HT Image
HT Image

But can you handle the truth?

When the Minister of State for Home unfailingly points to a ‘foreign hand’ each and every time, without a blink of the eye, do we wonder whether he's lying? Barkha Dutt asks.
By Third eye | Barkha Dutt | None
UPDATED ON JUL 05, 2008 01:24 PM IST

One of the more curious and complex criticisms thrown at the media — for how we reported the murder of 14-year old Aarushi Talwar — was to do with why we had believed the police.

On a recent television debate, participating journalists already knew they would soon be guillotined by public anger. But the question that had them spluttering in angry incoherence went something like this: ‘So what if the UP Police officially declared that they had caught the killers. Why didn’t the media report the police statements with scepticism and disbelief?’ Media representatives argued — weakly, in some cases — that once people in authority or uniform went on record to make an accusation, it wasn’t put through a lie detector before being broadcast. This wasn’t about salacious leaks and whispered, underhand gossip about so-called sexual promiscuity, we argued. This was the Police — ON RECORD! Why were we wrong to tell it as it was being told to us? It took a retired cop to concede — and he did it without a trace of irony or embarrassment — that “public and political pressure” could sometimes compel men like him to embellish, exaggerate and, yes, even ‘fabricate the truth’. He asked for our empathy, as we stared at him in disbelief.

But should we have been so surprised? Was he telling us something that every hard-boiled reporter doesn’t already know? Or were we just stunned at his willingness to be so brazen, and in this case, entirely truthful?

In a few months, the murders of a perky little girl called Aarushi and a quiet middle-aged man named Hemraj will fade from the front pages of our minds. We may never even know who killed them. But the murders have held up a mirror to all our wobbly, awkward, ugly bits — the dimensions we try so hard to disguise. Much has already been said about the sensationalism of a greedy, hyperventilating television industry; about a potential, subconscious class bias in the reportage, and about the idiotic bungling and hideous sexism of the Uttar Pradesh cops.

But what about another disconcerting, inconvenient truth that the murders have revealed: the State can and does lie to its people.

And while this time we have slammed the media for not being more cynical about what the police told us, here’s the truth. As a people, we only permit interrogation of certain institutions when it doesn’t interfere with our pre-conceived notions of fact and fiction. We are willing to be sceptical only if our belief system is allowed to remain intact. We always need and cling to the comfort of some of our collective fables and fairy tales.

So, we are quite happy to demand more of our journalists and police officers when it comes to these double murders. But what if this were all happening, not in Noida, but in Kashmir or Manipur? What if an army officer was guilty of rape and murder or a police officer was caught dressing up a murder as an encounter? Would we still be outraged? Of course not. Instead, chances are that the journalists reporting those stories would get branded ‘anti-national’, ‘unpatriotic’ and unmindful of the struggles of our security forces.

Think about all the times that bombs have ripped through our cities, tearing at our hearts and our sense of safety. When the grim-faced men go on television and release sketches of suspects along with funny-sounding acronyms of the terrorist groups they supposedly belong to, do we ever wonder whether we are being fed fabrications? When the Minister of State for Home unfailingly points to a ‘foreign hand’ each and every time, without a blink of the eye, do we wonder whether he's lying? Do we demand to know how it is that so many details are available with our cops and our sleuths just minutes after a terrorist strike? No, we don’t. Instead, we faithfully and breathlessly report every tiny morsel tossed at us, as if it were a full meal, instead of a mere crumb of information. And I’m pretty sure that if the media chose that moment to question the veracity of what the State was saying-you, our viewers and readers would never forgive us. Instead you would call us ‘irresponsible and sensationalist’ — exactly the same adjectives, you employ to describe our reportage of the Aarushi murder.

As a people we must ask ourselves one question: do we really have the appetite for unvarnished truth? Or is this a selective menu where only some things are palatable to us?

Seven years ago, the mass killings of 40 Sikhs in a remote village of Kashmir caught international headlines. Bill Clinton was visiting India and the government obviously needed to appear strong and in control. The Home Secretary went on record to say that the five ‘terrorists’ who had killed the villagers had been caught and ‘eliminated’. Many months of mass protests later, the terrorists turned out to be innocent civilians drawn at random by a harried security force and then shot in cold blood, so that the case could be closed. Till this date, not only do those security officials remain unpunished; but we still don’t know who actually killed the Sikhs of Chittisinghpora. But to even ask the question is to invite mostly indifference or contemptuous anger in the Indian public.

Yes, conflict zones and acts of terrorism possibly throw up different and much more complex scenarios than ‘routine’ city crimes do. That said, when we demand an ethical code of conduct of the institutions that define our democracy — the media, the army, the police, the judiciary — the moral code must hold, no matter what the context.

We have long known that the camera can lie. Now we must accept, so can the State.

Barkha Dutt is Group Editor, English News, NDTV

SHARE THIS ARTICLE ON
app
Close
Representational Image.
Representational Image.

Uttarakhand assembly polls a yr away, BJP starts prep; Cong faces infighting

By HT Correspondent | Edited by Smriti Sinha
UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 05:12 PM IST
Uttarakhand BJP president Bansidhar Bhagat has formed a five-member committee under the leadership of Rajya Sabha member Naresh Bansal for preparing a road map for the 2022 elections
Close
Bharatiya Janata Party leader Ram Kadam looks on as his supporters blacken the faces of actors on the poster of Amazon Prime Video's web series Tandav during a protest in Mumbai on Monday.(ANI)
Bharatiya Janata Party leader Ram Kadam looks on as his supporters blacken the faces of actors on the poster of Amazon Prime Video's web series Tandav during a protest in Mumbai on Monday.(ANI)

Tandav over Tandav: Why Amazon’s political drama ignited a firestorm

Reported by Aditi PrasadEdited by Meenakshi Ray, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 05:12 PM IST
The controversy over Tandav once again raises the age-old debate about freedom of expression versus moral policing and censorship.
Close
Representational image. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Representational image. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

BSF constable kills self with service rifle in Tripura

By Priyanka Deb Barman
UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 05:08 PM IST
A Border Security Force constable allegedly shot himself with his service rifle in Khowai District of
Close
BJP's Shahnawaz Hussain (left) will replace Sushil Modi in the legislative council after the latter's election to the Rajya Sabha while VIP chief Mukesh Sahni (right) will replace Vinod Narayan Jha who had won the assembly election.(HT PHOTO)
BJP's Shahnawaz Hussain (left) will replace Sushil Modi in the legislative council after the latter's election to the Rajya Sabha while VIP chief Mukesh Sahni (right) will replace Vinod Narayan Jha who had won the assembly election.(HT PHOTO)

Shahnawaz Hussain, Mukesh Sahni set to become Bihar MLCs unopposed

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 05:00 PM IST
  • No other person has filed nomination against Shahnawaz Hussain and Mukesh Sani in view of the obvious majority of the National Democratic Alliance in the state legislature
Close
A teacher takes a class in a Delhi school. Schools in the national capital reopened for students of classes 10 and 12 on Monday. (PTI)
A teacher takes a class in a Delhi school. Schools in the national capital reopened for students of classes 10 and 12 on Monday. (PTI)

Scale down deployment of teachers on Covid-19 duty: Delhi dy CM Manish Sisodia

UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:54 PM IST
As schools in the Capital reopened, several principals had expressed concerns of managing classes as teachers remained deployed on Covid-19 duty
Close
Bharatiya Janata Party leader Ram Kadam and supporters blackening the face of actors of Amazon Web Series Tandava's poster during a protest in Mumbai.(ANI Photo)
Bharatiya Janata Party leader Ram Kadam and supporters blackening the face of actors of Amazon Web Series Tandava's poster during a protest in Mumbai.(ANI Photo)

News updates from Hindustan Times: FIR against makers of web series Tandav

By hindustantimes.com
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:52 PM IST
Here are today’s top news, analysis, and opinion. Know all about the latest news and other news updates from Hindustan Times
Close
Many lawyers practicing in district courts welcomed the decision and said that it will heal the lawyers of trial court who had suffered financially due to limited hearing in the courts.(HT archive)
Many lawyers practicing in district courts welcomed the decision and said that it will heal the lawyers of trial court who had suffered financially due to limited hearing in the courts.(HT archive)

Physical hearing on alternate basis resumes in Delhi district courts

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:51 PM IST
The subordinate Courts have also been permitted to record evidence (except in those cases where the accused is in custody) while scrupulously adhering to the norms of social distancing when holding Courts physically.
Close
Arrested computer hacker and cyber criminal with handcuffs, close up of hands (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Arrested computer hacker and cyber criminal with handcuffs, close up of hands (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Man arrested for running fictitious firms to aid businesses evade GST: Officials

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:47 PM IST
Investigation conducted so far has revealed 46 firms to be fictitious which were being controlled by Kumar and his associate.
Close
Taking note of the submission, the court disposed of the petition as not pressed.(HT File Photo)
Taking note of the submission, the court disposed of the petition as not pressed.(HT File Photo)

Amitabh Bachchan voice removed from Covid-19 awareness caller tune: HC told

PTI, New Delhi
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:39 PM IST
The submission was made before a bench of Chief Justice D N Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh by the petitioner who said that with the removal of the actor's voice from the caller tune his plea has become infructuous.
Close
Tandav has a big star cast with actor Saif Ali Khan playing one of the lead roles. (File photo)
Tandav has a big star cast with actor Saif Ali Khan playing one of the lead roles. (File photo)

FIR registered in UP against makers of web series ‘Tandav’

By HT Correspondents | Edited by Smriti Sinha
UPDATED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:41 PM IST
A case has also been registered against the producer of web series ‘Mirzapur’ and Amazon Prime for hurting religious sentiments and social beliefs in Mirzapur district of eastern UP
Close
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) volunteers perform a salute towards the RSS flag. (Representational photo/HT)
Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) volunteers perform a salute towards the RSS flag. (Representational photo/HT)

RSS decision-making body to hold annual meet in Bengaluru

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:13 PM IST
The annual meeting, which will have in attendance the RSS brass and leaders of its 40-plus affiliates including the Bharatiya Janata Party president, was cancelled last year on account of the pandemic
Close
Union minister Nitin Gadkari interacts with media after a meeting on the ongoing projects in Maharashtra, in Mumbai, (PTI)
Union minister Nitin Gadkari interacts with media after a meeting on the ongoing projects in Maharashtra, in Mumbai, (PTI)

Before 2025, we aim to bring down road accidents by 50%: Nitin Gadkari

ANI
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:12 PM IST
Highlighlight the achievements of the Ministry, he said, "We have achieved the target of constructing 30 kilometres of road per day. I believe that by the end of March, perhaps we will achieve the target of constructing 40 kilometres of road per day."
Close
Police said that the family has not filed any case yet.(HT representative photo )
Police said that the family has not filed any case yet.(HT representative photo )

16-year-old girl's body with throat slit found in Rajasthan's Barmer

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:10 PM IST
Family members and locals have alleged that the minor was raped, but police said it could be confirmed only after the post-mortem.
Close
Shyam Saran Negi, believed to be India's oldest voter at 103 years of age, shows his inked finger after casting vote for Panchayat elections, at Kalpa in Kinnaur.(PTI)
Shyam Saran Negi, believed to be India's oldest voter at 103 years of age, shows his inked finger after casting vote for Panchayat elections, at Kalpa in Kinnaur.(PTI)

India's first voter, ex-school teacher: Shyam Saran Negi has never missed an ele

By hindustantimes.com | Edited by Mallika Soni
PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:07 PM IST
Negi has voted in every general election since 1951 and is believed to be India's oldest voter.
Close
Representational image. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Representational image. (Getty Images/iStockphoto)

Uttarakhand: Man arrested for drowning two children in a canal

PUBLISHED ON JAN 18, 2021 04:03 PM IST
The man, who started living with a woman and her two children after her husband died two years ago, told police that he thought of the children, aged 6 and 7, as “obstacles”
Close
SHARE
Story Saved
OPEN APP