inputs)

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
Close Story
QUICKREADS

Less time to read?

Try Quickreads

  • Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde on Wednesday ordered a probe by the state police’s Crime Investigation Department (CID) into the death of former MLC and prominent Maratha quota leader Vinayak Mete in a road accident (HT FILE PHOTO)

    CID to probe ex-MLC Vinayak Mete’s death in road accident

    Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde on Wednesday ordered a probe by the state police's Crime Investigation Department into the death of former MLC and prominent Maratha quota leader Vinayak Mete in a road accident, said an official. Mete (52), who headed the Maratha outfit Shiv Sangram Sanghatna, was killed after a vehicle hit his car on the Mumbai-Pune Expressway on Sunday last.

  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi interacts with Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin during a meeting, in New Delhi.

    Tamil Nadu CM MK Stalin calls on PM Modi, deliberates key issues

    Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M K Stalin on Wednesday called on Prime Minister Narendra Modi and discussed state-specific development issues with him. Stalin called on President Droupadi Murmu and Vice President Jagdeep Dhankar and described the meeting, a courtesy visit, as satisfactory. The Chief Minister said he thanked Modi for having inaugurated the 44th FIDE Chess Olympiad in Chennai. He spoke over phone to Congress party's top leader Sonia Gandhi and enquired about her health.

  • The demise of Shiv Sangram party leader Vinayak Mete in an accident on the Pune-Mumbai expressway on Sunday has put the spotlight on the ‘Mrutyunjay Doot’ initiative launched by the Maharashtra highway police (HT FILE PHOTO)

    Mrutyunjay Doots save over 1,000 lives between March 2021 & July 2022

    The demise of Shiv Sangram party leader Vinayak Mete in an accident on the Pune-Mumbai expressway on Sunday has put the spotlight on the 'Mrutyunjay Doot' initiative launched by the Maharashtra highway police on March 1, 2021 to offer immediate help to victims of accidents on state and national highways within the golden hour (first hour after a road accident with casualties) to increase their chances of survival.

  • Students of New English School sang the Indian National Anthem at 11am at Tilak road campus on Wednesday. (Ravindra Joshi/HT PHOTO)

    Mass singing of National Anthem in Pune

    Many in Pune including students, government employees and corporate staff participated in singing the national anthem on Wednesday following an appeal by the state government. The tourism and cultural affairs secretary Saurabh Vijay on Monday issued the government resolution. According to the government resolution, participation is mandatory for government and private schools, colleges, educational institutes, university teachers and students. It is expected to sing the collective anthem from 11 am to 11.01 am.

  • The state government has rolled out the draft policy that may get the cabinet’s nod very soon as the current solar policy (notified in 2017) has completed its five-year term. (Pic for representation)

    UP to develop 20 solar cities in the next five years

    LUCKNOW Uttar Pradesh's proposed Solar Energy Policy-2022 seeks to meet an ambitious target of producing 16,000 mw renewable power by 2026-27, among other things, and developing 20 cities comprising 10 lakh households as 'solar cities' over the next five years. Under the policy, 20 cities will be developed as 'solar cities' covering 10 lakh residential households with solar rooftop installations across the state in five years.

SHARE
Story Saved
×
Saved Articles
Following
My Reads
Sign out
New Delhi 0C
Wednesday, August 17, 2022
Start 15 Days Free Trial Subscribe Now